{"export":{"count":448,"exported_at":"2026-10-26T23:37:20Z","head":{"hash":"6d9366220c2ac2a053b1e3f11fd47ea162ea44a8d9a6ea3ab7a545a28eeb9239","seq":447},"keyed":false}}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"8d614ddb177249b78b22b6a6d0b272492abdfb84f88d154a42bd2c78f51ba941","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:20","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"What does the Firefighters Local 3535 MOU say about overtime?"},"prev_hash":"0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":0,"ts":1791397220.8314,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"cf9cad94235938f0c4b05775fd4f6ae7539f56b57ef472d3e7b3be0e177a5456","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:22","payload":{"intent":"policy"},"prev_hash":"8d614ddb177249b78b22b6a6d0b272492abdfb84f88d154a42bd2c78f51ba941","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":1,"ts":1791397222.6680076,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"41165b025b7e1dffaab4e85bfdc1b3ef76bc1af1d1e401527f2c756a66853e57","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:22","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"cf9cad94235938f0c4b05775fd4f6ae7539f56b57ef472d3e7b3be0e177a5456","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":2,"ts":1791397222.6702182,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f190ce1b017a0ea9f990fe3be2ac4ac58efbe2b100619f7401ec7a0dca373a26","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:22","payload":{"bargaining_units":[],"department":null,"known_departments":["admin","district","fire","management"],"named_docs":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"scope_how":"document","stated":false},"prev_hash":"41165b025b7e1dffaab4e85bfdc1b3ef76bc1af1d1e401527f2c756a66853e57","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":3,"ts":1791397222.6789849,"type":"policy.department"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"df60470dd14a35e1cf7fee3b51fb51c2b6ad277151c5ba91334c830574df506b","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:22","payload":{"candidate_docs":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"corpus_size":5,"declared":5,"department":null,"scope_how":"document"},"prev_hash":"f190ce1b017a0ea9f990fe3be2ac4ac58efbe2b100619f7401ec7a0dca373a26","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":4,"ts":1791397222.6812294,"type":"retrieval.candidates"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"ef3372a786bd5cbd503b0dc33007c7a392b5053c1ccda6bcf201da000db2d30b","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:22","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"in scope by document","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"department":null,"how":"document","named":["firefighters_local3535_mou"]},"fork":"document_scope","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule","reason":"not the document the question named"}]},"prev_hash":"df60470dd14a35e1cf7fee3b51fb51c2b6ad277151c5ba91334c830574df506b","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":5,"ts":1791397222.6827805,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f1b7d6dc4b7a0985221d6c677de44f93ae4297c89cbb6cd9f1a3fc3b449df28c","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:26","payload":{"hits":[{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","score":0.0333},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0333},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0328},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.032},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0313},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0308},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0296},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0296}],"query":"overtime"},"prev_hash":"ef3372a786bd5cbd503b0dc33007c7a392b5053c1ccda6bcf201da000db2d30b","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":6,"ts":1791397226.4026015,"type":"retrieval.hits"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"8c7b38b71ac5667d6168d04f05ebf26ef59c307590f5c6755bb498da064e6280","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:26","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"rank 1, pinned by firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:1","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the r\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"},"value":0.0333},{"detail":"rank 2","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:7:2","label":"p.7 \u00b7 B. OVERTIME","ref":{"bbox":[126.36,500.34671999999995,189.45993787200004,492.01128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"text":"B. OVERTIME"},"value":0.0333},{"detail":"rank 3","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0328},{"detail":"rank 4","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Incremen\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[141.4304564,423.66664719936,469.2488398472001,414.05279314036005],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Increments."},"value":0.032},{"detail":"rank 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:14:5","label":"p.14 \u00b7 \u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,680.53824,492.481209024,644.9245199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"text":"\u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to the highest level eligible.  Overtime earned on  "},"value":0.0313},{"detail":"rank 6","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:6","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Bargaining-unit employees are eligible to receive earned overtime in t\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[141.07002260000002,367.50661079904,495.7171106528,331.99775999999997],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Bargaining-unit employees are eligible to receive earned overtime in the form of compensatory time off. The maximum accu"},"value":0.0308},{"detail":"rank 7","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:7:7","label":"p.7 \u00b7 Central  Fire  District has established a  24-day work periad and ther\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[142.92,352.32552,516.239910504,247.22426706912006],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"text":"Central  Fire  District has established a  24-day work periad and therefore employees are entitled to FLSA-overtime for "},"value":0.0296},{"detail":"rank 8","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:7:8","label":"p.7 \u00b7 As set by the  Department of Labor, work periods for public safety emp\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,446.64552,515.879138304,369.71110845],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"text":"As set by the  Department of Labor, work periods for public safety employees can vary from seven to 28 days (section 207"},"value":0.0296}],"counts":{"chosen":8,"considered":14,"scope_docs":1,"searched":14},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"coverage":1.0,"query":"overtime","scope":["firefighters_local3535_mou"]},"fork":"clause_retrieval","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:9","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime \u2026","reason":"rank 9 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[142.13802712,655.8666107990399,513.7099673408001,552.4045199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"},"value":0.0284},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:15:10","label":"p.15 \u00b7 The Battalion Chief assigned to the Training Division will  be allowed\u2026","reason":"rank 10 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[139.68,286.69824,501.83933039999994,251.44452],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":15,"text":"The Battalion Chief assigned to the Training Division will  be allowed to take callbacks.only when he/she is off duty. T"},"value":0.0284},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:17:11","label":"p.17 \u00b7 Upon activation from standby status to duty status because of District\u2026","reason":"rank 11 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[109.08,259.254,499.680126,209.23775999999998],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":17,"text":"Upon activation from standby status to duty status because of District need, stand by pay ends and the employee Is compe"},"value":0.0273},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:23:12","label":"p.23 \u00b7 When a  bargaining unit member has received the appropriate approval t\u2026","reason":"rank 12 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[105.12,261.13816058112,503.639548416,170.44452],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":23,"text":"When a  bargaining unit member has received the appropriate approval to be absent from their scheduled shift(s) to atten"},"value":0.0268},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:7:13","label":"p.7 \u00b7 Employees who work in a  higher class in  an acting position or tempor\u2026","reason":"rank 13 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[138.5527723617,678.4012799999999,505.082966544,573.2975057002689],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"text":"Employees who work in a  higher class in  an acting position or temporary upgrade _assignment shall  have.any Out of Cla"},"value":0.024},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:16:14","label":"p.16 \u00b7 The Fire Chief may issue a  District vehicle to the  Battalion Chief a\u2026","reason":"rank 14 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[143.28,506.74248,490.67945136000003,444.04452000000003],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":16,"text":"The Fire Chief may issue a  District vehicle to the  Battalion Chief assigned to the Training Division if the employee r"},"value":0.0211}]},"prev_hash":"f1b7d6dc4b7a0985221d6c677de44f93ae4297c89cbb6cd9f1a3fc3b449df28c","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":7,"ts":1791397226.4145098,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"ce66b8c10e2fcb7f8715a8ff9c6bb0cfa82f6bebcef1ff826599b94d9a4f9443","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:34","payload":{"answer":"Quoted from p.8: Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee's 'regular rate of pay', as that term is defined under the  FLSA,  for all  the time worked or deemed to have been worked in excess of 182 hours In  a  24-day work period.  For the purpose of determining overtime, the words 'deemed to have been worked' shall  include all paid  le","coverage":1.0,"docs_used":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"lookup":false,"pinned":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"],"scope_how":"document","source":"guarded"},"prev_hash":"8c7b38b71ac5667d6168d04f05ebf26ef59c307590f5c6755bb498da064e6280","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":8,"ts":1791397234.3469434,"type":"policy.answer"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"9b53e2b7b37d18d1cfb3ab90371452158ccaec58a44142a1078bc313aaa33ed3","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:34","payload":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8},"prev_hash":"ce66b8c10e2fcb7f8715a8ff9c6bb0cfa82f6bebcef1ff826599b94d9a4f9443","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":9,"ts":1791397234.349546,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"9f9df497c9e4126fb943fb3551816ef75cb77701eb6cd68856f3881223d7cc43","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:34","payload":{"bbox":[126.36,500.34671999999995,189.45993787200004,492.01128],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7},"prev_hash":"9b53e2b7b37d18d1cfb3ab90371452158ccaec58a44142a1078bc313aaa33ed3","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":10,"ts":1791397234.351887,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"0cd7f7b35945f7dcd1c843eb4437997a583abe3b17396c6d411b536b94ba2be0","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:34","payload":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8},"prev_hash":"9f9df497c9e4126fb943fb3551816ef75cb77701eb6cd68856f3881223d7cc43","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":11,"ts":1791397234.3542156,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"c35800c41d34d5031fd8c825e0e22bdec3fc043db046bebd3255f7782e336cb4","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:34","payload":{"bbox":[141.4304564,423.66664719936,469.2488398472001,414.05279314036005],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8},"prev_hash":"0cd7f7b35945f7dcd1c843eb4437997a583abe3b17396c6d411b536b94ba2be0","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":12,"ts":1791397234.3562605,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"c526f9122950ca9e6e55536e665719371cc8e3e2ecfe07dea86af94ab610b22e","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:34","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":371,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1832,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":931,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"c35800c41d34d5031fd8c825e0e22bdec3fc043db046bebd3255f7782e336cb4","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":13,"ts":1791397234.3826194,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"fb72567aebde0d45e9d5e7327ef67dcf1e26d9c0f2017e9f9aa04f0755dceadb","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:34","payload":{"fn":"answer_policy","input_tokens":883,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":7929,"output_tokens":588,"prompt_chars":2418,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"c526f9122950ca9e6e55536e665719371cc8e3e2ecfe07dea86af94ab610b22e","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":14,"ts":1791397234.3857677,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"01c73f163bea2252929fe91f6ed0b24375147bf6858e32b0be5d983ff58f1714","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:34","payload":{"fn":"answer_policy","rule":"ground-check: model figure(s) not in retrieved clauses","source":"fallback","unverified_figures":["1.5","3535"]},"prev_hash":"fb72567aebde0d45e9d5e7327ef67dcf1e26d9c0f2017e9f9aa04f0755dceadb","query_id":"020adf73ae6c","seq":15,"ts":1791397234.390079,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"53a3b2cfa51827b49738997317def5b16cd72ceabc90fed17db1b9880ff112b5","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:34","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"Cost an 8-hour overtime shift for a Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step) with 12 years of service"},"prev_hash":"01c73f163bea2252929fe91f6ed0b24375147bf6858e32b0be5d983ff58f1714","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":16,"ts":1791397234.74487,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"dc7f75f2ba532ab3feb8bbb960f998e8efc843d50735572a8876f24e0d709c6f","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:35","payload":{"intent":"costing"},"prev_hash":"53a3b2cfa51827b49738997317def5b16cd72ceabc90fed17db1b9880ff112b5","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":17,"ts":1791397235.6865008,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"296fe9cddd0a2ee992711eb5069a23316cf6dd4dd4e724a07132b9ac7d5d00e6","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:35","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"dc7f75f2ba532ab3feb8bbb960f998e8efc843d50735572a8876f24e0d709c6f","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":18,"ts":1791397235.6897533,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f400e3fa8d660eb6108c66cd797722a20bd74c0e96d4558e037c90858d01e154","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"date":"","holiday_weekday":"","hours":8.0,"pay_type":"overtime","question_facts":{"years_of_service":{"source":"from the question, unverified \u2014 not a roster field","value":12.0}},"source":"claude","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"years_of_service":12.0},"prev_hash":"296fe9cddd0a2ee992711eb5069a23316cf6dd4dd4e724a07132b9ac7d5d00e6","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":19,"ts":1791397237.1923828,"type":"llm.parse_intent"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"6a8cd86b5ff5cb1fbedfa578305dc2dfd336a68c32700b510855aa2396976fef","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"named in the question","id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":13},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"subject","rejected":[{"id":"roster:Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","label":"Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Apparatus Technician, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Division Chief (top step)","label":"Division Chief (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Division Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=chief-officers not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Marshal (top step)","label":"Fire Marshal (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Marshal, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=management not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Analyst (top step)","label":"Administrative Analyst (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Analyst, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Assistant (top step)","label":"Administrative Assistant (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Assistant, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Inspector (top step)","label":"Fire Inspector (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Inspector, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"}]},"prev_hash":"f400e3fa8d660eb6108c66cd797722a20bd74c0e96d4558e037c90858d01e154","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":20,"ts":1791397237.19938,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"e42580d91de2770ab1fa8a249357398e615674a00b985694835318354885ec79","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"adapter":"csv","bargaining_units":["firefighters-local-3535"],"data_sha256":"1cfcfdfed61c7a854330452d40bff756dfc9645a4bca55fb715821ba59bff2a4","fields":["classification","department","rank","base_hourly","shift","bargaining_unit","name"],"records":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","base_hourly":53.4,"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","department":"fire","name":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","rank":"Firefighter/Paramedic","shift":"Suppression"}],"rows":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"shift_date":null},"prev_hash":"6a8cd86b5ff5cb1fbedfa578305dc2dfd336a68c32700b510855aa2396976fef","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":21,"ts":1791397237.2032707,"type":"data.read"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"1467dc732e3509b02eed8b14480db44d261779893788d677d9c0f210736cc0fc","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"checks":[{"agree":true,"deterministic":8.0,"field":"hours","model":8.0},{"agree":true,"deterministic":"overtime","field":"pay_type","model":null}],"date_iso":null,"date_note":"no date given","hours":8.0,"parsed_via":"claude","pay_type":"overtime","read_as":"8 h \u00b7 overtime \u00b7 Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step) \u00b7 no date given \u00b7 12 years of service (from the question)","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"years_note":null,"years_of_service":12.0},"prev_hash":"e42580d91de2770ab1fa8a249357398e615674a00b985694835318354885ec79","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":22,"ts":1791397237.2064588,"type":"chat.interpretation"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f895ea8ebd2679bc7794762096a2a6482f05389a3b915d272990b092967a07e0","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","date":null,"matched":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","effective_end":"2028-12-31","effective_start":"2025-12-20","mou_version":"L3535-2025","why":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only"}],"reason":"resolved by governance: units ['firefighters-local-3535'] + date None -> MOU(s) ['firefighters_local3535_mou']","resolved":true,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"units":["firefighters-local-3535"]},"prev_hash":"1467dc732e3509b02eed8b14480db44d261779893788d677d9c0f210736cc0fc","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":23,"ts":1791397237.2104573,"type":"governance.resolve"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"06b771c4f78e159022d1d432720c4557e1bf764aebfc9bafd0b3fcc759fff580","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"date":null,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"governance","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters)","reason":"unit admin-group \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter)","reason":"unit management \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028","reason":"unit chief-officers \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)","reason":"doc_type salary-schedule is not an MOU or amendment"}]},"prev_hash":"f895ea8ebd2679bc7794762096a2a6482f05389a3b915d272990b092967a07e0","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":24,"ts":1791397237.2126193,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"d46d29dfd42170303f5ff856b58a779cfcef74f807b302ef30e7a135c6bca079","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"topic overtime, currency, base","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular ","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Ra"}},{"detail":"topic longevity, currency, differential","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","label":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local 3535 MOU, Longevity Pay, p.12); corrobo"}}],"counts":{"chosen":2,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"asked":["overtime"],"before_pay_type":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"rule_filter","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:bereavement_shifts","label":"Three (3) shifts of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immedi","reason":"result_type shifts, costing wants currency","ref":{"bbox":[107.28,189.498,505.259,167.118],"clause":"XIV","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":21,"text":"Three (3) shifts of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate family (Local 3535 MOU, Article XIV,"}},{"id":"chief_officers_mou:bereavement_hours","label":"40 hours of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate fami","reason":"cites Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028, not a governing document","ref":{"bbox":[90.7,575.8,526.7,552.8],"clause":"Bereavement Leave (p.14)","doc_id":"chief_officers_mou","page":14,"text":"40 hours of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate family (Chief Officers MOU, Bereavement Leav"}},{"id":"admin_group_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"One and one-half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked in excess of the","reason":"cites Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters), not a governing document","ref":{"bbox":[104.4,137.7,509.6,113.8],"clause":"Overtime (p.6)","doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":6,"text":"One and one-half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked in excess of the normal schedule (Admin Group MOU, Overt"}}]},"prev_hash":"06b771c4f78e159022d1d432720c4557e1bf764aebfc9bafd0b3fcc759fff580","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":25,"ts":1791397237.2162046,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"41fc6ca63829a878d9f5ecf2cdf414f6b9697c82919954e332091a337daa9972","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"approved by analyst (hand-authored 2026-10-07, longevity clause p.12; reviewed against p.38 column) on 2026-10-07","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","label":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local 3535 MOU, Longevity Pay, p.12); corrobo"}},{"detail":"approved by kenny on 2026-07-18","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular ","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Ra"}}],"counts":{"chosen":2,"considered":2},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","total":656.82,"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"rule_select","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"d46d29dfd42170303f5ff856b58a779cfcef74f807b302ef30e7a135c6bca079","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":26,"ts":1791397237.2189753,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"68b02550239720037195d02f3fa743fc63fbec28b05b15c1f410726eb835d0bc","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver kenny; verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate:multiplier","label":"multiplier: Overtime Rate (p.8)","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"multiplier","name":"multiplier","query":"premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one half times regular rate of pay","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Incremen\u2026","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[141.4304564,423.66664719936,469.2488398472001,414.05279314036005],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Increments."},"value":0.0328},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime \u2026","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.13802712,655.8666107990399,513.7099673408001,552.4045199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who is promoted to a  higher position shall have one half \u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[140.4,272.10672,486.7074593236,236.68452000000002],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who is promoted to a  higher position shall have one half of their . ac\u00e9rued CTO hours paid off at the time "},"value":0.0308},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:5","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0308}]},"prev_hash":"41fc6ca63829a878d9f5ecf2cdf414f6b9697c82919954e332091a337daa9972","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":27,"ts":1791397237.3249412,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"d9d29588fa4c7d154c79208a0793015b3ac6d784e039cdc32f4587d0f73e1365","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver kenny; verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate:regular_rate_definition","label":"regular_rate_definition: Regular Rate of Pay (p.8)","ref":{"bbox":[142.138,655.867,513.71,552.405],"clause":"Regular Rate of Pay (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"definition","name":"regular_rate_definition","query":"regular rate of pay definition overtime","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 2, Regular Rate of Pay","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.92,683.22672,245.16004550399998,675.25128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"2, Regular Rate of Pay"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the r\u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"},"value":0.0317},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:14:5","label":"p.14 \u00b7 \u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to\u2026","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,680.53824,492.481209024,644.9245199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"text":"\u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to the highest level eligible.  Overtime earned on  "},"value":0.0303}]},"prev_hash":"68b02550239720037195d02f3fa743fc63fbec28b05b15c1f410726eb835d0bc","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":28,"ts":1791397237.4142492,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"a9afe0b8920b0cd2fe4f19b686409f129f77f59b5be84b53f7ecb0a7e7400516","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"from the roster file, printed on the salary schedule","id":"roster:base_hourly:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"base_hourly = 53.4 \u2014 roster row Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","ref":{"bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"clause":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr \u00b7 MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","page":1,"text":"$53.40"},"value":53.4}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"base_hourly","pointer":{"bbox":[110.88,526.566,510.48,489.331],"clause":"Salary Schedule set forth in Appendix A (p.6)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"roster","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"d9d29588fa4c7d154c79208a0793015b3ac6d784e039cdc32f4587d0f73e1365","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":29,"ts":1791397237.4179568,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"91bbc8206786f20dc6d99a1d6231810ad6ba03e52563486f342a9cd409a4ca1d","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"question:hours","label":"hours = 8.0 \u2014 stated in the question","value":8.0}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"user","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"question","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"a9afe0b8920b0cd2fe4f19b686409f129f77f59b5be84b53f7ecb0a7e7400516","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":30,"ts":1791397237.420647,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f1630a8ffccc338169dc5cfdf869072ce3feec3e3817c10d1b94653beed0354f","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver analyst (hand-authored 2026-10-07, longevity clause p.12; reviewed against p.38 column); verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr:longevity","label":"longevity: Longevity Pay (p.12)","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"Upon completion of ten (10) years of service to the District employees shall receive a 2.5% general salary increase,  Lo"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"multiplier","name":"longevity","query":"longevity pay ten years of service","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:26:2","label":"p.26 \u00b7 Central  Legacy employees that retired on or before December 314,  202\u2026","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[125.64,560.29824,495.720142884,510.91776],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":26,"text":"Central  Legacy employees that retired on or before December 314,  2021, witha minimum of 20 years of service to the Dis"},"value":0.0328},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:12:3","label":"p.12 \u00b7 LONGEVITY PAY","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[143.9682876,290.77405861683997,222.259622984,282.04454394576004],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"LONGEVITY PAY"},"value":0.0318},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:27:4","label":"p.27 \u00b7 tn  the event of the death of a  current employee or retiree, dependen\u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[123.48,244.76976000000002,502.559917056,222.111],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":27,"text":"tn  the event of the death of a  current employee or retiree, dependents will receive the same level of coverage as outl"},"value":0.031},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:27:5","label":"p.27 \u00b7 Aminimum of 15 years of service to the District is required to be elig\u2026","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[140.04,339.894,503.63873496,289.791],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":27,"text":"Aminimum of 15 years of service to the District is required to be eligible for 75% of the amployee only rate of retiree "},"value":0.0303}]},"prev_hash":"91bbc8206786f20dc6d99a1d6231810ad6ba03e52563486f342a9cd409a4ca1d","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":31,"ts":1791397237.5371294,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f501c375f0968bfa5b820aeec107e85671fd91469ffadbdb8cb164f91a30c65b","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"question:years_of_service","label":"years_of_service = 12.0 \u2014 stated in the question","value":12.0}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"user","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"years_of_service","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","source":"question","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"f1630a8ffccc338169dc5cfdf869072ce3feec3e3817c10d1b94653beed0354f","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":32,"ts":1791397237.540329,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"3d7d8e585b3b91d89940ec4e9ca0c8592520d02fe85cd0abb6d80b38a8de746f","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"effective_base = round(effective_base * 1.025, 6) -> 54.735","inputs":{"effective_base":53.4},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":54.735},"prev_hash":"f501c375f0968bfa5b820aeec107e85671fd91469ffadbdb8cb164f91a30c65b","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":33,"ts":1791397237.5425315,"type":"rule.modifier"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"033a38ef6e49dd905c6bb1e388aa4e7bf57a0a7950a06f759166879f52bb8c6c","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"when: hours > 0 -> True (scope 2, priority 0)","inputs":{"hours":8.0},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":true},"prev_hash":"3d7d8e585b3b91d89940ec4e9ca0c8592520d02fe85cd0abb6d80b38a8de746f","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":34,"ts":1791397237.5447025,"type":"rule.selector_considered"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"e0b678d0622b2e9dd7f559a4cf1e116e9af849458ee60e89da389ceb9577609a","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"chose firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate (scope 2, priority 0); Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Rate, p.8). Reviewed and approved by the analyst against the clause text; the drafted FLSA 182/192-hour cycle rules were deliberately not approved \u2014 they model the 24-day work period, a different pay branch than a premium overtime shift.","inputs":{},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":656.82},"prev_hash":"033a38ef6e49dd905c6bb1e388aa4e7bf57a0a7950a06f759166879f52bb8c6c","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":35,"ts":1791397237.547131,"type":"rule.selector_chosen"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"b0cdb809172b4dffdc294d952569457f76ca61ed1a944100cab3bd06dfeaa721","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours = 656.82","expr":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours","inputs":{"effective_base":54.735,"hours":8.0},"line":"$53.40/hr \u00d7 1.025 \u00d7 1.5 \u00d7 8 h = $656.82","operands":[{"kind":"fact","name":"effective_base","role":"rate","source":{"bbox":[503.7,211.1,530.64,202.5],"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","column":"MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","context_bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","field":"base_hourly","kind":"schedule-cell","page":1,"row":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr","row_bbox":[51.227725982666016,522.4412994384766,739.9093627929688,134.97317504882812],"text":"$53.40","title":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)"},"unit":"hour","value":53.4},{"citation":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"char_span":[],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","doc_sha256":"b30076962d29c424864fbe8b05a048911356f7b807b3472f83104aeb921ee800","page":12,"quote_sha256":"582ed036d89a5884"},"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","source":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":12,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr"},"value":1.025},{"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":8,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"value":1.5},{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","role":"hours","source":{"kind":"question","param":"hours"},"value":8.0}],"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":656.82},"prev_hash":"e0b678d0622b2e9dd7f559a4cf1e116e9af849458ee60e89da389ceb9577609a","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":36,"ts":1791397237.5503871,"type":"rule.math"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"d015e430fdc5864777371b22c8827fa8204505a7ae1d41322bafe34466707261","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"char_span":[],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","doc_sha256":"b30076962d29c424864fbe8b05a048911356f7b807b3472f83104aeb921ee800","page":12,"quote_sha256":"582ed036d89a5884","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"},"prev_hash":"b0cdb809172b4dffdc294d952569457f76ca61ed1a944100cab3bd06dfeaa721","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":37,"ts":1791397237.5546238,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"fe35c7765ea7cd2eecc9b410c727960e03abfc17da36132ebc4e2e04400776d4","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"char_span":[],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","doc_sha256":"b30076962d29c424864fbe8b05a048911356f7b807b3472f83104aeb921ee800","page":8,"quote_sha256":"97bd147f7e3aec58","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"},"prev_hash":"d015e430fdc5864777371b22c8827fa8204505a7ae1d41322bafe34466707261","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":38,"ts":1791397237.5582397,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"954c59eae53203a0b5490206c99302bfd3e023356396e3d2791ccf249069505e","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"engine_sha256":"6538a13f34e6e99c4fd9484b93f2beb5af6892ef44bbee48304db8be797b2aa1","math":[{"expr":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours","line":"$53.40/hr \u00d7 1.025 \u00d7 1.5 \u00d7 8 h = $656.82","operands":[{"kind":"fact","name":"effective_base","role":"rate","source":{"bbox":[503.7,211.1,530.64,202.5],"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","column":"MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","context_bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","field":"base_hourly","kind":"schedule-cell","page":1,"row":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr","row_bbox":[51.227725982666016,522.4412994384766,739.9093627929688,134.97317504882812],"text":"$53.40","title":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)"},"unit":"hour","value":53.4},{"citation":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"char_span":[],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","doc_sha256":"b30076962d29c424864fbe8b05a048911356f7b807b3472f83104aeb921ee800","page":12,"quote_sha256":"582ed036d89a5884"},"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","source":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":12,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr"},"value":1.025},{"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":8,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"value":1.5},{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","role":"hours","source":{"kind":"question","param":"hours"},"value":8.0}],"subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"}],"partial":false,"result_sha256":"a00286506ebea5a734c7cf00ef87f44805a02f9683107a47947014b07a8af2e8","result_type":"currency","rules":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","sha256":"07efac20a48d41212702b810cf18f3e43daca430768105948e1b8d76cbfe4e15"},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","sha256":"f55a83eb171ba3b1fa11d358dae6a781a80cf0e7bd639fc43b922f7ca9c54c1e"}],"schema":2,"snapshot":"83845eb8ee24.json","snapshot_sha256":"4a81ec04592e416c66c848f3d1887337a9dd22c1ad250cb559580a86e7de23c4","total":656.82,"uncovered":[]},"prev_hash":"fe35c7765ea7cd2eecc9b410c727960e03abfc17da36132ebc4e2e04400776d4","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":39,"ts":1791397237.5647488,"type":"answer.snapshot"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"6d6b26a92fc4a184c0b02f34e767b3e552356617ad02cdf26113687774976211","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":391,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":900,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":970,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"954c59eae53203a0b5490206c99302bfd3e023356396e3d2791ccf249069505e","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":40,"ts":1791397237.5728374,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"28dd2ad3299c285d27d0141f325b23f6b7cc9d5074029e5ed4091365aaec9428","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:37","payload":{"fn":"parse_intent","input_tokens":431,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1492,"output_tokens":81,"prompt_chars":1033,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"6d6b26a92fc4a184c0b02f34e767b3e552356617ad02cdf26113687774976211","query_id":"83845eb8ee24","seq":41,"ts":1791397237.5760803,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"e8da801517abf70f45f2a0b53ef3dd017d640a28836c313518ab993984b39b89","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:38","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"What holidays do firefighters get?"},"prev_hash":"28dd2ad3299c285d27d0141f325b23f6b7cc9d5074029e5ed4091365aaec9428","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":42,"ts":1791397238.1724746,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"ecb79b31d3d847e3481edc5f56caa3bf62891c9d2710db044a964b3272e42579","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:38","payload":{"intent":"policy"},"prev_hash":"e8da801517abf70f45f2a0b53ef3dd017d640a28836c313518ab993984b39b89","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":43,"ts":1791397238.9402654,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"7150f065137b0f1e1d2fede2f5f1fec216171d8fe5b61978a9a023d8103da1c5","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:38","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"ecb79b31d3d847e3481edc5f56caa3bf62891c9d2710db044a964b3272e42579","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":44,"ts":1791397238.9434795,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"919b2cc12c044d079c69be5c48250fbfbc6fc7077fa18479de021d33827e5d67","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:38","payload":{"bargaining_units":["firefighters-local-3535"],"department":null,"known_departments":["admin","district","fire","management"],"named_docs":[],"scope_how":"unit","stated":false},"prev_hash":"7150f065137b0f1e1d2fede2f5f1fec216171d8fe5b61978a9a023d8103da1c5","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":45,"ts":1791397238.9557211,"type":"policy.department"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"7fc8d0081e2c06ed86fb7d3791b6591a6774119573052251e59adb6c6e087c56","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:38","payload":{"candidate_docs":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"corpus_size":5,"declared":5,"department":null,"scope_how":"unit"},"prev_hash":"919b2cc12c044d079c69be5c48250fbfbc6fc7077fa18479de021d33827e5d67","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":46,"ts":1791397238.958883,"type":"retrieval.candidates"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"ad8fc16bcbda8588da405813886f1a99a952fb3d555ad25a716e59944fe1aa7e","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:38","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"in scope by unit","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"department":null,"how":"unit","named":[]},"fork":"document_scope","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU","reason":"outside the unit scope"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU","reason":"outside the unit scope"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU","reason":"outside the unit scope"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule","reason":"outside the unit scope"}]},"prev_hash":"7fc8d0081e2c06ed86fb7d3791b6591a6774119573052251e59adb6c6e087c56","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":47,"ts":1791397238.9617941,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"d4c1078d17fa16386ae01a546e89d260b5f88ebb308ec76b28299448d1e37314","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:39","payload":{"hits":[{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":20,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0328},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":20,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0323},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":20,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0308},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":35,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0285},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":36,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0271},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":37,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0267},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":36,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.024},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":36,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0236}],"query":"holidays"},"prev_hash":"ad8fc16bcbda8588da405813886f1a99a952fb3d555ad25a716e59944fe1aa7e","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":48,"ts":1791397239.085212,"type":"retrieval.hits"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"4ac7024eb538606b26a8e37a8e33e2a3b604bb9f7a039f99a3a2afc6c1bc8003","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:39","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"rank 1","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:20:1","label":"p.20 \u00b7 Designated  Holidays are as follows: -","ref":{"bbox":[110.16,455.53824000000003,270.045321408,446.83776],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":20,"text":"Designated  Holidays are as follows: -"},"value":0.0328},{"detail":"rank 2","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:20:2","label":"p.20 \u00b7 '  Xi.  Holidays","ref":{"bbox":[102.9527723617,525.1380471992228,177.4830982982143,514.9775057002689],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":20,"text":"'  Xi.  Holidays"},"value":0.0323},{"detail":"rank 3","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:20:3","label":"p.20 \u00b7 There are  13  designated holidays (312 hours),  Compensation for holi\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[109.44,509.62248,508.32058363199997,473.83776],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":20,"text":"There are  13  designated holidays (312 hours),  Compensation for holidays will  be  paid In the pay period the holiday "},"value":0.0308},{"detail":"rank 4","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:35:4","label":"p.35 \u00b7 All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay","ref":{"bbox":[367.08,734.1517200000001,611.0505042216005,703.2208800000001],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":35,"text":"All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay"},"value":0.0285},{"detail":"rank 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:36:5","label":"p.36 \u00b7 All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay (table: 5% COLA PP Including \u2026","ref":{"bbox":[35.11994552612305,739.3926315307617,575.9816284179688,227.33984375],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":36,"text":"All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay (table: 5% COLA PP Including January 1, 2027 POSITION, Hourly, Bi-Weekly, Base "},"value":0.0271},{"detail":"rank 6","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:37:6","label":"p.37 \u00b7 All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay (table: 5% COLA PP Including \u2026","ref":{"bbox":[35.1610221862793,724.1069488525391,575.8329467773438,212.35760498046875],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":37,"text":"All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay (table: 5% COLA PP Including January 1, 2028 POSITION, Hourly, Bi-Weekly, Base "},"value":0.0267},{"detail":"rank 7","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:36:7","label":"p.36 \u00b7 All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including Januar\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[35.11994552612305,739.3926315307617,575.9816284179688,227.33984375],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":36,"text":"All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including January 1, 2027 POSITION: II | Hourly: $48.54 | Bi-Weekl"},"value":0.024},{"detail":"rank 8","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:36:8","label":"p.36 \u00b7 All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including Januar\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[35.11994552612305,739.3926315307617,575.9816284179688,227.33984375],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":36,"text":"All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including January 1, 2027 POSITION: III | Hourly: $56.07 | Bi-Week"},"value":0.0236}],"counts":{"chosen":8,"considered":14,"scope_docs":1,"searched":14},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"coverage":1.0,"query":"holidays","scope":["firefighters_local3535_mou"]},"fork":"clause_retrieval","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:36:9","label":"p.36 \u00b7 All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including Januar\u2026","reason":"rank 9 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[35.11994552612305,739.3926315307617,575.9816284179688,227.33984375],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":36,"text":"All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including January 1, 2027 POSITION: II | Hourly: $71.56 | Bi-Weekl"},"value":0.0229},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:36:10","label":"p.36 \u00b7 All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including Januar\u2026","reason":"rank 10 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[35.11994552612305,739.3926315307617,575.9816284179688,227.33984375],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":36,"text":"All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including January 1, 2027 POSITION: II | Hourly: $78.71 | Bi-Weekl"},"value":0.0228},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:36:11","label":"p.36 \u00b7 All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including Januar\u2026","reason":"rank 11 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[35.11994552612305,739.3926315307617,575.9816284179688,227.33984375],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":36,"text":"All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including January 1, 2027 POSITION: III | Hourly: $50.97 | Bi-Week"},"value":0.0227},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:36:12","label":"p.36 \u00b7 All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including Januar\u2026","reason":"rank 12 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[35.11994552612305,739.3926315307617,575.9816284179688,227.33984375],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":36,"text":"All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including January 1, 2027 POSITION: III | Hourly: $64.06 | Bi-Week"},"value":0.0226},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:36:13","label":"p.36 \u00b7 All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including Januar\u2026","reason":"rank 13 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[35.11994552612305,739.3926315307617,575.9816284179688,227.33984375],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":36,"text":"All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including January 1, 2027 POSITION: II | Hourly: $89.94 | Bi-Weekl"},"value":0.0226},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:36:14","label":"p.36 \u00b7 All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including Januar\u2026","reason":"rank 14 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[35.11994552612305,739.3926315307617,575.9816284179688,227.33984375],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":36,"text":"All Members Receive Base and Holiday Pay \u2014 5% COLA PP Including January 1, 2027 POSITION: II | Hourly: $61.01 | Bi-Weekl"},"value":0.0225}]},"prev_hash":"d4c1078d17fa16386ae01a546e89d260b5f88ebb308ec76b28299448d1e37314","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":49,"ts":1791397239.0930982,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f4266dba8c17c9d5ee882b7af4badba5d323b4da43992128da45090839798b81","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:41","payload":{"answer":"The MOU states there are 13 designated holidays (312 hours), with compensation paid in the pay period the holiday occurs at the employees' base hourly rate, and holiday compensation shall not be converted to paid leave (\u00a7Xi. Holidays). However, while the document references a list of designated holidays (\"Designated Holidays are as follows:\"), the specific names/dates of the 13 holidays are not included in the provided clauses, so I cannot identify which particular holidays they are.","coverage":1.0,"docs_used":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"lookup":false,"pinned":[],"scope_how":"unit","source":"claude"},"prev_hash":"4ac7024eb538606b26a8e37a8e33e2a3b604bb9f7a039f99a3a2afc6c1bc8003","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":50,"ts":1791397241.5946486,"type":"policy.answer"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"ea4904868c2835e1d7694a25b371d40d7eabf5400987b69d8c6bf5d7c95f7072","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:41","payload":{"bbox":[110.16,455.53824000000003,270.045321408,446.83776],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":20},"prev_hash":"f4266dba8c17c9d5ee882b7af4badba5d323b4da43992128da45090839798b81","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":51,"ts":1791397241.5974362,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"b5dafacd86f0739b7931cd53322961092211ae3551eab814b19a463f654fbbf8","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:41","payload":{"bbox":[102.9527723617,525.1380471992228,177.4830982982143,514.9775057002689],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":20},"prev_hash":"ea4904868c2835e1d7694a25b371d40d7eabf5400987b69d8c6bf5d7c95f7072","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":52,"ts":1791397241.5996637,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"c4efed300d568af70e108b2b42807d597b99d0edd101ec886122677812106c85","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:41","payload":{"bbox":[109.44,509.62248,508.32058363199997,473.83776],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":20},"prev_hash":"b5dafacd86f0739b7931cd53322961092211ae3551eab814b19a463f654fbbf8","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":53,"ts":1791397241.603421,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"d97409c192188630992587090f1a815a18a6b407cf982f05fa772f40c38de4e8","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:41","payload":{"bbox":[367.08,734.1517200000001,611.0505042216005,703.2208800000001],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":35},"prev_hash":"c4efed300d568af70e108b2b42807d597b99d0edd101ec886122677812106c85","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":54,"ts":1791397241.606569,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"f60b667f7152958fd84c0724f16d56b647649b2ec6e930b639f50a30d7b48001","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:41","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":359,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":761,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":904,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"d97409c192188630992587090f1a815a18a6b407cf982f05fa772f40c38de4e8","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":55,"ts":1791397241.6353793,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"31f7692c1a30cd44b21ebaf238fee8730fb192eebbeb17ffcd2dd5b0a887dd6b","iso":"2026-10-07T18:20:41","payload":{"fn":"answer_policy","input_tokens":859,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":2493,"output_tokens":163,"prompt_chars":1945,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"f60b667f7152958fd84c0724f16d56b647649b2ec6e930b639f50a30d7b48001","query_id":"656d897c0499","seq":56,"ts":1791397241.6405013,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"421912b2c6ada004fc209043cc66fedacffb22ad315c81de64bd087997584c00","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:51","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"How is premium overtime compensated under the Firefighters Local 3535 MOU?"},"prev_hash":"31f7692c1a30cd44b21ebaf238fee8730fb192eebbeb17ffcd2dd5b0a887dd6b","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":57,"ts":1791398451.6527922,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"39b3e2c40e88e538d76b9553845cd333be3a827132e2ee51604c0da51ec375e5","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:52","payload":{"intent":"policy"},"prev_hash":"421912b2c6ada004fc209043cc66fedacffb22ad315c81de64bd087997584c00","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":58,"ts":1791398452.4721575,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"023c3c9ba23271edaea7be9aba904a6a8b849b33bedd1f04c293884fbbdf4104","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:52","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"39b3e2c40e88e538d76b9553845cd333be3a827132e2ee51604c0da51ec375e5","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":59,"ts":1791398452.4759588,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"eb07ddca62788f7aca52d115d7e2c295e23534f682f4795b827433792fc87c9b","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:52","payload":{"bargaining_units":[],"department":null,"known_departments":["admin","district","fire","management"],"named_docs":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"scope_how":"document","stated":false},"prev_hash":"023c3c9ba23271edaea7be9aba904a6a8b849b33bedd1f04c293884fbbdf4104","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":60,"ts":1791398452.4854598,"type":"policy.department"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"8ec92c3e0c14d3b7b8528709f05b88246a94256d00e106d8e49d874bf579d9a3","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:52","payload":{"candidate_docs":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"corpus_size":5,"declared":5,"department":null,"scope_how":"document"},"prev_hash":"eb07ddca62788f7aca52d115d7e2c295e23534f682f4795b827433792fc87c9b","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":61,"ts":1791398452.4910736,"type":"retrieval.candidates"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"3a4798d6b05210ec83fe07cff834b7860008d0546dbdd8720e597c595b3d007e","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:52","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"in scope by document","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"department":null,"how":"document","named":["firefighters_local3535_mou"]},"fork":"document_scope","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule","reason":"not the document the question named"}]},"prev_hash":"8ec92c3e0c14d3b7b8528709f05b88246a94256d00e106d8e49d874bf579d9a3","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":62,"ts":1791398452.4972649,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"c493da33b050621a71efee74dd1c5bbcda3393be4db664c08d0c28e92e8f8364","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:52","payload":{"hits":[{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","score":0.0331},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.032},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0315},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0313},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0312},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":17,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0299},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0292},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":16,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0286}],"query":"premium overtime compensated"},"prev_hash":"3a4798d6b05210ec83fe07cff834b7860008d0546dbdd8720e597c595b3d007e","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":63,"ts":1791398452.736629,"type":"retrieval.hits"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"36d7e60ebcfb6f01be14d216a2c2bd48de8cb0ee374bea755346d0d3ccd678d2","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:52","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"rank 1, pinned by firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:1","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the r\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"},"value":0.0331},{"detail":"rank 2","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime \u2026","ref":{"bbox":[142.13802712,655.8666107990399,513.7099673408001,552.4045199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"},"value":0.032},{"detail":"rank 3","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0315},{"detail":"rank 4","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:7:4","label":"p.7 \u00b7 B. OVERTIME","ref":{"bbox":[126.36,500.34671999999995,189.45993787200004,492.01128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"text":"B. OVERTIME"},"value":0.0313},{"detail":"rank 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:5","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Incremen\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[141.4304564,423.66664719936,469.2488398472001,414.05279314036005],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Increments."},"value":0.0312},{"detail":"rank 6","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:17:6","label":"p.17 \u00b7 Upon activation from standby status to duty status because of District\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[109.08,259.254,499.680126,209.23775999999998],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":17,"text":"Upon activation from standby status to duty status because of District need, stand by pay ends and the employee Is compe"},"value":0.0299},{"detail":"rank 7","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:14:7","label":"p.14 \u00b7 \u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,680.53824,492.481209024,644.9245199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"text":"\u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to the highest level eligible.  Overtime earned on  "},"value":0.0292},{"detail":"rank 8","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:16:8","label":"p.16 \u00b7 If an  employee Is assigned  Duty Coverage, they will be compensated $\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[110.88,168.894,493.19975700000003,146.32452],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":16,"text":"If an  employee Is assigned  Duty Coverage, they will be compensated $550/week for the assignment."},"value":0.0286}],"counts":{"chosen":8,"considered":14,"scope_docs":1,"searched":14},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"coverage":0.71,"query":"premium overtime compensated","scope":["firefighters_local3535_mou"]},"fork":"clause_retrieval","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:7:9","label":"p.7 \u00b7 Central  Fire  District has established a  24-day work periad and ther\u2026","reason":"rank 9 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[142.92,352.32552,516.239910504,247.22426706912006],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"text":"Central  Fire  District has established a  24-day work periad and therefore employees are entitled to FLSA-overtime for "},"value":0.0285},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:6:10","label":"p.6 \u00b7 Those employees required to work out of class (upward) shall be compen\u2026","reason":"rank 10 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[144.0,229.20551999999998,523.4385373712377,96.29728],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6,"text":"Those employees required to work out of class (upward) shall be compensated at the same rate of pay that they would rece"},"value":0.0281},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:11","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Bargaining-unit employees are eligible to receive earned overtime in t\u2026","reason":"rank 11 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[141.07002260000002,367.50661079904,495.7171106528,331.99775999999997],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Bargaining-unit employees are eligible to receive earned overtime in the form of compensatory time off. The maximum accu"},"value":0.0278},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:7:12","label":"p.7 \u00b7 Employees who work in a  higher class in  an acting position or tempor\u2026","reason":"rank 12 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[138.5527723617,678.4012799999999,505.082966544,573.2975057002689],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"text":"Employees who work in a  higher class in  an acting position or temporary upgrade _assignment shall  have.any Out of Cla"},"value":0.0277},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:26:13","label":"p.26 \u00b7 Central  Legacy employees that retired on or before December 314,  202\u2026","reason":"rank 13 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[125.64,560.29824,495.720142884,510.91776],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":26,"text":"Central  Legacy employees that retired on or before December 314,  2021, witha minimum of 20 years of service to the Dis"},"value":0.0264},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:23:14","label":"p.23 \u00b7 When a  bargaining unit member has received the appropriate approval t\u2026","reason":"rank 14 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[105.12,261.13816058112,503.639548416,170.44452],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":23,"text":"When a  bargaining unit member has received the appropriate approval to be absent from their scheduled shift(s) to atten"},"value":0.0253}]},"prev_hash":"c493da33b050621a71efee74dd1c5bbcda3393be4db664c08d0c28e92e8f8364","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":64,"ts":1791398452.7408543,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"01ed9e79ce0af8ec32c3a3e3832da2bb0c15da64e5401de0e642d717043e8ad7","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:56","payload":{"answer":"Quoted from p.8: Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee's 'regular rate of pay', as that term is defined under the  FLSA,  for all  the time worked or deemed to have been worked in excess of 182 hours In  a  24-day work period.  For the purpose of determining overtime, the words 'deemed to have been worked' shall  include all paid  le","coverage":0.71,"docs_used":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"lookup":false,"pinned":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"],"scope_how":"document","source":"guarded"},"prev_hash":"36d7e60ebcfb6f01be14d216a2c2bd48de8cb0ee374bea755346d0d3ccd678d2","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":65,"ts":1791398456.3257205,"type":"policy.answer"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"b52fc41f703e4b13fafe4bcc48726e721889de46ed23e5cb5e15ac4b5f0f5697","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:56","payload":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8},"prev_hash":"01ed9e79ce0af8ec32c3a3e3832da2bb0c15da64e5401de0e642d717043e8ad7","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":66,"ts":1791398456.3283978,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"83bf6d20cc985cecdc80ef013a483fba0c79740696d424b0a6ec6dcb2308af43","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:56","payload":{"bbox":[142.13802712,655.8666107990399,513.7099673408001,552.4045199999999],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8},"prev_hash":"b52fc41f703e4b13fafe4bcc48726e721889de46ed23e5cb5e15ac4b5f0f5697","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":67,"ts":1791398456.3311982,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"640f1867849d4a9157744e66bbd3a23ba28e35222caa948a8fe32fc3ea34eaae","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:56","payload":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8},"prev_hash":"83bf6d20cc985cecdc80ef013a483fba0c79740696d424b0a6ec6dcb2308af43","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":68,"ts":1791398456.3340251,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"780708b5b54e15abc935f13ed3c2d764bf2c0c9c21655711b7477cd8a22c015e","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:56","payload":{"bbox":[126.36,500.34671999999995,189.45993787200004,492.01128],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7},"prev_hash":"640f1867849d4a9157744e66bbd3a23ba28e35222caa948a8fe32fc3ea34eaae","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":69,"ts":1791398456.3362224,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"7244b364724368fba9a21f9bfa214113bbfae6289fd455c05b8739eae6858846","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:56","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":375,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":810,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":944,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"780708b5b54e15abc935f13ed3c2d764bf2c0c9c21655711b7477cd8a22c015e","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":70,"ts":1791398456.3604116,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"b0131d354283e8a53f0b82f9b8e51feb7cb86597a5233bef421e26dbc5e69e00","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:56","payload":{"fn":"answer_policy","input_tokens":815,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":3578,"output_tokens":339,"prompt_chars":2246,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"7244b364724368fba9a21f9bfa214113bbfae6289fd455c05b8739eae6858846","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":71,"ts":1791398456.3636866,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"d51d428f7af16baa7b8fb5b67a07f14191ae70508ce19c5dc6a463fa16a387f3","iso":"2026-10-07T18:40:56","payload":{"fn":"answer_policy","rule":"ground-check: model figure(s) not in retrieved clauses","source":"fallback","unverified_figures":["1.5"]},"prev_hash":"b0131d354283e8a53f0b82f9b8e51feb7cb86597a5233bef421e26dbc5e69e00","query_id":"2dfbc1c91256","seq":72,"ts":1791398456.3675358,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"d3e77fa66701dcbc6f2b78aaf3d78c5ee8395802b5df45f70d424acd144cecc1","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:27","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"Cost an 8-hour overtime shift for a Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"},"prev_hash":"d51d428f7af16baa7b8fb5b67a07f14191ae70508ce19c5dc6a463fa16a387f3","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":73,"ts":1791398847.063941,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"20e4bd664f540dc9dfc34e3f72ee1bb94e0cae6f1c9f2b8eee0ec75aa8b54475","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:28","payload":{"intent":"costing"},"prev_hash":"d3e77fa66701dcbc6f2b78aaf3d78c5ee8395802b5df45f70d424acd144cecc1","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":74,"ts":1791398848.2143419,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"3d805a619f8e8ee8777f0adf9f6c753a3f501b42dbc892e458d926477d934431","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:28","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"20e4bd664f540dc9dfc34e3f72ee1bb94e0cae6f1c9f2b8eee0ec75aa8b54475","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":75,"ts":1791398848.2180424,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"81d2be18dc1d4c57e195220ef6093a1b30d75d8841fefa74cc0e0ddfdd4d1c48","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:29","payload":{"date":"","holiday_weekday":"","hours":8.0,"pay_type":"overtime","source":"claude","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"years_of_service":0.0},"prev_hash":"3d805a619f8e8ee8777f0adf9f6c753a3f501b42dbc892e458d926477d934431","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":76,"ts":1791398849.547338,"type":"llm.parse_intent"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"d42ea21718ef46090da75b3e5eafc60a9fd76e5b246dba32e9a60ed8d210b99f","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:29","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"named in the question","id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":13},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"subject","rejected":[{"id":"roster:Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","label":"Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Apparatus Technician, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Division Chief (top step)","label":"Division Chief (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Division Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=chief-officers not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Marshal (top step)","label":"Fire Marshal (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Marshal, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=management not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Analyst (top step)","label":"Administrative Analyst (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Analyst, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Assistant (top step)","label":"Administrative Assistant (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Assistant, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Inspector (top step)","label":"Fire Inspector (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Inspector, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"}]},"prev_hash":"81d2be18dc1d4c57e195220ef6093a1b30d75d8841fefa74cc0e0ddfdd4d1c48","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":77,"ts":1791398849.552222,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f98adf2328352afaa13ec869baf85f5c139e877e5047483683cc999431ee8ec1","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:29","payload":{"adapter":"csv","bargaining_units":["firefighters-local-3535"],"data_sha256":"1cfcfdfed61c7a854330452d40bff756dfc9645a4bca55fb715821ba59bff2a4","fields":["classification","department","rank","base_hourly","shift","bargaining_unit","name"],"records":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","base_hourly":53.4,"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","department":"fire","name":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","rank":"Firefighter/Paramedic","shift":"Suppression"}],"rows":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"shift_date":null},"prev_hash":"d42ea21718ef46090da75b3e5eafc60a9fd76e5b246dba32e9a60ed8d210b99f","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":78,"ts":1791398849.5584126,"type":"data.read"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f9dd5f0bad1aa2c3fa17f13a344026ae450752098b6020d208fca4e1fadcf29f","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:29","payload":{"checks":[{"agree":true,"deterministic":8.0,"field":"hours","model":8.0},{"agree":true,"deterministic":"overtime","field":"pay_type","model":null}],"date_iso":null,"date_note":"no date given","hours":8.0,"parsed_via":"claude","pay_type":"overtime","read_as":"8 h \u00b7 overtime \u00b7 Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step) \u00b7 no date given","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"years_note":null,"years_of_service":null},"prev_hash":"f98adf2328352afaa13ec869baf85f5c139e877e5047483683cc999431ee8ec1","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":79,"ts":1791398849.5629163,"type":"chat.interpretation"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"2a645dfdff3bfad98097590480f8721965950e45d633961e1b4f8f88fa5b5700","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:29","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","date":null,"matched":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","effective_end":"2028-12-31","effective_start":"2025-12-20","mou_version":"L3535-2025","why":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only"}],"reason":"resolved by governance: units ['firefighters-local-3535'] + date None -> MOU(s) ['firefighters_local3535_mou']","resolved":true,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"units":["firefighters-local-3535"]},"prev_hash":"f9dd5f0bad1aa2c3fa17f13a344026ae450752098b6020d208fca4e1fadcf29f","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":80,"ts":1791398849.5675929,"type":"governance.resolve"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"b709df5c5ef059fab8196d860ffb50d68cf2e8050384c2723e739c66d034b22c","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:29","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"date":null,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"governance","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters)","reason":"unit admin-group \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter)","reason":"unit management \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028","reason":"unit chief-officers \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)","reason":"doc_type salary-schedule is not an MOU or amendment"}]},"prev_hash":"2a645dfdff3bfad98097590480f8721965950e45d633961e1b4f8f88fa5b5700","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":81,"ts":1791398849.5699098,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"25747025ed095fe168e9221b6d005a654ac9559e26cc6603eb05aa530c5c1937","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:29","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"topic overtime, currency, base","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular ","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Ra"}},{"detail":"topic longevity, currency, differential","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","label":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local 3535 MOU, Longevity Pay, p.12); corrobo"}}],"counts":{"chosen":2,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"asked":["overtime"],"before_pay_type":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"rule_filter","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:bereavement_shifts","label":"Three (3) shifts of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immedi","reason":"result_type shifts, costing wants currency","ref":{"bbox":[107.28,189.498,505.259,167.118],"clause":"XIV","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":21,"text":"Three (3) shifts of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate family (Local 3535 MOU, Article XIV,"}},{"id":"chief_officers_mou:bereavement_hours","label":"40 hours of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate fami","reason":"cites Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028, not a governing document","ref":{"bbox":[90.7,575.8,526.7,552.8],"clause":"Bereavement Leave (p.14)","doc_id":"chief_officers_mou","page":14,"text":"40 hours of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate family (Chief Officers MOU, Bereavement Leav"}},{"id":"admin_group_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"One and one-half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked in excess of the","reason":"cites Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters), not a governing document","ref":{"bbox":[104.4,137.7,509.6,113.8],"clause":"Overtime (p.6)","doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":6,"text":"One and one-half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked in excess of the normal schedule (Admin Group MOU, Overt"}}]},"prev_hash":"b709df5c5ef059fab8196d860ffb50d68cf2e8050384c2723e739c66d034b22c","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":82,"ts":1791398849.572528,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"2055c053fd2413ba421b2bce7541c3372116fbc66718041505270a5ba8af8186","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:29","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"approved by kenny on 2026-07-18","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular ","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Ra"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":2},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","total":640.8,"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"rule_select","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","label":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local","reason":"when 'years_of_service >= 10' -> False","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local 3535 MOU, Longevity Pay, p.12); corrobo"}}]},"prev_hash":"25747025ed095fe168e9221b6d005a654ac9559e26cc6603eb05aa530c5c1937","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":83,"ts":1791398849.5753255,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f67eb52eee92590c6ee00c90a417d4974c17b348e595f800984a35a57bf7e09d","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:33","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver kenny; verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate:multiplier","label":"multiplier: Overtime Rate (p.8)","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"multiplier","name":"multiplier","query":"premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one half times regular rate of pay","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Incremen\u2026","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[141.4304564,423.66664719936,469.2488398472001,414.05279314036005],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Increments."},"value":0.0328},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime \u2026","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.13802712,655.8666107990399,513.7099673408001,552.4045199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who is promoted to a  higher position shall have one half \u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[140.4,272.10672,486.7074593236,236.68452000000002],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who is promoted to a  higher position shall have one half of their . ac\u00e9rued CTO hours paid off at the time "},"value":0.0308},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:5","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0308}]},"prev_hash":"2055c053fd2413ba421b2bce7541c3372116fbc66718041505270a5ba8af8186","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":84,"ts":1791398853.2880983,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"0eaaf94714180cb489f5c1b0c72cfe197c9297fd76576cad417cc6b1e9086a99","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:36","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver kenny; verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate:regular_rate_definition","label":"regular_rate_definition: Regular Rate of Pay (p.8)","ref":{"bbox":[142.138,655.867,513.71,552.405],"clause":"Regular Rate of Pay (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"definition","name":"regular_rate_definition","query":"regular rate of pay definition overtime","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 2, Regular Rate of Pay","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.92,683.22672,245.16004550399998,675.25128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"2, Regular Rate of Pay"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the r\u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"},"value":0.0317},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:14:5","label":"p.14 \u00b7 \u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to\u2026","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,680.53824,492.481209024,644.9245199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"text":"\u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to the highest level eligible.  Overtime earned on  "},"value":0.0303}]},"prev_hash":"f67eb52eee92590c6ee00c90a417d4974c17b348e595f800984a35a57bf7e09d","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":85,"ts":1791398856.5946846,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"ca08fb96888924601605be1489dc3d5dce6a727551f812c1af46a874ef8c57dc","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:36","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"from the roster file, printed on the salary schedule","id":"roster:base_hourly:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"base_hourly = 53.4 \u2014 roster row Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","ref":{"bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"clause":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr \u00b7 MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","page":1,"text":"$53.40"},"value":53.4}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"base_hourly","pointer":{"bbox":[110.88,526.566,510.48,489.331],"clause":"Salary Schedule set forth in Appendix A (p.6)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"roster","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"0eaaf94714180cb489f5c1b0c72cfe197c9297fd76576cad417cc6b1e9086a99","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":86,"ts":1791398856.5978703,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"ce66720cdba69ee8e215430d5bda7d704004cd162dd2c93b60d8b7bf48ad3201","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:36","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"question:hours","label":"hours = 8.0 \u2014 stated in the question","value":8.0}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"user","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"question","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"ca08fb96888924601605be1489dc3d5dce6a727551f812c1af46a874ef8c57dc","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":87,"ts":1791398856.6001806,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"bf07315a176267c24a3e23bcc57795a207db851d358440cc92e561bae61c8fdb","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:36","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"when: hours > 0 -> True (scope 2, priority 0)","inputs":{"hours":8.0},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":true},"prev_hash":"ce66720cdba69ee8e215430d5bda7d704004cd162dd2c93b60d8b7bf48ad3201","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":88,"ts":1791398856.6027405,"type":"rule.selector_considered"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"dbe18276e8175c89a3dfd74d0c026e4f3f405d1f8d898668c8d15e6318ee0892","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:36","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"chose firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate (scope 2, priority 0); Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Rate, p.8). Reviewed and approved by the analyst against the clause text; the drafted FLSA 182/192-hour cycle rules were deliberately not approved \u2014 they model the 24-day work period, a different pay branch than a premium overtime shift.","inputs":{},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":640.8},"prev_hash":"bf07315a176267c24a3e23bcc57795a207db851d358440cc92e561bae61c8fdb","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":89,"ts":1791398856.605487,"type":"rule.selector_chosen"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"de6619aeda211112b5da372596da560bc0a1281ae6d246d581da52ced2c10cab","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:36","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours = 640.8","expr":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours","inputs":{"effective_base":53.4,"hours":8.0},"line":"$53.40/hr \u00d7 1.5 \u00d7 8 h = $640.80","operands":[{"kind":"fact","name":"effective_base","role":"rate","source":{"bbox":[503.7,211.1,530.64,202.5],"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","column":"MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","context_bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","field":"base_hourly","kind":"schedule-cell","page":1,"row":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr","row_bbox":[51.227725982666016,522.4412994384766,739.9093627929688,134.97317504882812],"text":"$53.40","title":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)"},"unit":"hour","value":53.4},{"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":8,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"value":1.5},{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","role":"hours","source":{"kind":"question","param":"hours"},"value":8.0}],"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":640.8},"prev_hash":"dbe18276e8175c89a3dfd74d0c026e4f3f405d1f8d898668c8d15e6318ee0892","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":90,"ts":1791398856.609709,"type":"rule.math"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"c5a6789fb081715bba0042e2b7854a496cac8741ebb45f34a2839338e946d0f2","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:36","payload":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"char_span":[],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","doc_sha256":"b30076962d29c424864fbe8b05a048911356f7b807b3472f83104aeb921ee800","page":8,"quote_sha256":"97bd147f7e3aec58","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"},"prev_hash":"de6619aeda211112b5da372596da560bc0a1281ae6d246d581da52ced2c10cab","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":91,"ts":1791398856.6126857,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"2de2c3083369bb1dead9517f82f5eeabfb0ea6c56e7fb8f9ecc90b6c5d8705c2","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:36","payload":{"engine_sha256":"6538a13f34e6e99c4fd9484b93f2beb5af6892ef44bbee48304db8be797b2aa1","math":[{"expr":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours","line":"$53.40/hr \u00d7 1.5 \u00d7 8 h = $640.80","operands":[{"kind":"fact","name":"effective_base","role":"rate","source":{"bbox":[503.7,211.1,530.64,202.5],"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","column":"MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","context_bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","field":"base_hourly","kind":"schedule-cell","page":1,"row":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr","row_bbox":[51.227725982666016,522.4412994384766,739.9093627929688,134.97317504882812],"text":"$53.40","title":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)"},"unit":"hour","value":53.4},{"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":8,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"value":1.5},{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","role":"hours","source":{"kind":"question","param":"hours"},"value":8.0}],"subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"}],"partial":false,"result_sha256":"bb116678b8f7b093f053d4ad463f7eb960cf201821ec3756019ee19baf33dbb5","result_type":"currency","rules":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","sha256":"07efac20a48d41212702b810cf18f3e43daca430768105948e1b8d76cbfe4e15"}],"schema":2,"snapshot":"51e5427e2428.json","snapshot_sha256":"f35f2608f31f8638bfa4e835c68eb9c37b07dda7bc36ecd1c4cd460a52e1822c","total":640.8,"uncovered":[]},"prev_hash":"c5a6789fb081715bba0042e2b7854a496cac8741ebb45f34a2839338e946d0f2","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":92,"ts":1791398856.616381,"type":"answer.snapshot"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"40a452bb2affc753515a6efe1f77672ffe245ff2bfdab153d60caf682e79c2d2","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:36","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":384,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1132,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":945,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"2de2c3083369bb1dead9517f82f5eeabfb0ea6c56e7fb8f9ecc90b6c5d8705c2","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":93,"ts":1791398856.6276898,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"93ea05987676783663a568918297a4f0594e5bd851a710dc30d37bf2b9a95c8d","iso":"2026-10-07T18:47:36","payload":{"fn":"parse_intent","input_tokens":424,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1321,"output_tokens":78,"prompt_chars":1008,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"40a452bb2affc753515a6efe1f77672ffe245ff2bfdab153d60caf682e79c2d2","query_id":"51e5427e2428","seq":94,"ts":1791398856.6312554,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"c50d8ad8b188dae4ba0c7dd04b3e6f06848622a874334e1e372158d8bf08c332","iso":"2026-10-07T18:49:09","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"Cost an 8-hour overtime shift for a Fire Marshal (top step)"},"prev_hash":"93ea05987676783663a568918297a4f0594e5bd851a710dc30d37bf2b9a95c8d","query_id":"a230d29c3e80","seq":95,"ts":1791398949.8431785,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"3dacb5c6882e6857611c59ed9bd76a9d2e724f567c08f56e3662a66c5e437a1f","iso":"2026-10-07T18:49:11","payload":{"intent":"costing"},"prev_hash":"c50d8ad8b188dae4ba0c7dd04b3e6f06848622a874334e1e372158d8bf08c332","query_id":"a230d29c3e80","seq":96,"ts":1791398951.1788385,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"db28ea53f871ddd831274a1fab1819e91af66f26437010f3a4896d264aece833","iso":"2026-10-07T18:49:11","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"3dacb5c6882e6857611c59ed9bd76a9d2e724f567c08f56e3662a66c5e437a1f","query_id":"a230d29c3e80","seq":97,"ts":1791398951.181549,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"5a95828e1204b51d93c12d29db077064190f10b1807a8e91bd48db3388fdf8b2","iso":"2026-10-07T18:49:12","payload":{"date":"","holiday_weekday":"","hours":8.0,"pay_type":"overtime","source":"claude","subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"years_of_service":0.0},"prev_hash":"db28ea53f871ddd831274a1fab1819e91af66f26437010f3a4896d264aece833","query_id":"a230d29c3e80","seq":98,"ts":1791398952.1518753,"type":"llm.parse_intent"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"1bef7f5dd7afd1389342d42393fcd658d29494271ad201a81f1ab75c84a6ab1b","iso":"2026-10-07T18:49:12","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"named in the question","id":"roster:Fire Marshal (top step)","label":"Fire Marshal (top step)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":13},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"subject","rejected":[{"id":"roster:Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Firefighter, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Firefighter/Paramedic, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Firefighter/Paramedic, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Fire Captain, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Fire Captain, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","label":"Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Apparatus Technician, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Division Chief (top step)","label":"Division Chief (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Division Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=chief-officers not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Analyst (top step)","label":"Administrative Analyst (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Analyst, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Assistant (top step)","label":"Administrative Assistant (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Assistant, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Inspector (top step)","label":"Fire Inspector (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Inspector, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"}]},"prev_hash":"5a95828e1204b51d93c12d29db077064190f10b1807a8e91bd48db3388fdf8b2","query_id":"a230d29c3e80","seq":99,"ts":1791398952.155702,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"c88c33d03f53472e4ac9f3dce570287028f322da0a34dde8fe22d6fea0ae3242","iso":"2026-10-07T18:49:12","payload":{"adapter":"csv","bargaining_units":["management"],"data_sha256":"1cfcfdfed61c7a854330452d40bff756dfc9645a4bca55fb715821ba59bff2a4","fields":["classification","department","rank","base_hourly","shift","bargaining_unit","name"],"records":[{"bargaining_unit":"management","base_hourly":108.59,"classification":"Fire Marshal (top step)","department":"fire","name":"Fire Marshal (top step)","rank":"Fire Marshal","shift":"Day"}],"rows":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"shift_date":null},"prev_hash":"1bef7f5dd7afd1389342d42393fcd658d29494271ad201a81f1ab75c84a6ab1b","query_id":"a230d29c3e80","seq":100,"ts":1791398952.159561,"type":"data.read"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"5099adf59af8524b9a7c70bcdaecc2ebef0ed948c5daf4b1a06a55f8f96ad66c","iso":"2026-10-07T18:49:12","payload":{"checks":[{"agree":true,"deterministic":8.0,"field":"hours","model":8.0},{"agree":true,"deterministic":"overtime","field":"pay_type","model":null}],"date_iso":null,"date_note":"no date given","hours":8.0,"parsed_via":"claude","pay_type":"overtime","read_as":"8 h \u00b7 overtime \u00b7 Fire Marshal (top step) \u00b7 no date given","subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"years_note":null,"years_of_service":null},"prev_hash":"c88c33d03f53472e4ac9f3dce570287028f322da0a34dde8fe22d6fea0ae3242","query_id":"a230d29c3e80","seq":101,"ts":1791398952.1714864,"type":"chat.interpretation"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"dcb0c9277a11887033d50a8fe5183db15559e9cd0a8a2eb183dd1ebf8eb00fc5","iso":"2026-10-07T18:49:12","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"management","date":null,"matched":[{"bargaining_unit":"management","doc_id":"management_mou","effective_end":"2026-12-31","effective_start":"2024-01-01","mou_version":"MGMT-2024","why":"unit 'management' matches; no date given; unit match only"}],"reason":"resolved by governance: units ['management'] + date None -> MOU(s) ['management_mou']","resolved":true,"subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"units":["management"]},"prev_hash":"5099adf59af8524b9a7c70bcdaecc2ebef0ed948c5daf4b1a06a55f8f96ad66c","query_id":"a230d29c3e80","seq":102,"ts":1791398952.178883,"type":"governance.resolve"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f5a2603a2c3a83212cc3321901effebdc496cdf939df91ff478bcfa7b8d326c0","iso":"2026-10-07T18:49:12","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"unit 'management' matches; no date given; unit match only","id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"date":null,"subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"unit":"management"},"fork":"governance","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule)","reason":"unit firefighters-local-3535 \u2260 management"},{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters)","reason":"unit admin-group \u2260 management"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028","reason":"unit chief-officers \u2260 management"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)","reason":"doc_type salary-schedule is not an MOU or amendment"}]},"prev_hash":"dcb0c9277a11887033d50a8fe5183db15559e9cd0a8a2eb183dd1ebf8eb00fc5","query_id":"a230d29c3e80","seq":103,"ts":1791398952.1839995,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"6a3d7785c5a381434fe538bbd18efc726f13c6c0d1336bd291c9e034ba91786a","iso":"2026-10-07T18:49:12","payload":{"approved_topics":[],"bargaining_unit":"management","doc":["management_mou"],"reason":"Not covered \u2014 Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter) has no approved rule","stale":[],"status":"no_rules","subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"]},"prev_hash":"f5a2603a2c3a83212cc3321901effebdc496cdf939df91ff478bcfa7b8d326c0","query_id":"a230d29c3e80","seq":104,"ts":1791398952.188285,"type":"costing.uncovered"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"d09dbbc2287df6e08a0789d8357598862ba6549b0518a2a516cfbbd1e1306879","iso":"2026-10-07T18:49:12","payload":{"doc":["management_mou"],"error":null,"per_unit":[{"bargaining_unit":"management","reason":"Not covered \u2014 Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter) has no approved rule","status":"no_rules"}],"reason":"no ratified rules","stale":[],"units":["management"]},"prev_hash":"6a3d7785c5a381434fe538bbd18efc726f13c6c0d1336bd291c9e034ba91786a","query_id":"a230d29c3e80","seq":105,"ts":1791398952.1913009,"type":"costing.blocked"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"cc705937b99632454bde3c95554ab9eb35a2b08c3be8c53484e291e7ffda6e52","iso":"2026-10-07T18:49:12","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":375,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1331,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":929,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"d09dbbc2287df6e08a0789d8357598862ba6549b0518a2a516cfbbd1e1306879","query_id":"a230d29c3e80","seq":106,"ts":1791398952.1963775,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"a03d21bcb698405436c319094de55a24e000db7597b969b95231a24f10535af7","iso":"2026-10-07T18:49:12","payload":{"fn":"parse_intent","input_tokens":415,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":964,"output_tokens":69,"prompt_chars":992,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"cc705937b99632454bde3c95554ab9eb35a2b08c3be8c53484e291e7ffda6e52","query_id":"a230d29c3e80","seq":107,"ts":1791398952.2010899,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"b4e311bf0dc6b7866b7799699bc2afcae35312d534a2079723115058087f749e","iso":"2026-10-07T20:34:56","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"Cost an 8-hour overtime shift for a Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"},"prev_hash":"a03d21bcb698405436c319094de55a24e000db7597b969b95231a24f10535af7","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":108,"ts":1791405296.0016317,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"510992aeda9bff7617efa925b873944cde437e0943c367e178c36c3127bf094c","iso":"2026-10-07T20:34:57","payload":{"intent":"costing"},"prev_hash":"b4e311bf0dc6b7866b7799699bc2afcae35312d534a2079723115058087f749e","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":109,"ts":1791405297.137501,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"392c9189ab277291095e31f2194972709ea73fc321c68837bdbbf705a1875d2d","iso":"2026-10-07T20:34:57","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"510992aeda9bff7617efa925b873944cde437e0943c367e178c36c3127bf094c","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":110,"ts":1791405297.142555,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"32f0569411d1a8349bd5fc299d62d570982864aeaf29daa5cc8ae2e196532857","iso":"2026-10-07T20:34:58","payload":{"date":"","holiday_weekday":"","hours":8.0,"pay_type":"overtime","source":"claude","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"years_of_service":0.0},"prev_hash":"392c9189ab277291095e31f2194972709ea73fc321c68837bdbbf705a1875d2d","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":111,"ts":1791405298.2955043,"type":"llm.parse_intent"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"6b07d5e52ee8be051f7ba4ab268c2898e0bc0f94b5825ee2354e9ccfa7c98738","iso":"2026-10-07T20:34:58","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"named in the question","id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":13},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"subject","rejected":[{"id":"roster:Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","label":"Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Apparatus Technician, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Division Chief (top step)","label":"Division Chief (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Division Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=chief-officers not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Marshal (top step)","label":"Fire Marshal (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Marshal, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=management not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Analyst (top step)","label":"Administrative Analyst (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Analyst, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Assistant (top step)","label":"Administrative Assistant (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Assistant, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Inspector (top step)","label":"Fire Inspector (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Inspector, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"}]},"prev_hash":"32f0569411d1a8349bd5fc299d62d570982864aeaf29daa5cc8ae2e196532857","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":112,"ts":1791405298.2997427,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"a4e76988fc97ff09e58c49c42935ca1da5397ac84414af86016c3a824fedd1f4","iso":"2026-10-07T20:34:58","payload":{"adapter":"csv","bargaining_units":["firefighters-local-3535"],"data_sha256":"1cfcfdfed61c7a854330452d40bff756dfc9645a4bca55fb715821ba59bff2a4","fields":["classification","department","rank","base_hourly","shift","bargaining_unit","name"],"records":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","base_hourly":53.4,"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","department":"fire","name":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","rank":"Firefighter/Paramedic","shift":"Suppression"}],"rows":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"shift_date":null},"prev_hash":"6b07d5e52ee8be051f7ba4ab268c2898e0bc0f94b5825ee2354e9ccfa7c98738","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":113,"ts":1791405298.305888,"type":"data.read"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"35073d044b7cbc031554ea84468f54f0a87cfb403291f6747f7b50f53e1ffd0f","iso":"2026-10-07T20:34:58","payload":{"checks":[{"agree":true,"deterministic":8.0,"field":"hours","model":8.0},{"agree":true,"deterministic":"overtime","field":"pay_type","model":null}],"date_iso":null,"date_note":"no date given","hours":8.0,"parsed_via":"claude","pay_type":"overtime","read_as":"8 h \u00b7 overtime \u00b7 Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step) \u00b7 no date given","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"years_note":null,"years_of_service":null},"prev_hash":"a4e76988fc97ff09e58c49c42935ca1da5397ac84414af86016c3a824fedd1f4","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":114,"ts":1791405298.3090632,"type":"chat.interpretation"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"558b40ca231498a8f61d854c9be0a58b03304e0771ebdb106e1884ad9aec8a12","iso":"2026-10-07T20:34:58","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","date":null,"matched":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","effective_end":"2028-12-31","effective_start":"2025-12-20","mou_version":"L3535-2025","why":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only"}],"reason":"resolved by governance: units ['firefighters-local-3535'] + date None -> MOU(s) ['firefighters_local3535_mou']","resolved":true,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"units":["firefighters-local-3535"]},"prev_hash":"35073d044b7cbc031554ea84468f54f0a87cfb403291f6747f7b50f53e1ffd0f","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":115,"ts":1791405298.3142672,"type":"governance.resolve"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"1e931be2e0b94ec8dcf59903ba1591bfa1227db2649a45fca8320a1c74e7d11b","iso":"2026-10-07T20:34:58","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"date":null,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"governance","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters)","reason":"unit admin-group \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter)","reason":"unit management \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028","reason":"unit chief-officers \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)","reason":"doc_type salary-schedule is not an MOU or amendment"}]},"prev_hash":"558b40ca231498a8f61d854c9be0a58b03304e0771ebdb106e1884ad9aec8a12","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":116,"ts":1791405298.3169022,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"38fdc14a1b5fe29e9d989c3e26246dd026f5b34e9bb509ee1cab5dc6ac85e4de","iso":"2026-10-07T20:34:58","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"topic overtime, currency, base","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular ","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Ra"}},{"detail":"topic longevity, currency, differential","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","label":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local 3535 MOU, Longevity Pay, p.12); corrobo"}}],"counts":{"chosen":2,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"asked":["overtime"],"before_pay_type":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"rule_filter","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:bereavement_shifts","label":"Three (3) shifts of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immedi","reason":"result_type shifts, costing wants currency","ref":{"bbox":[107.28,189.498,505.259,167.118],"clause":"XIV","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":21,"text":"Three (3) shifts of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate family (Local 3535 MOU, Article XIV,"}},{"id":"chief_officers_mou:bereavement_hours","label":"40 hours of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate fami","reason":"cites Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028, not a governing document","ref":{"bbox":[90.7,575.8,526.7,552.8],"clause":"Bereavement Leave (p.14)","doc_id":"chief_officers_mou","page":14,"text":"40 hours of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate family (Chief Officers MOU, Bereavement Leav"}},{"id":"admin_group_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"One and one-half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked in excess of the","reason":"cites Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters), not a governing document","ref":{"bbox":[104.4,137.7,509.6,113.8],"clause":"Overtime (p.6)","doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":6,"text":"One and one-half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked in excess of the normal schedule (Admin Group MOU, Overt"}}]},"prev_hash":"1e931be2e0b94ec8dcf59903ba1591bfa1227db2649a45fca8320a1c74e7d11b","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":117,"ts":1791405298.3257594,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"e5b53f7d5743df3c1787e105aa35a9884433c679aa55e71bd21b325b83c0ff01","iso":"2026-10-07T20:34:58","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"approved by kenny on 2026-07-18","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular ","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Ra"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":2},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","total":640.8,"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"rule_select","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","label":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local","reason":"when 'years_of_service >= 10' -> False","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local 3535 MOU, Longevity Pay, p.12); corrobo"}}]},"prev_hash":"38fdc14a1b5fe29e9d989c3e26246dd026f5b34e9bb509ee1cab5dc6ac85e4de","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":118,"ts":1791405298.32977,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"c992be4f8cc3ad02be9b099d866cbf257a8fd7dc282dae668802b183fc4ba1ee","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:01","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver kenny; verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate:multiplier","label":"multiplier: Overtime Rate (p.8)","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"multiplier","name":"multiplier","query":"premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one half times regular rate of pay","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Incremen\u2026","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[141.4304564,423.66664719936,469.2488398472001,414.05279314036005],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Increments."},"value":0.0328},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime \u2026","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.13802712,655.8666107990399,513.7099673408001,552.4045199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who is promoted to a  higher position shall have one half \u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[140.4,272.10672,486.7074593236,236.68452000000002],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who is promoted to a  higher position shall have one half of their . ac\u00e9rued CTO hours paid off at the time "},"value":0.0308},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:5","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0308}]},"prev_hash":"e5b53f7d5743df3c1787e105aa35a9884433c679aa55e71bd21b325b83c0ff01","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":119,"ts":1791405301.494526,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"084ad9ec3a5528541ae43ed0d92b51280122b7bb16a44ed7abf1be7b61fa78cb","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:05","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver kenny; verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate:regular_rate_definition","label":"regular_rate_definition: Regular Rate of Pay (p.8)","ref":{"bbox":[142.138,655.867,513.71,552.405],"clause":"Regular Rate of Pay (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"definition","name":"regular_rate_definition","query":"regular rate of pay definition overtime","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 2, Regular Rate of Pay","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.92,683.22672,245.16004550399998,675.25128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"2, Regular Rate of Pay"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the r\u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"},"value":0.0317},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:14:5","label":"p.14 \u00b7 \u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to\u2026","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,680.53824,492.481209024,644.9245199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"text":"\u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to the highest level eligible.  Overtime earned on  "},"value":0.0303}]},"prev_hash":"c992be4f8cc3ad02be9b099d866cbf257a8fd7dc282dae668802b183fc4ba1ee","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":120,"ts":1791405305.494653,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"8d2cda8e2a01b8f25d4b6dabffe47c6768ec75c6865cbcae014492a3778dd4ec","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:05","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"from the roster file, printed on the salary schedule","id":"roster:base_hourly:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"base_hourly = 53.4 \u2014 roster row Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","ref":{"bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"clause":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr \u00b7 MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","page":1,"text":"$53.40"},"value":53.4}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"base_hourly","pointer":{"bbox":[110.88,526.566,510.48,489.331],"clause":"Salary Schedule set forth in Appendix A (p.6)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"roster","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"084ad9ec3a5528541ae43ed0d92b51280122b7bb16a44ed7abf1be7b61fa78cb","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":121,"ts":1791405305.5005167,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"b9011093b94dc965334add3c1ed7423897f8abcddb58151f54785e5e72008cff","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:05","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"question:hours","label":"hours = 8.0 \u2014 stated in the question","value":8.0}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"user","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"question","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"8d2cda8e2a01b8f25d4b6dabffe47c6768ec75c6865cbcae014492a3778dd4ec","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":122,"ts":1791405305.5083709,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"3949284c3b922a1dbf5994693f60a3616a709cf8f11cb6fde645a90c15ba0f1e","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:05","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"when: hours > 0 -> True (scope 2, priority 0)","inputs":{"hours":8.0},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":true},"prev_hash":"b9011093b94dc965334add3c1ed7423897f8abcddb58151f54785e5e72008cff","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":123,"ts":1791405305.5123703,"type":"rule.selector_considered"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"93ec7342a51a2a2bd4c9a5159ac645d72ccbff87bea2276e8a7e4a45a3419189","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:05","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"chose firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate (scope 2, priority 0); Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Rate, p.8). Reviewed and approved by the analyst against the clause text; the drafted FLSA 182/192-hour cycle rules were deliberately not approved \u2014 they model the 24-day work period, a different pay branch than a premium overtime shift.","inputs":{},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":640.8},"prev_hash":"3949284c3b922a1dbf5994693f60a3616a709cf8f11cb6fde645a90c15ba0f1e","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":124,"ts":1791405305.5158892,"type":"rule.selector_chosen"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"4a6bf2584d8d2d497f144a8bfef066e6fd03cec8bf08667a36c8a844d8c0f499","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:05","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours = 640.8","expr":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours","inputs":{"effective_base":53.4,"hours":8.0},"line":"$53.40/hr \u00d7 1.5 \u00d7 8 h = $640.80","operands":[{"kind":"fact","name":"effective_base","role":"rate","source":{"bbox":[503.7,211.1,530.64,202.5],"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","column":"MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","context_bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","field":"base_hourly","kind":"schedule-cell","page":1,"row":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr","row_bbox":[51.227725982666016,522.4412994384766,739.9093627929688,134.97317504882812],"text":"$53.40","title":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)"},"unit":"hour","value":53.4},{"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":8,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"value":1.5},{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","role":"hours","source":{"kind":"question","param":"hours"},"value":8.0}],"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":640.8},"prev_hash":"93ec7342a51a2a2bd4c9a5159ac645d72ccbff87bea2276e8a7e4a45a3419189","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":125,"ts":1791405305.5233502,"type":"rule.math"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"6f0c386403e4303bf31638a5602842b793b9ea437016f580987f77cca667b58c","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:05","payload":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"char_span":[],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","doc_sha256":"b30076962d29c424864fbe8b05a048911356f7b807b3472f83104aeb921ee800","page":8,"quote_sha256":"97bd147f7e3aec58","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"},"prev_hash":"4a6bf2584d8d2d497f144a8bfef066e6fd03cec8bf08667a36c8a844d8c0f499","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":126,"ts":1791405305.527997,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"e68443d15ca99fbcafe22cc42091ae6de58cd9477d2fc1fb285e5f7d696cb159","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:05","payload":{"engine_sha256":"6538a13f34e6e99c4fd9484b93f2beb5af6892ef44bbee48304db8be797b2aa1","math":[{"expr":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours","line":"$53.40/hr \u00d7 1.5 \u00d7 8 h = $640.80","operands":[{"kind":"fact","name":"effective_base","role":"rate","source":{"bbox":[503.7,211.1,530.64,202.5],"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","column":"MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","context_bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","field":"base_hourly","kind":"schedule-cell","page":1,"row":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr","row_bbox":[51.227725982666016,522.4412994384766,739.9093627929688,134.97317504882812],"text":"$53.40","title":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)"},"unit":"hour","value":53.4},{"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":8,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"value":1.5},{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","role":"hours","source":{"kind":"question","param":"hours"},"value":8.0}],"subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"}],"partial":false,"result_sha256":"bb116678b8f7b093f053d4ad463f7eb960cf201821ec3756019ee19baf33dbb5","result_type":"currency","rules":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","sha256":"07efac20a48d41212702b810cf18f3e43daca430768105948e1b8d76cbfe4e15"}],"schema":2,"snapshot":"76ff64cb6095.json","snapshot_sha256":"913e66dc9929ea7971d8201adf05561393ceac0cbcf2731afbe7328812f64e47","total":640.8,"uncovered":[]},"prev_hash":"6f0c386403e4303bf31638a5602842b793b9ea437016f580987f77cca667b58c","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":127,"ts":1791405305.5453258,"type":"answer.snapshot"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"21b78cb5df15a594febd65ed9cac10bc3917229018ff88bf292e77c60f60e5fe","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:05","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":384,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1125,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":945,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"e68443d15ca99fbcafe22cc42091ae6de58cd9477d2fc1fb285e5f7d696cb159","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":128,"ts":1791405305.555742,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"777342bf407fbb9bc8fdf25bee16e274301b61b9dc8facacae5f1657c718add9","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:05","payload":{"fn":"parse_intent","input_tokens":424,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1144,"output_tokens":78,"prompt_chars":1008,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"21b78cb5df15a594febd65ed9cac10bc3917229018ff88bf292e77c60f60e5fe","query_id":"76ff64cb6095","seq":129,"ts":1791405305.5605013,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"2b43659e67a19a7f39df12702cbe43c855485bda134271d7f456a3a55e09e6a8","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:19","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"Cost an 8-hour overtime shift for a Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"},"prev_hash":"777342bf407fbb9bc8fdf25bee16e274301b61b9dc8facacae5f1657c718add9","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":130,"ts":1791405319.4428525,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"3c5d7b4e72e7b1fe2d82e1a19ef4f9f3ef3ed5b2ebf470b17167ba302e603799","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:20","payload":{"intent":"costing"},"prev_hash":"2b43659e67a19a7f39df12702cbe43c855485bda134271d7f456a3a55e09e6a8","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":131,"ts":1791405320.409321,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"93edef2b7736597cdf177b805a5db9b1e5a81ccec6cef5814ece191fbaa16c49","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:20","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"3c5d7b4e72e7b1fe2d82e1a19ef4f9f3ef3ed5b2ebf470b17167ba302e603799","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":132,"ts":1791405320.413187,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"b87cef55b424f165d6115b0914cf976f3e47345de309f944045260f7bb25c428","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:21","payload":{"date":"","holiday_weekday":"","hours":8.0,"pay_type":"overtime","source":"claude","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"years_of_service":0.0},"prev_hash":"93edef2b7736597cdf177b805a5db9b1e5a81ccec6cef5814ece191fbaa16c49","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":133,"ts":1791405321.7312288,"type":"llm.parse_intent"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"568874ba711fa54262274a29f055ca55f161e42dd203b72cd11c48bd3b79b778","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:21","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"named in the question","id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":13},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"subject","rejected":[{"id":"roster:Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","label":"Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Apparatus Technician, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Division Chief (top step)","label":"Division Chief (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Division Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=chief-officers not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Marshal (top step)","label":"Fire Marshal (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Marshal, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=management not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Analyst (top step)","label":"Administrative Analyst (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Analyst, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Assistant (top step)","label":"Administrative Assistant (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Assistant, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Inspector (top step)","label":"Fire Inspector (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Inspector, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"}]},"prev_hash":"b87cef55b424f165d6115b0914cf976f3e47345de309f944045260f7bb25c428","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":134,"ts":1791405321.7352386,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"90f3bb1589f82cfc34afbda61d922a57da3dda66159dc43acfd1cf6663285081","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:21","payload":{"adapter":"csv","bargaining_units":["firefighters-local-3535"],"data_sha256":"1cfcfdfed61c7a854330452d40bff756dfc9645a4bca55fb715821ba59bff2a4","fields":["classification","department","rank","base_hourly","shift","bargaining_unit","name"],"records":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","base_hourly":53.4,"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","department":"fire","name":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","rank":"Firefighter/Paramedic","shift":"Suppression"}],"rows":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"shift_date":null},"prev_hash":"568874ba711fa54262274a29f055ca55f161e42dd203b72cd11c48bd3b79b778","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":135,"ts":1791405321.7387364,"type":"data.read"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"c1b7afc0aa257a50f75fbdfd10c521ae25828b0e4415caf8fd45e35953a47d41","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:21","payload":{"checks":[{"agree":true,"deterministic":8.0,"field":"hours","model":8.0},{"agree":true,"deterministic":"overtime","field":"pay_type","model":null}],"date_iso":null,"date_note":"no date given","hours":8.0,"parsed_via":"claude","pay_type":"overtime","read_as":"8 h \u00b7 overtime \u00b7 Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step) \u00b7 no date given","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"years_note":null,"years_of_service":null},"prev_hash":"90f3bb1589f82cfc34afbda61d922a57da3dda66159dc43acfd1cf6663285081","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":136,"ts":1791405321.7419968,"type":"chat.interpretation"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"07f533ac6d29a2da493ec37bed607fc62c9b94e1cfe9e425a8daca3d9cdadbcb","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:21","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","date":null,"matched":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","effective_end":"2028-12-31","effective_start":"2025-12-20","mou_version":"L3535-2025","why":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only"}],"reason":"resolved by governance: units ['firefighters-local-3535'] + date None -> MOU(s) ['firefighters_local3535_mou']","resolved":true,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"units":["firefighters-local-3535"]},"prev_hash":"c1b7afc0aa257a50f75fbdfd10c521ae25828b0e4415caf8fd45e35953a47d41","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":137,"ts":1791405321.7483323,"type":"governance.resolve"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"7ff1dfe0f74123c648bdb1d4e32435a8603620a13a0581a0570d794da1edc43d","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:21","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"date":null,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"governance","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters)","reason":"unit admin-group \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter)","reason":"unit management \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028","reason":"unit chief-officers \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)","reason":"doc_type salary-schedule is not an MOU or amendment"}]},"prev_hash":"07f533ac6d29a2da493ec37bed607fc62c9b94e1cfe9e425a8daca3d9cdadbcb","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":138,"ts":1791405321.751171,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"55fe650bbf6c74161cadcfc00218557d9ed08e6495d1629b47b3af36a7da20ff","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:21","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"topic overtime, currency, base","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular ","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Ra"}},{"detail":"topic longevity, currency, differential","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","label":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local 3535 MOU, Longevity Pay, p.12); corrobo"}}],"counts":{"chosen":2,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"asked":["overtime"],"before_pay_type":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"rule_filter","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:bereavement_shifts","label":"Three (3) shifts of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immedi","reason":"result_type shifts, costing wants currency","ref":{"bbox":[107.28,189.498,505.259,167.118],"clause":"XIV","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":21,"text":"Three (3) shifts of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate family (Local 3535 MOU, Article XIV,"}},{"id":"chief_officers_mou:bereavement_hours","label":"40 hours of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate fami","reason":"cites Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028, not a governing document","ref":{"bbox":[90.7,575.8,526.7,552.8],"clause":"Bereavement Leave (p.14)","doc_id":"chief_officers_mou","page":14,"text":"40 hours of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate family (Chief Officers MOU, Bereavement Leav"}},{"id":"admin_group_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"One and one-half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked in excess of the","reason":"cites Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters), not a governing document","ref":{"bbox":[104.4,137.7,509.6,113.8],"clause":"Overtime (p.6)","doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":6,"text":"One and one-half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked in excess of the normal schedule (Admin Group MOU, Overt"}}]},"prev_hash":"7ff1dfe0f74123c648bdb1d4e32435a8603620a13a0581a0570d794da1edc43d","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":139,"ts":1791405321.757747,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"3c4cc3fdd7b4ac63f69114557f2c0c3294b9d05958b61618badf9d9af54bae85","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:21","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"approved by kenny on 2026-07-18","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular ","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Ra"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":2},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","total":640.8,"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"rule_select","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","label":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local","reason":"when 'years_of_service >= 10' -> False","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local 3535 MOU, Longevity Pay, p.12); corrobo"}}]},"prev_hash":"55fe650bbf6c74161cadcfc00218557d9ed08e6495d1629b47b3af36a7da20ff","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":140,"ts":1791405321.7614937,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"85a97d8cd456f5850e7986b87a7dcb002d55817b15abb398eec3b72bf1b6d0ef","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:25","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver kenny; verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate:multiplier","label":"multiplier: Overtime Rate (p.8)","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"multiplier","name":"multiplier","query":"premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one half times regular rate of pay","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Incremen\u2026","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[141.4304564,423.66664719936,469.2488398472001,414.05279314036005],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Increments."},"value":0.0328},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime \u2026","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.13802712,655.8666107990399,513.7099673408001,552.4045199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who is promoted to a  higher position shall have one half \u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[140.4,272.10672,486.7074593236,236.68452000000002],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who is promoted to a  higher position shall have one half of their . ac\u00e9rued CTO hours paid off at the time "},"value":0.0308},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:5","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0308}]},"prev_hash":"3c4cc3fdd7b4ac63f69114557f2c0c3294b9d05958b61618badf9d9af54bae85","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":141,"ts":1791405325.3601007,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"bd1e5b4d2e72555b2e0ff218d292e739d51a82ce5be7a36250b138e1ecb53771","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:29","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver kenny; verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate:regular_rate_definition","label":"regular_rate_definition: Regular Rate of Pay (p.8)","ref":{"bbox":[142.138,655.867,513.71,552.405],"clause":"Regular Rate of Pay (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"definition","name":"regular_rate_definition","query":"regular rate of pay definition overtime","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 2, Regular Rate of Pay","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.92,683.22672,245.16004550399998,675.25128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"2, Regular Rate of Pay"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the r\u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"},"value":0.0317},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:14:5","label":"p.14 \u00b7 \u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to\u2026","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,680.53824,492.481209024,644.9245199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"text":"\u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to the highest level eligible.  Overtime earned on  "},"value":0.0303}]},"prev_hash":"85a97d8cd456f5850e7986b87a7dcb002d55817b15abb398eec3b72bf1b6d0ef","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":142,"ts":1791405329.0649118,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"5e2f1997c76508dbe7d13e0ee447e1739e9e2e60f5c63412f686afe1df7b90e8","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:29","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"from the roster file, printed on the salary schedule","id":"roster:base_hourly:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"base_hourly = 53.4 \u2014 roster row Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","ref":{"bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"clause":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr \u00b7 MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","page":1,"text":"$53.40"},"value":53.4}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"base_hourly","pointer":{"bbox":[110.88,526.566,510.48,489.331],"clause":"Salary Schedule set forth in Appendix A (p.6)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"roster","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"bd1e5b4d2e72555b2e0ff218d292e739d51a82ce5be7a36250b138e1ecb53771","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":143,"ts":1791405329.0696456,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"8279ecccd52b25ba61ca7b541675e8a44f87999d2b0cd18926ab0209b6d4acb5","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:29","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"question:hours","label":"hours = 8.0 \u2014 stated in the question","value":8.0}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"user","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"question","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"5e2f1997c76508dbe7d13e0ee447e1739e9e2e60f5c63412f686afe1df7b90e8","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":144,"ts":1791405329.0755801,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"f93ebe558d41758e592c07c666a68db1dd162cb8d5a74e5bb9e8d3166e03a702","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:29","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"when: hours > 0 -> True (scope 2, priority 0)","inputs":{"hours":8.0},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":true},"prev_hash":"8279ecccd52b25ba61ca7b541675e8a44f87999d2b0cd18926ab0209b6d4acb5","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":145,"ts":1791405329.0802739,"type":"rule.selector_considered"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"910e39c4702ca12d0ed9e1ab20dff9f8b556dc40404004ff23bf9c8281a63a17","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:29","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"chose firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate (scope 2, priority 0); Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Rate, p.8). Reviewed and approved by the analyst against the clause text; the drafted FLSA 182/192-hour cycle rules were deliberately not approved \u2014 they model the 24-day work period, a different pay branch than a premium overtime shift.","inputs":{},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":640.8},"prev_hash":"f93ebe558d41758e592c07c666a68db1dd162cb8d5a74e5bb9e8d3166e03a702","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":146,"ts":1791405329.0841348,"type":"rule.selector_chosen"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"22798fe1670ea52954a14a51d35cd2e96c6dc6f6431a69f58c6bc29325a7e5ef","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:29","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours = 640.8","expr":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours","inputs":{"effective_base":53.4,"hours":8.0},"line":"$53.40/hr \u00d7 1.5 \u00d7 8 h = $640.80","operands":[{"kind":"fact","name":"effective_base","role":"rate","source":{"bbox":[503.7,211.1,530.64,202.5],"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","column":"MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","context_bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","field":"base_hourly","kind":"schedule-cell","page":1,"row":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr","row_bbox":[51.227725982666016,522.4412994384766,739.9093627929688,134.97317504882812],"text":"$53.40","title":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)"},"unit":"hour","value":53.4},{"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":8,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"value":1.5},{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","role":"hours","source":{"kind":"question","param":"hours"},"value":8.0}],"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":640.8},"prev_hash":"910e39c4702ca12d0ed9e1ab20dff9f8b556dc40404004ff23bf9c8281a63a17","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":147,"ts":1791405329.0880728,"type":"rule.math"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"4fb856b6d2179acbe4b8b76c221c92aa02d89dba93a7119e658dfd34c80c4b4c","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:29","payload":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"char_span":[],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","doc_sha256":"b30076962d29c424864fbe8b05a048911356f7b807b3472f83104aeb921ee800","page":8,"quote_sha256":"97bd147f7e3aec58","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"},"prev_hash":"22798fe1670ea52954a14a51d35cd2e96c6dc6f6431a69f58c6bc29325a7e5ef","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":148,"ts":1791405329.0927231,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"cfe5a99cc75c6690bde6805813ce96f73b5b42196eed401e313dd2ed7bac6257","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:29","payload":{"engine_sha256":"6538a13f34e6e99c4fd9484b93f2beb5af6892ef44bbee48304db8be797b2aa1","math":[{"expr":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours","line":"$53.40/hr \u00d7 1.5 \u00d7 8 h = $640.80","operands":[{"kind":"fact","name":"effective_base","role":"rate","source":{"bbox":[503.7,211.1,530.64,202.5],"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","column":"MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","context_bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","field":"base_hourly","kind":"schedule-cell","page":1,"row":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr","row_bbox":[51.227725982666016,522.4412994384766,739.9093627929688,134.97317504882812],"text":"$53.40","title":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)"},"unit":"hour","value":53.4},{"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":8,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"value":1.5},{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","role":"hours","source":{"kind":"question","param":"hours"},"value":8.0}],"subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"}],"partial":false,"result_sha256":"bb116678b8f7b093f053d4ad463f7eb960cf201821ec3756019ee19baf33dbb5","result_type":"currency","rules":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","sha256":"07efac20a48d41212702b810cf18f3e43daca430768105948e1b8d76cbfe4e15"}],"schema":2,"snapshot":"b5bdf9ad5497.json","snapshot_sha256":"3d01aa65af5fae9bb3eeb849d8de5b39cc080d5bcb204122cd8243b900e42705","total":640.8,"uncovered":[]},"prev_hash":"4fb856b6d2179acbe4b8b76c221c92aa02d89dba93a7119e658dfd34c80c4b4c","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":149,"ts":1791405329.105134,"type":"answer.snapshot"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"d1b7ac53755ab9e291880fc51d447644d7169e92416fc589b3a0dccc47af2cc9","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:29","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":384,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":959,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":945,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"cfe5a99cc75c6690bde6805813ce96f73b5b42196eed401e313dd2ed7bac6257","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":150,"ts":1791405329.1192558,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"54f8b8008f6d10321a91a2f61caf1c946578c7099567e8add53d91439ca691cf","iso":"2026-10-07T20:35:29","payload":{"fn":"parse_intent","input_tokens":424,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1310,"output_tokens":78,"prompt_chars":1008,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"d1b7ac53755ab9e291880fc51d447644d7169e92416fc589b3a0dccc47af2cc9","query_id":"b5bdf9ad5497","seq":151,"ts":1791405329.1320207,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"be3a2133068bc51a091b6066b5cfb757797d7c61893b4e7f4e3c95cb40f6c81c","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:11","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"How much bereavement leave does a firefighter get?"},"prev_hash":"54f8b8008f6d10321a91a2f61caf1c946578c7099567e8add53d91439ca691cf","query_id":"47e5715168eb","seq":152,"ts":1791405371.420501,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"123efdcbb3f9ea0b315efece389e9f47dfebdcc71e3f78a80c6e1d1929cab487","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:13","payload":{"intent":"entitlement"},"prev_hash":"be3a2133068bc51a091b6066b5cfb757797d7c61893b4e7f4e3c95cb40f6c81c","query_id":"47e5715168eb","seq":153,"ts":1791405373.0567,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"7454b7d0781ce036d1d08254a20196139982a08686842ac63abb97efebaab22a","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:13","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"123efdcbb3f9ea0b315efece389e9f47dfebdcc71e3f78a80c6e1d1929cab487","query_id":"47e5715168eb","seq":154,"ts":1791405373.0612307,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"668b02961430c1c8501d5052fad33297f34c40d4c2707d680e3c1ee70c30dbfd","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:14","payload":{"date_iso":"","how":"classification","subjects":["Firefighter (56 hr, top step)"],"units":["firefighters-local-3535"]},"prev_hash":"7454b7d0781ce036d1d08254a20196139982a08686842ac63abb97efebaab22a","query_id":"47e5715168eb","seq":155,"ts":1791405374.1608906,"type":"entitlement.scope"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"a4f37b24dbb2f190fc96cf3e224114d1a72f32a3d2bf29ad83367a3df194cda0","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:14","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"date":"","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"governance","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters)","reason":"unit admin-group \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter)","reason":"unit management \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028","reason":"unit chief-officers \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)","reason":"doc_type salary-schedule is not an MOU or amendment"}]},"prev_hash":"668b02961430c1c8501d5052fad33297f34c40d4c2707d680e3c1ee70c30dbfd","query_id":"47e5715168eb","seq":156,"ts":1791405374.1694548,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"ebfd9030c7dc62624d4d33b0545a544e83d20192bf5b1f5a1f3239d9bb2e00a8","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:14","payload":{"candidate_docs":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"candidates":1,"hits":[{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":21,"score":0.0333},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":2,"score":0.0325},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":21,"score":0.0325},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":21,"score":0.0308},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":22,"score":0.0305},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":23,"score":0.0301},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":20,"score":0.0301},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":18,"score":0.0286}],"query":"bereavement leave","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"prev_hash":"a4f37b24dbb2f190fc96cf3e224114d1a72f32a3d2bf29ad83367a3df194cda0","query_id":"47e5715168eb","seq":157,"ts":1791405374.2122688,"type":"entitlement.retrieval"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"e8f9b3b002a2effcdb512120b6709e6a592a4d9544598520ee560cc9c35b95c5","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:14","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"rank 1","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:21:1","label":"p.21 \u00b7 XIV.  Bereavement Leave","ref":{"bbox":[107.28,216.774,237.59904060000002,207.711],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":21,"text":"XIV.  Bereavement Leave"},"value":0.0333},{"detail":"rank 2","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:2:2","label":"p.2 \u00b7 Table of Contents \u2014 0: XIV. | 1: Bereavement Leave wun","ref":{"bbox":[132.70127868652344,681.1662979125977,482.231689453125,119.72119140625],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":2,"text":"Table of Contents \u2014 0: XIV. | 1: Bereavement Leave wun"},"value":0.0325},{"detail":"rank 3","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:21:3","label":"p.21 \u00b7 In  the evant of  a  death  in  the employee's immediate family, the e\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[107.28,189.49824,505.25933097600006,167.11775999999998],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":21,"text":"In  the evant of  a  death  in  the employee's immediate family, the employee shall  be granted three (3) shifts  paid  "},"value":0.0325},{"detail":"rank 4","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:21:4","label":"p.21 \u00b7 Employees on an unpaid leave of absence shall continue to accrue sick \u2026","ref":{"bbox":[107.64,556.33824,467.999521344,534.0445199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":21,"text":"Employees on an unpaid leave of absence shall continue to accrue sick leave hours at their normal rate."},"value":0.0308},{"detail":"rank 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:22:5","label":"p.22 \u00b7 XV.  Vacation Leave","ref":{"bbox":[111.96,680.00976,213.84060789599997,670.58424],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":22,"text":"XV.  Vacation Leave"},"value":0.0305},{"detail":"rank 6","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:23:6","label":"p.23 \u00b7 Employees on an unpaid leave of absence shall continue to accrue vacat\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[108.72,637.4224800000001,462.59969022,615.4045199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":23,"text":"Employees on an unpaid leave of absence shall continue to accrue vacation leave hours at their normal rate."},"value":0.0301},{"detail":"rank 7","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:20:7","label":"p.20 \u00b7 XIIL.  Sick Leave","ref":{"bbox":[109.44,252.60551999999996,191.880780408,242.81747999999993],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":20,"text":"XIIL.  Sick Leave"},"value":0.0301},{"detail":"rank 8","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:18:8","label":"p.18 \u00b7 Gov. Code 20965 - Sick Leave Credit","ref":{"bbox":[176.04,130.73400000000004,330.65974529999994,121.67100000000005],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":18,"text":"Gov. Code 20965 - Sick Leave Credit"},"value":0.0286}],"counts":{"chosen":8,"considered":14,"scope_docs":1,"searched":14},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"query":"bereavement leave","scope":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"clause_retrieval","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:22:9","label":"p.22 \u00b7 Employees separating for any reason will  receive compensation for any\u2026","reason":"rank 9 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[110.88,258.78664719936,506.70373248,209.68452000000002],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":22,"text":"Employees separating for any reason will  receive compensation for any unused vacation leave hours  earned, excluding an"},"value":0.0282},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:20:10","label":"p.20 \u00b7 Gov. Code 20965 - Sick Leave Credit","reason":"rank 10 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[158.4,667.21824,311.58011260800004,658.5177600000001],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":20,"text":"Gov. Code 20965 - Sick Leave Credit"},"value":0.0282},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:22:11","label":"p.22 \u00b7 Any  Member incurring a  serious injury or illness which requires the \u2026","reason":"rank 11 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[110.16,191.74248,505.439571456,129.13128000000006],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":22,"text":"Any  Member incurring a  serious injury or illness which requires the Member ta be hospitalized or confined while on pai"},"value":0.0281},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:14:12","label":"p.14 \u00b7 \u00ab The 40-hour safety employee shall  accrue vacation and sick leave at\u2026","reason":"rank 12 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,372.73824,497.5208568,337.03776],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"text":"\u00ab The 40-hour safety employee shall  accrue vacation and sick leave at the same rate as employees assigned to a  56-hour"},"value":0.027},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:2:13","label":"p.2 \u00b7 Table of Contents \u2014 0: XV, | 1: Vacation Leave ..","reason":"rank 13 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[132.70127868652344,681.1662979125977,482.231689453125,119.72119140625],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":2,"text":"Table of Contents \u2014 0: XV, | 1: Vacation Leave .."},"value":0.0259},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:16:14","label":"p.16 \u00b7 The Battalion  Chief assigned to the Training Division shall accrue va\u2026","reason":"rank 14 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[142.92,573.34248,498.239665632,522.25128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":16,"text":"The Battalion  Chief assigned to the Training Division shall accrue vacation and sick  leave  at the same rate as  Batta"},"value":0.0258}]},"prev_hash":"ebfd9030c7dc62624d4d33b0545a544e83d20192bf5b1f5a1f3239d9bb2e00a8","query_id":"47e5715168eb","seq":158,"ts":1791405374.2163033,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"d575012b654a1cefaad91f3cd6a474055c74d3cb4ececa970a01497e7ad50cdb","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:14","payload":{"hit_rank":3,"overlap":1.0,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:bereavement_shifts","scope_how":"classification","topic":"bereavement","unit":"firefighters-local-3535","via":"evidence"},"prev_hash":"e8f9b3b002a2effcdb512120b6709e6a592a4d9544598520ee560cc9c35b95c5","query_id":"47e5715168eb","seq":159,"ts":1791405374.2205474,"type":"entitlement.match"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"68ed13090686fc4447137c02570de1130266a59b65d357e3fe433e5092f0d2e5","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:14","payload":{"engine_sha256":"6538a13f34e6e99c4fd9484b93f2beb5af6892ef44bbee48304db8be797b2aa1","intent":"entitlement","result_sha256":"c9cdd1af42d6aa137a95caf4383763bb050f144ed4bd16704729a85848b31b37","result_type":"shifts","rules":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:bereavement_shifts","sha256":"1aa15a8383910c7dda9500bc771bd2c68c40b5a455fffa7f9ae676e451b1057d"}],"schema":2,"snapshot":"47e5715168eb.json","snapshot_sha256":"c6b52d7371a07117a160ac45f5068981746338483149a413591e12d8bf74aedd","total":3.0,"unit_label":"shifts"},"prev_hash":"d575012b654a1cefaad91f3cd6a474055c74d3cb4ececa970a01497e7ad50cdb","query_id":"47e5715168eb","seq":160,"ts":1791405374.226812,"type":"answer.snapshot"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"72d8b2c9818cc4e334e6b15321ea6d11ee83c848c56595977eb32abd735e2bdf","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:14","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":364,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1628,"output_tokens":14,"prompt_chars":920,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"68ed13090686fc4447137c02570de1130266a59b65d357e3fe433e5092f0d2e5","query_id":"47e5715168eb","seq":161,"ts":1791405374.2333276,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"4147dd5290b12de694f95867f0f7721202d018dd2106c3aeb3e993643a8267d9","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:14","payload":{"fn":"parse_intent","input_tokens":404,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1086,"output_tokens":66,"prompt_chars":983,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"72d8b2c9818cc4e334e6b15321ea6d11ee83c848c56595977eb32abd735e2bdf","query_id":"47e5715168eb","seq":162,"ts":1791405374.2366278,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"3e888b5c8d777bdf3d3ca080322fa7bb502200d86c2c550441b3098b937a2374","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:14","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"Cost an 8-hour overtime shift for a Fire Marshal (top step)"},"prev_hash":"4147dd5290b12de694f95867f0f7721202d018dd2106c3aeb3e993643a8267d9","query_id":"db3406df6b92","seq":163,"ts":1791405374.7116587,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"8b94b3b53988639111c0fbaf7f6e21e8bd0262ba89da270dc8f72025a5352e84","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:15","payload":{"intent":"costing"},"prev_hash":"3e888b5c8d777bdf3d3ca080322fa7bb502200d86c2c550441b3098b937a2374","query_id":"db3406df6b92","seq":164,"ts":1791405375.4181828,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"a2bb5f0ae3d6dda671f1f2de07bb3f0bf1636ef56572566e1c2f7c70695a1bd1","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:15","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"8b94b3b53988639111c0fbaf7f6e21e8bd0262ba89da270dc8f72025a5352e84","query_id":"db3406df6b92","seq":165,"ts":1791405375.4215765,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"d1f02d2ea89c5cc36cfc7ec43c53f969b32690a10e535f9472485629a1fe0d7c","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:16","payload":{"date":"","holiday_weekday":"","hours":8.0,"pay_type":"overtime","source":"claude","subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"years_of_service":0.0},"prev_hash":"a2bb5f0ae3d6dda671f1f2de07bb3f0bf1636ef56572566e1c2f7c70695a1bd1","query_id":"db3406df6b92","seq":166,"ts":1791405376.7067528,"type":"llm.parse_intent"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"ddcf63ca9a34de218720b8ee8c98171f4f7aa3ca02a9ae0fc5849e3d057aaea9","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:16","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"named in the question","id":"roster:Fire Marshal (top step)","label":"Fire Marshal (top step)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":13},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"subject","rejected":[{"id":"roster:Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Firefighter, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Firefighter/Paramedic, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Firefighter/Paramedic, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Fire Captain, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Fire Captain, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","label":"Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Apparatus Technician, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Division Chief (top step)","label":"Division Chief (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Division Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=chief-officers not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Analyst (top step)","label":"Administrative Analyst (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Analyst, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Assistant (top step)","label":"Administrative Assistant (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Assistant, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Inspector (top step)","label":"Fire Inspector (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Inspector, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"}]},"prev_hash":"d1f02d2ea89c5cc36cfc7ec43c53f969b32690a10e535f9472485629a1fe0d7c","query_id":"db3406df6b92","seq":167,"ts":1791405376.7146423,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"eb5e39ac4f7902f9b2429c69097a8e6804ca335950c13054b39538796faa7569","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:16","payload":{"adapter":"csv","bargaining_units":["management"],"data_sha256":"1cfcfdfed61c7a854330452d40bff756dfc9645a4bca55fb715821ba59bff2a4","fields":["classification","department","rank","base_hourly","shift","bargaining_unit","name"],"records":[{"bargaining_unit":"management","base_hourly":108.59,"classification":"Fire Marshal (top step)","department":"fire","name":"Fire Marshal (top step)","rank":"Fire Marshal","shift":"Day"}],"rows":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"shift_date":null},"prev_hash":"ddcf63ca9a34de218720b8ee8c98171f4f7aa3ca02a9ae0fc5849e3d057aaea9","query_id":"db3406df6b92","seq":168,"ts":1791405376.724365,"type":"data.read"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"cf55ed4b116fbd9379ac4b83008e9237b9dc9881892d7ef75796bc9f620fdcc5","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:16","payload":{"checks":[{"agree":true,"deterministic":8.0,"field":"hours","model":8.0},{"agree":true,"deterministic":"overtime","field":"pay_type","model":null}],"date_iso":null,"date_note":"no date given","hours":8.0,"parsed_via":"claude","pay_type":"overtime","read_as":"8 h \u00b7 overtime \u00b7 Fire Marshal (top step) \u00b7 no date given","subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"years_note":null,"years_of_service":null},"prev_hash":"eb5e39ac4f7902f9b2429c69097a8e6804ca335950c13054b39538796faa7569","query_id":"db3406df6b92","seq":169,"ts":1791405376.7375011,"type":"chat.interpretation"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"8233d8aa035955c61e83a178e0c656704257f61175e6ea09896e6275c34bdfd4","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:16","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"management","date":null,"matched":[{"bargaining_unit":"management","doc_id":"management_mou","effective_end":"2026-12-31","effective_start":"2024-01-01","mou_version":"MGMT-2024","why":"unit 'management' matches; no date given; unit match only"}],"reason":"resolved by governance: units ['management'] + date None -> MOU(s) ['management_mou']","resolved":true,"subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"units":["management"]},"prev_hash":"cf55ed4b116fbd9379ac4b83008e9237b9dc9881892d7ef75796bc9f620fdcc5","query_id":"db3406df6b92","seq":170,"ts":1791405376.7489748,"type":"governance.resolve"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"356178a2458139d15f676bd61da62d2d087853323833b525b201168a0f3ca718","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:16","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"unit 'management' matches; no date given; unit match only","id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"date":null,"subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"unit":"management"},"fork":"governance","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule)","reason":"unit firefighters-local-3535 \u2260 management"},{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters)","reason":"unit admin-group \u2260 management"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028","reason":"unit chief-officers \u2260 management"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)","reason":"doc_type salary-schedule is not an MOU or amendment"}]},"prev_hash":"8233d8aa035955c61e83a178e0c656704257f61175e6ea09896e6275c34bdfd4","query_id":"db3406df6b92","seq":171,"ts":1791405376.7586687,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"acf8b23d9dd16aadb7af080d859d41a10e8fd372241feba2751a8b38a568225a","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:16","payload":{"approved_topics":[],"bargaining_unit":"management","doc":["management_mou"],"reason":"Not covered \u2014 Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter) has no approved rule","stale":[],"status":"no_rules","subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"]},"prev_hash":"356178a2458139d15f676bd61da62d2d087853323833b525b201168a0f3ca718","query_id":"db3406df6b92","seq":172,"ts":1791405376.76635,"type":"costing.uncovered"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"b6caa76c9f9b2f0fb6515cab21012ec5bf4b2f74f7f501180fa0f0c9d10e45f3","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:16","payload":{"doc":["management_mou"],"error":null,"per_unit":[{"bargaining_unit":"management","reason":"Not covered \u2014 Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter) has no approved rule","status":"no_rules"}],"reason":"no ratified rules","stale":[],"units":["management"]},"prev_hash":"acf8b23d9dd16aadb7af080d859d41a10e8fd372241feba2751a8b38a568225a","query_id":"db3406df6b92","seq":173,"ts":1791405376.7743416,"type":"costing.blocked"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"b97ee3bf290b2fad1e7876d5edc391b2aae0d27e49b4f8c60f77011b6565bca8","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:16","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":375,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":699,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":929,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"b6caa76c9f9b2f0fb6515cab21012ec5bf4b2f74f7f501180fa0f0c9d10e45f3","query_id":"db3406df6b92","seq":174,"ts":1791405376.7844064,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"6e4aaf78ae48a7e44ef804bdf39090a9c0de48c88ef502669e2666dc2917fda4","iso":"2026-10-07T20:36:16","payload":{"fn":"parse_intent","input_tokens":415,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1278,"output_tokens":69,"prompt_chars":992,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"b97ee3bf290b2fad1e7876d5edc391b2aae0d27e49b4f8c60f77011b6565bca8","query_id":"db3406df6b92","seq":175,"ts":1791405376.7932084,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"8efd21c39854d74aedd687db33a184ec2bb6f0e05d8778e669a688ec5fe5188b","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:51","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"Cost an 8-hour overtime shift for a Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, bottom step)"},"prev_hash":"6e4aaf78ae48a7e44ef804bdf39090a9c0de48c88ef502669e2666dc2917fda4","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":176,"ts":1791405471.364664,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"483bafaab2d8f7c85139a6b0da8b79df50d8983cf2828f14f76867ce1e31949d","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:52","payload":{"intent":"costing"},"prev_hash":"8efd21c39854d74aedd687db33a184ec2bb6f0e05d8778e669a688ec5fe5188b","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":177,"ts":1791405472.2014322,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"9ed0571e3a07c1737962516ec8e919247ecce3ac53e6e888caf3516fa5a5862a","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:52","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"483bafaab2d8f7c85139a6b0da8b79df50d8983cf2828f14f76867ce1e31949d","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":178,"ts":1791405472.2123985,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"d8ea18587e32f8ba1888b6cd4c16a79bb35c697db809c43d756ed676c34cc89a","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"date":"","holiday_weekday":"","hours":8.0,"pay_type":"overtime","source":"claude","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)"],"years_of_service":0.0},"prev_hash":"9ed0571e3a07c1737962516ec8e919247ecce3ac53e6e888caf3516fa5a5862a","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":179,"ts":1791405473.492459,"type":"llm.parse_intent"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"58f34a43169f78c0807008e94027f4c4ce5cc9eab1f30fb9102a6caad811994e","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"named in the question","id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":13},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"subject","rejected":[{"id":"roster:Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","label":"Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Apparatus Technician, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Division Chief (top step)","label":"Division Chief (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Division Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=chief-officers not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Marshal (top step)","label":"Fire Marshal (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Marshal, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=management not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Analyst (top step)","label":"Administrative Analyst (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Analyst, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Assistant (top step)","label":"Administrative Assistant (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Assistant, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Inspector (top step)","label":"Fire Inspector (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Inspector, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"}]},"prev_hash":"d8ea18587e32f8ba1888b6cd4c16a79bb35c697db809c43d756ed676c34cc89a","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":180,"ts":1791405473.498617,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"024b51c7eaadc6744a272bd3a74f960594c352c6172bf516f35ddf9968a2a6de","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"adapter":"csv","bargaining_units":["firefighters-local-3535"],"data_sha256":"1cfcfdfed61c7a854330452d40bff756dfc9645a4bca55fb715821ba59bff2a4","fields":["classification","department","rank","base_hourly","shift","bargaining_unit","name"],"records":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","base_hourly":39.72,"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","department":"fire","name":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","rank":"Firefighter/Paramedic","shift":"Suppression"}],"rows":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)"],"shift_date":null},"prev_hash":"58f34a43169f78c0807008e94027f4c4ce5cc9eab1f30fb9102a6caad811994e","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":181,"ts":1791405473.5029962,"type":"data.read"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"c89b3621f73b9269a8a7bde5f48d811a4917521b0f8d5e8c9cf69487ac44df58","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"checks":[{"agree":true,"deterministic":8.0,"field":"hours","model":8.0},{"agree":true,"deterministic":"overtime","field":"pay_type","model":null}],"date_iso":null,"date_note":"no date given","hours":8.0,"parsed_via":"claude","pay_type":"overtime","read_as":"8 h \u00b7 overtime \u00b7 Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step) \u00b7 no date given","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)"],"years_note":null,"years_of_service":null},"prev_hash":"024b51c7eaadc6744a272bd3a74f960594c352c6172bf516f35ddf9968a2a6de","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":182,"ts":1791405473.5069005,"type":"chat.interpretation"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"ed7677871a409fc8d236854950d534358ea4c6230e75a0bc95b5ec933a42faac","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","date":null,"matched":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","effective_end":"2028-12-31","effective_start":"2025-12-20","mou_version":"L3535-2025","why":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only"}],"reason":"resolved by governance: units ['firefighters-local-3535'] + date None -> MOU(s) ['firefighters_local3535_mou']","resolved":true,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)"],"units":["firefighters-local-3535"]},"prev_hash":"c89b3621f73b9269a8a7bde5f48d811a4917521b0f8d5e8c9cf69487ac44df58","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":183,"ts":1791405473.5123868,"type":"governance.resolve"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"aa6d856261d84cd9d7398f9c4e428b60899b1502e32403946780d1347a14fae4","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"date":null,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"governance","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters)","reason":"unit admin-group \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter)","reason":"unit management \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028","reason":"unit chief-officers \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)","reason":"doc_type salary-schedule is not an MOU or amendment"}]},"prev_hash":"ed7677871a409fc8d236854950d534358ea4c6230e75a0bc95b5ec933a42faac","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":184,"ts":1791405473.5153582,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"fdef846bdd4134ff65002cdfa2d3b72ca56a2c1135d678cc4a7a62790cc2e380","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"topic overtime, currency, base","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular ","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Ra"}},{"detail":"topic longevity, currency, differential","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","label":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local 3535 MOU, Longevity Pay, p.12); corrobo"}}],"counts":{"chosen":2,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"asked":["overtime"],"before_pay_type":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"rule_filter","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:bereavement_shifts","label":"Three (3) shifts of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immedi","reason":"result_type shifts, costing wants currency","ref":{"bbox":[107.28,189.498,505.259,167.118],"clause":"XIV","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":21,"text":"Three (3) shifts of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate family (Local 3535 MOU, Article XIV,"}},{"id":"chief_officers_mou:bereavement_hours","label":"40 hours of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate fami","reason":"cites Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028, not a governing document","ref":{"bbox":[90.7,575.8,526.7,552.8],"clause":"Bereavement Leave (p.14)","doc_id":"chief_officers_mou","page":14,"text":"40 hours of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate family (Chief Officers MOU, Bereavement Leav"}},{"id":"admin_group_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"One and one-half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked in excess of the","reason":"cites Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters), not a governing document","ref":{"bbox":[104.4,137.7,509.6,113.8],"clause":"Overtime (p.6)","doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":6,"text":"One and one-half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked in excess of the normal schedule (Admin Group MOU, Overt"}}]},"prev_hash":"aa6d856261d84cd9d7398f9c4e428b60899b1502e32403946780d1347a14fae4","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":185,"ts":1791405473.5197146,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"8bded7989333b9896895b2b3833be4e570ca1b7f3d1fb5b7d0d4af18e835856e","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"approved by kenny on 2026-07-18","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular ","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Ra"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":2},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","total":476.64,"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"rule_select","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","label":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local","reason":"when 'years_of_service >= 10' -> False","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local 3535 MOU, Longevity Pay, p.12); corrobo"}}]},"prev_hash":"fdef846bdd4134ff65002cdfa2d3b72ca56a2c1135d678cc4a7a62790cc2e380","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":186,"ts":1791405473.523523,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"beca94994988f11a95e5169ee309d1c4a1f6b5c7783ca44bd82741e91114da94","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver kenny; verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate:multiplier","label":"multiplier: Overtime Rate (p.8)","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"multiplier","name":"multiplier","query":"premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one half times regular rate of pay","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Incremen\u2026","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[141.4304564,423.66664719936,469.2488398472001,414.05279314036005],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Increments."},"value":0.0328},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime \u2026","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.13802712,655.8666107990399,513.7099673408001,552.4045199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who is promoted to a  higher position shall have one half \u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[140.4,272.10672,486.7074593236,236.68452000000002],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who is promoted to a  higher position shall have one half of their . ac\u00e9rued CTO hours paid off at the time "},"value":0.0308},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:5","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0308}]},"prev_hash":"8bded7989333b9896895b2b3833be4e570ca1b7f3d1fb5b7d0d4af18e835856e","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":187,"ts":1791405473.597754,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"fa42483afe28877377b86d31d6e334b4c85dd485b44c4e640b2f2002416eeb1e","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver kenny; verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate:regular_rate_definition","label":"regular_rate_definition: Regular Rate of Pay (p.8)","ref":{"bbox":[142.138,655.867,513.71,552.405],"clause":"Regular Rate of Pay (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"definition","name":"regular_rate_definition","query":"regular rate of pay definition overtime","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 2, Regular Rate of Pay","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.92,683.22672,245.16004550399998,675.25128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"2, Regular Rate of Pay"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the r\u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"},"value":0.0317},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:14:5","label":"p.14 \u00b7 \u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to\u2026","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,680.53824,492.481209024,644.9245199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"text":"\u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to the highest level eligible.  Overtime earned on  "},"value":0.0303}]},"prev_hash":"beca94994988f11a95e5169ee309d1c4a1f6b5c7783ca44bd82741e91114da94","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":188,"ts":1791405473.6734283,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"80500a240554c098bda71c5a0cc281f2e1c30059076c9a3b87d4b4d6e83db776","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"from the roster file, printed on the salary schedule","id":"roster:base_hourly:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","label":"base_hourly = 39.72 \u2014 roster row Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","ref":{"bbox":[53.52,213.1,426.37,200.34],"clause":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr \u00b7 MINIMUM HOURLY RATE","doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","page":1,"text":"$39.72"},"value":39.72}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"base_hourly","pointer":{"bbox":[110.88,526.566,510.48,489.331],"clause":"Salary Schedule set forth in Appendix A (p.6)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"roster","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"fa42483afe28877377b86d31d6e334b4c85dd485b44c4e640b2f2002416eeb1e","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":189,"ts":1791405473.677873,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"49fdc2e22cabf51d3d4d7e7bf01321f90bd1a924059daf81e250faeed60b421e","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"question:hours","label":"hours = 8.0 \u2014 stated in the question","value":8.0}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"user","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"question","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"80500a240554c098bda71c5a0cc281f2e1c30059076c9a3b87d4b4d6e83db776","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":190,"ts":1791405473.6815162,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"189de9c5edee1b7fa8d04e6165b09398fd1a780a48a08daa669c3de5c0de1ea3","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"when: hours > 0 -> True (scope 2, priority 0)","inputs":{"hours":8.0},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","value":true},"prev_hash":"49fdc2e22cabf51d3d4d7e7bf01321f90bd1a924059daf81e250faeed60b421e","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":191,"ts":1791405473.685119,"type":"rule.selector_considered"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"34f6cd422099cda64c98b18562c5b0b08d753958ae6e7729582f5ac64d6a2fbb","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"chose firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate (scope 2, priority 0); Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Rate, p.8). Reviewed and approved by the analyst against the clause text; the drafted FLSA 182/192-hour cycle rules were deliberately not approved \u2014 they model the 24-day work period, a different pay branch than a premium overtime shift.","inputs":{},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","value":476.64},"prev_hash":"189de9c5edee1b7fa8d04e6165b09398fd1a780a48a08daa669c3de5c0de1ea3","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":192,"ts":1791405473.6924403,"type":"rule.selector_chosen"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"41ea5b5a4e5b8b786f656727aa2a435fb74ee4401aae30beca0c514c68390239","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours = 476.64","expr":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours","inputs":{"effective_base":39.72,"hours":8.0},"line":"$39.72/hr \u00d7 1.5 \u00d7 8 h = $476.64","operands":[{"kind":"fact","name":"effective_base","role":"rate","source":{"bbox":[399.64,211.1,426.37,202.5],"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","column":"MINIMUM HOURLY RATE","context_bbox":[53.52,213.1,426.37,200.34],"doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","field":"base_hourly","kind":"schedule-cell","page":1,"row":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr","row_bbox":[51.227725982666016,522.4412994384766,739.9093627929688,134.97317504882812],"text":"$39.72","title":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)"},"unit":"hour","value":39.72},{"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":8,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"value":1.5},{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","role":"hours","source":{"kind":"question","param":"hours"},"value":8.0}],"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","value":476.64},"prev_hash":"34f6cd422099cda64c98b18562c5b0b08d753958ae6e7729582f5ac64d6a2fbb","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":193,"ts":1791405473.6985836,"type":"rule.math"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"73db6dad5440c3b6eb64468176feba3a879c8b5c1299e3ce700bcdda740e66d1","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"char_span":[],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","doc_sha256":"b30076962d29c424864fbe8b05a048911356f7b807b3472f83104aeb921ee800","page":8,"quote_sha256":"97bd147f7e3aec58","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)"},"prev_hash":"41ea5b5a4e5b8b786f656727aa2a435fb74ee4401aae30beca0c514c68390239","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":194,"ts":1791405473.7057672,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"cbd657c5da5eb912acc305cc1a6fbea18e941d0dfd4b637dba8f17d3da9f5cbe","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"engine_sha256":"6538a13f34e6e99c4fd9484b93f2beb5af6892ef44bbee48304db8be797b2aa1","math":[{"expr":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours","line":"$39.72/hr \u00d7 1.5 \u00d7 8 h = $476.64","operands":[{"kind":"fact","name":"effective_base","role":"rate","source":{"bbox":[399.64,211.1,426.37,202.5],"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","column":"MINIMUM HOURLY RATE","context_bbox":[53.52,213.1,426.37,200.34],"doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","field":"base_hourly","kind":"schedule-cell","page":1,"row":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr","row_bbox":[51.227725982666016,522.4412994384766,739.9093627929688,134.97317504882812],"text":"$39.72","title":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)"},"unit":"hour","value":39.72},{"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":8,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"value":1.5},{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","role":"hours","source":{"kind":"question","param":"hours"},"value":8.0}],"subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)"}],"partial":false,"result_sha256":"9cb507d5f5343e93020ab41f7db5915d814242bd943b44d71f9241e838ccc73e","result_type":"currency","rules":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","sha256":"07efac20a48d41212702b810cf18f3e43daca430768105948e1b8d76cbfe4e15"}],"schema":2,"snapshot":"332778634e0d.json","snapshot_sha256":"3e89102f036050c671bce2b4f7e978dbdc990f195f86f7f96574eed36465827c","total":476.64,"uncovered":[]},"prev_hash":"73db6dad5440c3b6eb64468176feba3a879c8b5c1299e3ce700bcdda740e66d1","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":195,"ts":1791405473.7122955,"type":"answer.snapshot"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"095850dcc4b944d99fb5cd069ffe7012d2aeba615dbd9c9d58a4554a0e9e86f4","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":386,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":830,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":948,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"cbd657c5da5eb912acc305cc1a6fbea18e941d0dfd4b637dba8f17d3da9f5cbe","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":196,"ts":1791405473.7219872,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"01e77a52043453fff618490c63f83e4fea2cdb1e38a8f263b13d6ddbbb179582","iso":"2026-10-07T20:37:53","payload":{"fn":"parse_intent","input_tokens":426,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1269,"output_tokens":79,"prompt_chars":1011,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"095850dcc4b944d99fb5cd069ffe7012d2aeba615dbd9c9d58a4554a0e9e86f4","query_id":"332778634e0d","seq":197,"ts":1791405473.7272868,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"e46e6a6a8c92eb9cb1947fa8b810d8fe5271808959fa48b7bb3c0f5615c9cd67","iso":"2026-10-07T20:38:33","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"Cost a regular 8-hour shift for a Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"},"prev_hash":"01e77a52043453fff618490c63f83e4fea2cdb1e38a8f263b13d6ddbbb179582","query_id":"0eac7f96b23b","seq":198,"ts":1791405513.482729,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"870ddb352a3db80e5335fe381cf824ba09b5f7d6daca4569bf78b763fb2cba5c","iso":"2026-10-07T20:38:34","payload":{"intent":"costing"},"prev_hash":"e46e6a6a8c92eb9cb1947fa8b810d8fe5271808959fa48b7bb3c0f5615c9cd67","query_id":"0eac7f96b23b","seq":199,"ts":1791405514.6459284,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"5b36958f0d79f1c7f0549cb6c0163a29bb610ff65e9446b0150171fa4065275f","iso":"2026-10-07T20:38:34","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"870ddb352a3db80e5335fe381cf824ba09b5f7d6daca4569bf78b763fb2cba5c","query_id":"0eac7f96b23b","seq":200,"ts":1791405514.650039,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"d357939d6c1f0732b80f03d5b0d3321e78b144cd53e677d8563a5a9076f2c359","iso":"2026-10-07T20:38:35","payload":{"date":"","holiday_weekday":"","hours":8.0,"pay_type":"regular","source":"claude","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"years_of_service":0.0},"prev_hash":"5b36958f0d79f1c7f0549cb6c0163a29bb610ff65e9446b0150171fa4065275f","query_id":"0eac7f96b23b","seq":201,"ts":1791405515.8497775,"type":"llm.parse_intent"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"103621fe53bcdd17b2aa1b1d8c4e010a12fe6688f79b3cde1484d061ebf5f27d","iso":"2026-10-07T20:38:35","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"named in the question","id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":13},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"subject","rejected":[{"id":"roster:Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","label":"Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Apparatus Technician, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Division Chief (top step)","label":"Division Chief (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Division Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=chief-officers not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Marshal (top step)","label":"Fire Marshal (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Marshal, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=management not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Analyst (top step)","label":"Administrative Analyst (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Analyst, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Assistant (top step)","label":"Administrative Assistant (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Assistant, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Inspector (top step)","label":"Fire Inspector (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Inspector, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"}]},"prev_hash":"d357939d6c1f0732b80f03d5b0d3321e78b144cd53e677d8563a5a9076f2c359","query_id":"0eac7f96b23b","seq":202,"ts":1791405515.8545778,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"477b2022258f35a108c269178a3654fd1e135eb733653e4ea2659cb98371f478","iso":"2026-10-07T20:38:35","payload":{"adapter":"csv","bargaining_units":["firefighters-local-3535"],"data_sha256":"1cfcfdfed61c7a854330452d40bff756dfc9645a4bca55fb715821ba59bff2a4","fields":["classification","department","rank","base_hourly","shift","bargaining_unit","name"],"records":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","base_hourly":53.4,"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","department":"fire","name":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","rank":"Firefighter/Paramedic","shift":"Suppression"}],"rows":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"shift_date":null},"prev_hash":"103621fe53bcdd17b2aa1b1d8c4e010a12fe6688f79b3cde1484d061ebf5f27d","query_id":"0eac7f96b23b","seq":203,"ts":1791405515.86093,"type":"data.read"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"dfb833f699e0c0363fb95d1f05b56344fc314a5df647c39db0a00dc2e1cf7418","iso":"2026-10-07T20:38:35","payload":{"checks":[{"agree":true,"deterministic":8.0,"field":"hours","model":8.0},{"agree":true,"deterministic":"regular","field":"pay_type","model":null}],"date_iso":null,"date_note":"no date given","hours":8.0,"parsed_via":"claude","pay_type":"regular","read_as":"8 h \u00b7 regular \u00b7 Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step) \u00b7 no date given","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"years_note":null,"years_of_service":null},"prev_hash":"477b2022258f35a108c269178a3654fd1e135eb733653e4ea2659cb98371f478","query_id":"0eac7f96b23b","seq":204,"ts":1791405515.864638,"type":"chat.interpretation"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"3eb4c269df367f71cee18807c839cd6b14bbce85f7757231adfa6972d9a6697a","iso":"2026-10-07T20:38:35","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","date":null,"matched":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","effective_end":"2028-12-31","effective_start":"2025-12-20","mou_version":"L3535-2025","why":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only"}],"reason":"resolved by governance: units ['firefighters-local-3535'] + date None -> MOU(s) ['firefighters_local3535_mou']","resolved":true,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"units":["firefighters-local-3535"]},"prev_hash":"dfb833f699e0c0363fb95d1f05b56344fc314a5df647c39db0a00dc2e1cf7418","query_id":"0eac7f96b23b","seq":205,"ts":1791405515.8728435,"type":"governance.resolve"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"78dbc4c9e4a7a2b2ed4bb93717f76f7a3637b8a7e506c871f3619e8cfdab4afa","iso":"2026-10-07T20:38:35","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"date":null,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"governance","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters)","reason":"unit admin-group \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter)","reason":"unit management \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028","reason":"unit chief-officers \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)","reason":"doc_type salary-schedule is not an MOU or amendment"}]},"prev_hash":"3eb4c269df367f71cee18807c839cd6b14bbce85f7757231adfa6972d9a6697a","query_id":"0eac7f96b23b","seq":206,"ts":1791405515.8764253,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"dff03721ac39516906d6612a0e8aced6d13212a4727c7d47bd3ab575e098c76c","iso":"2026-10-07T20:38:35","payload":{"approved_topics":["overtime"],"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","doc":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"reason":"No approved regular rule for Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule); approved for this unit: overtime","stale":[],"status":"no_rule_for_pay_type","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"]},"prev_hash":"78dbc4c9e4a7a2b2ed4bb93717f76f7a3637b8a7e506c871f3619e8cfdab4afa","query_id":"0eac7f96b23b","seq":207,"ts":1791405515.880492,"type":"costing.uncovered"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"190b951455df54ecf44052c5d4be7371cadce9821f4eee843e49a0ae0d8cc9a3","iso":"2026-10-07T20:38:39","payload":{"approved_topics":["overtime"],"asked":["regular"],"doc":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"nearest":[{"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8},{"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":15}],"reason":"No approved regular rule for Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule); approved for this unit: overtime","units":["firefighters-local-3535"]},"prev_hash":"dff03721ac39516906d6612a0e8aced6d13212a4727c7d47bd3ab575e098c76c","query_id":"0eac7f96b23b","seq":208,"ts":1791405519.0046318,"type":"costing.refused"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"9883f9f405d875106de1cae49593307d1936df1aacba41019464addeb5c7b99e","iso":"2026-10-07T20:38:39","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":383,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1156,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":943,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"190b951455df54ecf44052c5d4be7371cadce9821f4eee843e49a0ae0d8cc9a3","query_id":"0eac7f96b23b","seq":209,"ts":1791405519.0109067,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"316946f0faddea0ae840160cd2f692c2913c1972beb676ec7c796e878dfea912","iso":"2026-10-07T20:38:39","payload":{"fn":"parse_intent","input_tokens":423,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1191,"output_tokens":77,"prompt_chars":1006,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"9883f9f405d875106de1cae49593307d1936df1aacba41019464addeb5c7b99e","query_id":"0eac7f96b23b","seq":210,"ts":1791405519.0205607,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"8220f1320bdd3cda7b261bb9a739f1c66f1a18678fd055e0052d3fb5aa1fcf5c","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:06","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"Cost an 8-hour overtime shift for a Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top      step) with 12 years of service"},"prev_hash":"316946f0faddea0ae840160cd2f692c2913c1972beb676ec7c796e878dfea912","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":211,"ts":1791405546.8515172,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"ffaf848022f9f76f48f5862f576cd45504945af676b8bb9c1f41c5b338786cc7","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:08","payload":{"intent":"costing"},"prev_hash":"8220f1320bdd3cda7b261bb9a739f1c66f1a18678fd055e0052d3fb5aa1fcf5c","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":212,"ts":1791405548.0587003,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"088606cc10a34171762f71035dbeac854446db259416ea838996f70e02779345","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:08","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"ffaf848022f9f76f48f5862f576cd45504945af676b8bb9c1f41c5b338786cc7","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":213,"ts":1791405548.0653667,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"0e41414733a69e7d8af4678d2a78f05d045c3a3f109f2124059c36f315de8093","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:09","payload":{"date":"","holiday_weekday":"","hours":8.0,"pay_type":"overtime","question_facts":{"years_of_service":{"source":"from the question, unverified \u2014 not a roster field","value":12.0}},"source":"claude","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"years_of_service":12.0},"prev_hash":"088606cc10a34171762f71035dbeac854446db259416ea838996f70e02779345","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":214,"ts":1791405549.2888327,"type":"llm.parse_intent"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"b32602a23e4a0c88098792bef300ec9921c5864ef86f55439d6d1746827e097c","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:09","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"named in the question","id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":13},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"subject","rejected":[{"id":"roster:Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","label":"Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Apparatus Technician, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Division Chief (top step)","label":"Division Chief (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Division Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=chief-officers not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Marshal (top step)","label":"Fire Marshal (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Marshal, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=management not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Analyst (top step)","label":"Administrative Analyst (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Analyst, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Assistant (top step)","label":"Administrative Assistant (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Assistant, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Inspector (top step)","label":"Fire Inspector (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Inspector, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"}]},"prev_hash":"0e41414733a69e7d8af4678d2a78f05d045c3a3f109f2124059c36f315de8093","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":215,"ts":1791405549.2996013,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"098d99e7c7d966c889f507c4c5ce26fb7c14ada80a9ef7572328a756be63a2fb","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:09","payload":{"adapter":"csv","bargaining_units":["firefighters-local-3535"],"data_sha256":"1cfcfdfed61c7a854330452d40bff756dfc9645a4bca55fb715821ba59bff2a4","fields":["classification","department","rank","base_hourly","shift","bargaining_unit","name"],"records":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","base_hourly":53.4,"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","department":"fire","name":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","rank":"Firefighter/Paramedic","shift":"Suppression"}],"rows":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"shift_date":null},"prev_hash":"b32602a23e4a0c88098792bef300ec9921c5864ef86f55439d6d1746827e097c","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":216,"ts":1791405549.3140337,"type":"data.read"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"323927151ee1225c7fcc0dc579f8ac69292fa143761ca4a7b2cdd4109fd748a3","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:09","payload":{"checks":[{"agree":true,"deterministic":8.0,"field":"hours","model":8.0},{"agree":true,"deterministic":"overtime","field":"pay_type","model":null}],"date_iso":null,"date_note":"no date given","hours":8.0,"parsed_via":"claude","pay_type":"overtime","read_as":"8 h \u00b7 overtime \u00b7 Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step) \u00b7 no date given \u00b7 12 years of service (from the question)","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"years_note":null,"years_of_service":12.0},"prev_hash":"098d99e7c7d966c889f507c4c5ce26fb7c14ada80a9ef7572328a756be63a2fb","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":217,"ts":1791405549.3197877,"type":"chat.interpretation"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"08fa1706fe226db087c2b05c6706a3e7390d14efd7e370a7c8e590fb4c8f716a","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:09","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","date":null,"matched":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","effective_end":"2028-12-31","effective_start":"2025-12-20","mou_version":"L3535-2025","why":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only"}],"reason":"resolved by governance: units ['firefighters-local-3535'] + date None -> MOU(s) ['firefighters_local3535_mou']","resolved":true,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"units":["firefighters-local-3535"]},"prev_hash":"323927151ee1225c7fcc0dc579f8ac69292fa143761ca4a7b2cdd4109fd748a3","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":218,"ts":1791405549.3272712,"type":"governance.resolve"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"fc12d38eec97f5847d04ab092471d23ca6c681d496cfe0ee7938504772e5beb1","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:09","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"date":null,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"governance","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters)","reason":"unit admin-group \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter)","reason":"unit management \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028","reason":"unit chief-officers \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)","reason":"doc_type salary-schedule is not an MOU or amendment"}]},"prev_hash":"08fa1706fe226db087c2b05c6706a3e7390d14efd7e370a7c8e590fb4c8f716a","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":219,"ts":1791405549.3313289,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"4f4b113f14e43968dafd73f2b1118c2838525bf0a2ded1ddc2859b575b385e6d","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:09","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"topic overtime, currency, base","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular ","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Ra"}},{"detail":"topic longevity, currency, differential","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","label":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local 3535 MOU, Longevity Pay, p.12); corrobo"}}],"counts":{"chosen":2,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"asked":["overtime"],"before_pay_type":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"rule_filter","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:bereavement_shifts","label":"Three (3) shifts of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immedi","reason":"result_type shifts, costing wants currency","ref":{"bbox":[107.28,189.498,505.259,167.118],"clause":"XIV","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":21,"text":"Three (3) shifts of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate family (Local 3535 MOU, Article XIV,"}},{"id":"chief_officers_mou:bereavement_hours","label":"40 hours of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate fami","reason":"cites Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028, not a governing document","ref":{"bbox":[90.7,575.8,526.7,552.8],"clause":"Bereavement Leave (p.14)","doc_id":"chief_officers_mou","page":14,"text":"40 hours of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate family (Chief Officers MOU, Bereavement Leav"}},{"id":"admin_group_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"One and one-half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked in excess of the","reason":"cites Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters), not a governing document","ref":{"bbox":[104.4,137.7,509.6,113.8],"clause":"Overtime (p.6)","doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":6,"text":"One and one-half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked in excess of the normal schedule (Admin Group MOU, Overt"}}]},"prev_hash":"fc12d38eec97f5847d04ab092471d23ca6c681d496cfe0ee7938504772e5beb1","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":220,"ts":1791405549.3377805,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"fe34166817c714fed29dfe4068145bfe6932276838b9347a4c685c7e3258ffa2","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:09","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"approved by analyst (hand-authored 2026-10-07, longevity clause p.12; reviewed against p.38 column) on 2026-10-07","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","label":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local 3535 MOU, Longevity Pay, p.12); corrobo"}},{"detail":"approved by kenny on 2026-07-18","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular ","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Ra"}}],"counts":{"chosen":2,"considered":2},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","total":656.82,"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"rule_select","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"4f4b113f14e43968dafd73f2b1118c2838525bf0a2ded1ddc2859b575b385e6d","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":221,"ts":1791405549.3433554,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f6e3967ebe57b1710be0c1d4cf1bb180676484be6d58e5945928810e376b9c5e","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:12","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver kenny; verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate:multiplier","label":"multiplier: Overtime Rate (p.8)","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"multiplier","name":"multiplier","query":"premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one half times regular rate of pay","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Incremen\u2026","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[141.4304564,423.66664719936,469.2488398472001,414.05279314036005],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Increments."},"value":0.0328},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime \u2026","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.13802712,655.8666107990399,513.7099673408001,552.4045199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who is promoted to a  higher position shall have one half \u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[140.4,272.10672,486.7074593236,236.68452000000002],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who is promoted to a  higher position shall have one half of their . ac\u00e9rued CTO hours paid off at the time "},"value":0.0308},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:5","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0308}]},"prev_hash":"fe34166817c714fed29dfe4068145bfe6932276838b9347a4c685c7e3258ffa2","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":222,"ts":1791405552.9708524,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"ce1f94e7f5e9e1231e5853f7e9f91a73ececb93238274d4cfa4ee2d7fa679ff0","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:16","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver kenny; verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate:regular_rate_definition","label":"regular_rate_definition: Regular Rate of Pay (p.8)","ref":{"bbox":[142.138,655.867,513.71,552.405],"clause":"Regular Rate of Pay (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"definition","name":"regular_rate_definition","query":"regular rate of pay definition overtime","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 2, Regular Rate of Pay","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.92,683.22672,245.16004550399998,675.25128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"2, Regular Rate of Pay"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the r\u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"},"value":0.0317},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:14:5","label":"p.14 \u00b7 \u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to\u2026","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,680.53824,492.481209024,644.9245199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"text":"\u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to the highest level eligible.  Overtime earned on  "},"value":0.0303}]},"prev_hash":"f6e3967ebe57b1710be0c1d4cf1bb180676484be6d58e5945928810e376b9c5e","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":223,"ts":1791405556.3607345,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"7b93f82cd4381d4738408be47dba6e06c24134b34091bceb53a16a8f75ec86fe","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:16","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"from the roster file, printed on the salary schedule","id":"roster:base_hourly:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"base_hourly = 53.4 \u2014 roster row Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","ref":{"bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"clause":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr \u00b7 MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","page":1,"text":"$53.40"},"value":53.4}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"base_hourly","pointer":{"bbox":[110.88,526.566,510.48,489.331],"clause":"Salary Schedule set forth in Appendix A (p.6)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"roster","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"ce1f94e7f5e9e1231e5853f7e9f91a73ececb93238274d4cfa4ee2d7fa679ff0","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":224,"ts":1791405556.3652663,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"e55bccc5de8c5665b8aa9b48e5a55416ee131269cbf79d4e701cb7b24ce75cfb","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:16","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"question:hours","label":"hours = 8.0 \u2014 stated in the question","value":8.0}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"user","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"question","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"7b93f82cd4381d4738408be47dba6e06c24134b34091bceb53a16a8f75ec86fe","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":225,"ts":1791405556.3725588,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"a293c8c8156a21adad80b19c633d10d3599b9bddb08c3c1128f8618871cd6cc6","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:19","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver analyst (hand-authored 2026-10-07, longevity clause p.12; reviewed against p.38 column); verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr:longevity","label":"longevity: Longevity Pay (p.12)","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"Upon completion of ten (10) years of service to the District employees shall receive a 2.5% general salary increase,  Lo"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"multiplier","name":"longevity","query":"longevity pay ten years of service","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:26:2","label":"p.26 \u00b7 Central  Legacy employees that retired on or before December 314,  202\u2026","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[125.64,560.29824,495.720142884,510.91776],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":26,"text":"Central  Legacy employees that retired on or before December 314,  2021, witha minimum of 20 years of service to the Dis"},"value":0.0328},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:12:3","label":"p.12 \u00b7 LONGEVITY PAY","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[143.9682876,290.77405861683997,222.259622984,282.04454394576004],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"LONGEVITY PAY"},"value":0.0318},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:27:4","label":"p.27 \u00b7 tn  the event of the death of a  current employee or retiree, dependen\u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[123.48,244.76976000000002,502.559917056,222.111],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":27,"text":"tn  the event of the death of a  current employee or retiree, dependents will receive the same level of coverage as outl"},"value":0.031},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:27:5","label":"p.27 \u00b7 Aminimum of 15 years of service to the District is required to be elig\u2026","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[140.04,339.894,503.63873496,289.791],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":27,"text":"Aminimum of 15 years of service to the District is required to be eligible for 75% of the amployee only rate of retiree "},"value":0.0303}]},"prev_hash":"e55bccc5de8c5665b8aa9b48e5a55416ee131269cbf79d4e701cb7b24ce75cfb","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":226,"ts":1791405559.708808,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"07f290be6b62eb642143c37bcff8530c495bb95977e24247b887d1dde50c96c1","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:19","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"question:years_of_service","label":"years_of_service = 12.0 \u2014 stated in the question","value":12.0}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"user","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"years_of_service","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","source":"question","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"a293c8c8156a21adad80b19c633d10d3599b9bddb08c3c1128f8618871cd6cc6","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":227,"ts":1791405559.7155044,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"e15905aae9dced6bff398d7ddac2719494e31735229e74f52bd3d440b8738876","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:19","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"effective_base = round(effective_base * 1.025, 6) -> 54.735","inputs":{"effective_base":53.4},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":54.735},"prev_hash":"07f290be6b62eb642143c37bcff8530c495bb95977e24247b887d1dde50c96c1","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":228,"ts":1791405559.721983,"type":"rule.modifier"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"2a4b6e10a04d703bd6e9d4614f07fe2105170487f7a7df222a35d87fca91060a","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:19","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"when: hours > 0 -> True (scope 2, priority 0)","inputs":{"hours":8.0},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":true},"prev_hash":"e15905aae9dced6bff398d7ddac2719494e31735229e74f52bd3d440b8738876","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":229,"ts":1791405559.7262802,"type":"rule.selector_considered"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"f89b887135e3d1559d1d4feb8e9c6fc4731028fb0b721c8dd18c3eef6b6c1eb6","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:19","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"chose firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate (scope 2, priority 0); Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Rate, p.8). Reviewed and approved by the analyst against the clause text; the drafted FLSA 182/192-hour cycle rules were deliberately not approved \u2014 they model the 24-day work period, a different pay branch than a premium overtime shift.","inputs":{},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":656.82},"prev_hash":"2a4b6e10a04d703bd6e9d4614f07fe2105170487f7a7df222a35d87fca91060a","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":230,"ts":1791405559.73061,"type":"rule.selector_chosen"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"25b5ca9b414268839cc19906db4972eb215832eb1c233f7911936f4095c51c7a","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:19","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours = 656.82","expr":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours","inputs":{"effective_base":54.735,"hours":8.0},"line":"$53.40/hr \u00d7 1.025 \u00d7 1.5 \u00d7 8 h = $656.82","operands":[{"kind":"fact","name":"effective_base","role":"rate","source":{"bbox":[503.7,211.1,530.64,202.5],"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","column":"MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","context_bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","field":"base_hourly","kind":"schedule-cell","page":1,"row":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr","row_bbox":[51.227725982666016,522.4412994384766,739.9093627929688,134.97317504882812],"text":"$53.40","title":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)"},"unit":"hour","value":53.4},{"citation":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"char_span":[],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","doc_sha256":"b30076962d29c424864fbe8b05a048911356f7b807b3472f83104aeb921ee800","page":12,"quote_sha256":"582ed036d89a5884"},"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","source":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":12,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr"},"value":1.025},{"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":8,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"value":1.5},{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","role":"hours","source":{"kind":"question","param":"hours"},"value":8.0}],"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":656.82},"prev_hash":"f89b887135e3d1559d1d4feb8e9c6fc4731028fb0b721c8dd18c3eef6b6c1eb6","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":231,"ts":1791405559.734949,"type":"rule.math"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"b112cbf6b6951dd58d380f05639479594a7b729b012a80dd02c06488a30c5706","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:19","payload":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"char_span":[],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","doc_sha256":"b30076962d29c424864fbe8b05a048911356f7b807b3472f83104aeb921ee800","page":12,"quote_sha256":"582ed036d89a5884","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"},"prev_hash":"25b5ca9b414268839cc19906db4972eb215832eb1c233f7911936f4095c51c7a","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":232,"ts":1791405559.739243,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"b8f05efbd8abf273e9d179ba3520e7bc9bdd1e751e5856a7ce61d135c05f4e58","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:19","payload":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"char_span":[],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","doc_sha256":"b30076962d29c424864fbe8b05a048911356f7b807b3472f83104aeb921ee800","page":8,"quote_sha256":"97bd147f7e3aec58","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"},"prev_hash":"b112cbf6b6951dd58d380f05639479594a7b729b012a80dd02c06488a30c5706","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":233,"ts":1791405559.7427864,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"a8d9ed4bfea878a05f7db02c2bc1f743fd078f2352f9f404b639352d3eab2cbb","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:19","payload":{"engine_sha256":"6538a13f34e6e99c4fd9484b93f2beb5af6892ef44bbee48304db8be797b2aa1","math":[{"expr":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours","line":"$53.40/hr \u00d7 1.025 \u00d7 1.5 \u00d7 8 h = $656.82","operands":[{"kind":"fact","name":"effective_base","role":"rate","source":{"bbox":[503.7,211.1,530.64,202.5],"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","column":"MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","context_bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","field":"base_hourly","kind":"schedule-cell","page":1,"row":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr","row_bbox":[51.227725982666016,522.4412994384766,739.9093627929688,134.97317504882812],"text":"$53.40","title":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)"},"unit":"hour","value":53.4},{"citation":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"char_span":[],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","doc_sha256":"b30076962d29c424864fbe8b05a048911356f7b807b3472f83104aeb921ee800","page":12,"quote_sha256":"582ed036d89a5884"},"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","source":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":12,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr"},"value":1.025},{"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":8,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"value":1.5},{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","role":"hours","source":{"kind":"question","param":"hours"},"value":8.0}],"subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"}],"partial":false,"result_sha256":"a00286506ebea5a734c7cf00ef87f44805a02f9683107a47947014b07a8af2e8","result_type":"currency","rules":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","sha256":"07efac20a48d41212702b810cf18f3e43daca430768105948e1b8d76cbfe4e15"},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","sha256":"f55a83eb171ba3b1fa11d358dae6a781a80cf0e7bd639fc43b922f7ca9c54c1e"}],"schema":2,"snapshot":"c3b458223ee7.json","snapshot_sha256":"a3273d39195f054976144922cdb7d10d82b9160cb8478154a5f345da745dc8f3","total":656.82,"uncovered":[]},"prev_hash":"b8f05efbd8abf273e9d179ba3520e7bc9bdd1e751e5856a7ce61d135c05f4e58","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":234,"ts":1791405559.7502632,"type":"answer.snapshot"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"78a2c8216f3906ae64b8d542eaf2fe6cee316caaa4eb7e7a8d76bfa31b306d2a","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:19","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":392,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1200,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":975,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"a8d9ed4bfea878a05f7db02c2bc1f743fd078f2352f9f404b639352d3eab2cbb","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":235,"ts":1791405559.7597558,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"a1cf76be157c31bc1241f4348081fc634f0a8f3753646c26e06ebb3fdbc5f039","iso":"2026-10-07T20:39:19","payload":{"fn":"parse_intent","input_tokens":432,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1213,"output_tokens":81,"prompt_chars":1038,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"78a2c8216f3906ae64b8d542eaf2fe6cee316caaa4eb7e7a8d76bfa31b306d2a","query_id":"c3b458223ee7","seq":236,"ts":1791405559.765465,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"b99c4457e28f1935403e7ec8f729394867fd8d76e774f01c86c2648f850d4920","iso":"2026-10-07T20:41:50","payload":{"caught":4,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","survivors":["drop condition: when hours > 0 -> True","move threshold: 0 -> 0.1","move threshold: 0 -> -0.1"],"total":7,"verdict":"partly tested"},"prev_hash":"a1cf76be157c31bc1241f4348081fc634f0a8f3753646c26e06ebb3fdbc5f039","query_id":null,"seq":237,"ts":1791405710.8289523,"type":"authoring.mutation_check"}
{"actor":"skeptic","alg":"sha256","hash":"bfb4c57e731f33f2a0e4c9ca1c62fae2d1e7d584d59a6cbbda2c2d00a0bb603c","iso":"2026-10-07T20:42:35","payload":{"artifact_sha256":"d298aceb282dd2c19da5f11fc7ff57b7894dca5bf1bab0275d46e61551413e25","fresh":true,"produced_at":"2026-10-07T16:06:27Z","producer":"Claude Code session 2026-10-07","rule_id":"admin_group_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"prev_hash":"b99c4457e28f1935403e7ec8f729394867fd8d76e774f01c86c2648f850d4920","query_id":null,"seq":238,"ts":1791405755.838051,"type":"skeptic.imported"}
{"actor":"skeptic","alg":"sha256","hash":"5da08fded449816445f6b75b56ba872a288efae048e04746d16b3d0494cdc929","iso":"2026-10-07T20:43:01","payload":{"artifact_sha256":"fe21235db9782496babd898331bc9ff9be0f3dadaafd61c6919ecd9aae2bdc36","fresh":true,"produced_at":"2026-10-07T16:05:07Z","producer":"Claude Code session 2026-10-07","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"prev_hash":"bfb4c57e731f33f2a0e4c9ca1c62fae2d1e7d584d59a6cbbda2c2d00a0bb603c","query_id":null,"seq":239,"ts":1791405781.5131564,"type":"skeptic.imported"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"3e3e07ed1d9b28b0980855a8ad7e75623d9614659cc5aad65df64600ab1e1a28","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:57","payload":{"approver":"Kenny Geiler","reason":"not approved by reviewer","rule_ids":["firefighters_local3535_mou:vacation_accrual_1_5","firefighters_local3535_mou:vacation_accrual_6_10","firefighters_local3535_mou:vacation_accrual_11_13","firefighters_local3535_mou:vacation_accrual_14_16"]},"prev_hash":"5da08fded449816445f6b75b56ba872a288efae048e04746d16b3d0494cdc929","query_id":null,"seq":240,"ts":1791406017.9805284,"type":"authoring.denied"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"3301555c26cc449cb09fbf04b59238701140a680003cce099719cf824ccaa66e","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":640.8,"chosen":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"],"expected":640.8,"fired":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"],"passed":true,"per_subject":{"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)":640.8},"scenario":"8-hour overtime shift at base rate, hours beyond the 182-hour threshold, Firefighter/Paramedic top step (1.5x per Local 3535 MOU)","status":"pass"},"prev_hash":"3e3e07ed1d9b28b0980855a8ad7e75623d9614659cc5aad65df64600ab1e1a28","query_id":null,"seq":241,"ts":1791406018.0733867,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"ca33b62a240d78f6da49d4571506073252312b5ef9b8afccddd590e45502a379","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":656.82,"chosen":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"],"expected":656.82,"fired":["firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"],"passed":true,"per_subject":{"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)":656.82},"scenario":"8-hour overtime shift, 12-year Firefighter/Paramedic top step (longevity 2.5% into the 1.5x rate)","status":"pass"},"prev_hash":"3301555c26cc449cb09fbf04b59238701140a680003cce099719cf824ccaa66e","query_id":null,"seq":242,"ts":1791406018.0790248,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"3d1411c18a3f90dc5aa26e45ed553ce7e8a422466fa6db8394b12dc01ae70afa","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":640.8,"chosen":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"],"expected":640.8,"fired":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"],"passed":true,"per_subject":{"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)":640.8},"scenario":"8-hour overtime shift, 9-year Firefighter/Paramedic top step (no longevity; one year short of the p.12 threshold)","status":"pass"},"prev_hash":"ca33b62a240d78f6da49d4571506073252312b5ef9b8afccddd590e45502a379","query_id":null,"seq":243,"ts":1791406018.0832179,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"348fc21a1a624251fa105ad68f2fef457cbbaeb167ca307a8fe1cd04c0316dfc","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":656.82,"chosen":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"],"expected":656.82,"fired":["firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"],"passed":true,"per_subject":{"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)":656.82},"scenario":"8-hour overtime shift, 10-year Firefighter/Paramedic top step (longevity 2.5% from exactly the p.12 threshold)","status":"pass"},"prev_hash":"3d1411c18a3f90dc5aa26e45ed553ce7e8a422466fa6db8394b12dc01ae70afa","query_id":null,"seq":244,"ts":1791406018.0870943,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"612729bd00e95a519b12ac6265ed9793323eb257eacbce965e75a82619b241ec","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":3.0,"chosen":["firefighters_local3535_mou:bereavement_shifts"],"expected":3.0,"fired":["firefighters_local3535_mou:bereavement_shifts"],"passed":true,"per_subject":{"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)":3.0},"scenario":"bereavement leave, Firefighters Local 3535 (Article XIV)","status":"pass"},"prev_hash":"348fc21a1a624251fa105ad68f2fef457cbbaeb167ca307a8fe1cd04c0316dfc","query_id":null,"seq":245,"ts":1791406018.0917983,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"c817c6b113e43a105941b6cefa098fbab0ec958f581ea5ea2db81edb7826c020","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":3.0,"chosen":["firefighters_local3535_mou:bereavement_shifts"],"expected":3.0,"fired":["firefighters_local3535_mou:bereavement_shifts"],"passed":true,"per_subject":{"Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)":3.0},"scenario":"bereavement leave, Battalion Chief (Local 3535 Art. XIV)","status":"pass"},"prev_hash":"612729bd00e95a519b12ac6265ed9793323eb257eacbce965e75a82619b241ec","query_id":null,"seq":246,"ts":1791406018.0976977,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"e91bd6295afaddc32dfbcb49899bcc20bfb8931f8d56bbc14d307b40d57be058","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":40.0,"chosen":["chief_officers_mou:bereavement_hours"],"expected":40.0,"fired":["chief_officers_mou:bereavement_hours"],"passed":true,"per_subject":{"Division Chief (top step)":40.0},"scenario":"bereavement leave, Chief Officers Association (p.14)","status":"pass"},"prev_hash":"c817c6b113e43a105941b6cefa098fbab0ec958f581ea5ea2db81edb7826c020","query_id":null,"seq":247,"ts":1791406018.1020603,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"5c4a30e87fdb3c809da00233aed8dedffc94f44904ddf76fc34529d35d45f6b2","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":716.16,"chosen":["admin_group_mou:overtime_premium_rate"],"expected":716.16,"fired":["admin_group_mou:overtime_premium_rate"],"passed":true,"per_subject":{"Administrative Analyst (top step)":716.16},"scenario":"8-hour overtime shift, Administrative Analyst top step (1.5x per Admin Group MOU)","status":"pass"},"prev_hash":"e91bd6295afaddc32dfbcb49899bcc20bfb8931f8d56bbc14d307b40d57be058","query_id":null,"seq":248,"ts":1791406018.106051,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"776d11cf52937fe5a5e9d98050015e157ed945b0a5b0bea1dd75bbca7d3013ab","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":null,"error":"no base pay rule matched for subject 'Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)'","expected":7.38,"note":"No live rule covers this scenario yet, so Kenny refuses to cost it rather than guessing. Approve the rules for this unit and this check will run.","passed":true,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","status":"pending"},"prev_hash":"5c4a30e87fdb3c809da00233aed8dedffc94f44904ddf76fc34529d35d45f6b2","query_id":null,"seq":249,"ts":1791406018.1101043,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"79284124f0eedadc778c33ac6b71df0cb42e6a8dabad48f2517c47ab538de35d","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":null,"error":"no base pay rule matched for subject 'Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)'","expected":10.15,"note":"No live rule covers this scenario yet, so Kenny refuses to cost it rather than guessing. Approve the rules for this unit and this check will run.","passed":true,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 7-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, OCR-corrected cell)","status":"pending"},"prev_hash":"776d11cf52937fe5a5e9d98050015e157ed945b0a5b0bea1dd75bbca7d3013ab","query_id":null,"seq":250,"ts":1791406018.1149006,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"c29f1fe5d57a7d24f4528649a5eacbd3ee74d197aaf2d7d882a61dcd90cdad30","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":null,"error":"no base pay rule matched for subject 'Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)'","expected":12,"note":"No live rule covers this scenario yet, so Kenny refuses to cost it rather than guessing. Approve the rules for this unit and this check will run.","passed":true,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 12-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 11-13)","status":"pending"},"prev_hash":"79284124f0eedadc778c33ac6b71df0cb42e6a8dabad48f2517c47ab538de35d","query_id":null,"seq":251,"ts":1791406018.1225996,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"573cbea192f73c4a0036ad6662228eed557e781bfab4e07f954e85fdc707d8db","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":null,"error":"no base pay rule matched for subject 'Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)'","expected":13.85,"note":"No live rule covers this scenario yet, so Kenny refuses to cost it rather than guessing. Approve the rules for this unit and this check will run.","passed":true,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 15-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, OCR-corrected cell)","status":"pending"},"prev_hash":"c29f1fe5d57a7d24f4528649a5eacbd3ee74d197aaf2d7d882a61dcd90cdad30","query_id":null,"seq":252,"ts":1791406018.1287613,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"28e9e39b58bd8b6f5ee0747c217adad2e45967cf8cc1c4b5e7183059ac4e272a","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":14.78,"chosen":["firefighters_local3535_mou:vacation_accrual_17_plus"],"expected":14.78,"fired":["firefighters_local3535_mou:vacation_accrual_17_plus"],"passed":true,"per_subject":{"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)":14.78},"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 20-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, OCR-corrected cell)","status":"pass"},"prev_hash":"573cbea192f73c4a0036ad6662228eed557e781bfab4e07f954e85fdc707d8db","query_id":null,"seq":253,"ts":1791406018.1340206,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"cc2c1d62d820619346930efb71f0dde1a3524ecbd1bc7cc37a9f420e25e2b9da","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":null,"error":"no base pay rule matched for subject 'Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)'","expected":7.38,"note":"No live rule covers this scenario yet, so Kenny refuses to cost it rather than guessing. Approve the rules for this unit and this check will run.","passed":true,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 1-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, first year of row 1-5)","status":"pending"},"prev_hash":"28e9e39b58bd8b6f5ee0747c217adad2e45967cf8cc1c4b5e7183059ac4e272a","query_id":null,"seq":254,"ts":1791406018.1403298,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"3a65b89b66d0b7fedecc8e37b0913094fdf02f155d99167f64c83d49373e8e5c","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":null,"error":"no base pay rule matched for subject 'Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)'","expected":7.38,"note":"No live rule covers this scenario yet, so Kenny refuses to cost it rather than guessing. Approve the rules for this unit and this check will run.","passed":true,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 5-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, last year of row 1-5)","status":"pending"},"prev_hash":"cc2c1d62d820619346930efb71f0dde1a3524ecbd1bc7cc37a9f420e25e2b9da","query_id":null,"seq":255,"ts":1791406018.1450503,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"da2324f81ab41901ee22ccc10ca4a6e8a890f3cca446f446d4187ab3b07c30f3","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":null,"error":"no base pay rule matched for subject 'Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)'","expected":10.15,"note":"No live rule covers this scenario yet, so Kenny refuses to cost it rather than guessing. Approve the rules for this unit and this check will run.","passed":true,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 6-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, first year of row 6-10, OCR-corrected cell)","status":"pending"},"prev_hash":"3a65b89b66d0b7fedecc8e37b0913094fdf02f155d99167f64c83d49373e8e5c","query_id":null,"seq":256,"ts":1791406018.154915,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"38e833f052c69e31966bd183df1fe84f617b9dc107ac04a0e5c8ed1f64996ef8","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":null,"error":"no base pay rule matched for subject 'Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)'","expected":10.15,"note":"No live rule covers this scenario yet, so Kenny refuses to cost it rather than guessing. Approve the rules for this unit and this check will run.","passed":true,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 10-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, last year of row 6-10, OCR-corrected cell)","status":"pending"},"prev_hash":"da2324f81ab41901ee22ccc10ca4a6e8a890f3cca446f446d4187ab3b07c30f3","query_id":null,"seq":257,"ts":1791406018.1601825,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"b8031440888ca4716e8647da2c84f87957908ab5ca4bd24cbcde580d6d35b9b6","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":null,"error":"no base pay rule matched for subject 'Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)'","expected":12,"note":"No live rule covers this scenario yet, so Kenny refuses to cost it rather than guessing. Approve the rules for this unit and this check will run.","passed":true,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 11-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, first year of row 11-13)","status":"pending"},"prev_hash":"38e833f052c69e31966bd183df1fe84f617b9dc107ac04a0e5c8ed1f64996ef8","query_id":null,"seq":258,"ts":1791406018.1662219,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"7a679acfda9e3a9298e882f8ad8a381ec45c3b20aa6334c65d67daf849864993","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":null,"error":"no base pay rule matched for subject 'Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)'","expected":12,"note":"No live rule covers this scenario yet, so Kenny refuses to cost it rather than guessing. Approve the rules for this unit and this check will run.","passed":true,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 13-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, last year of row 11-13)","status":"pending"},"prev_hash":"b8031440888ca4716e8647da2c84f87957908ab5ca4bd24cbcde580d6d35b9b6","query_id":null,"seq":259,"ts":1791406018.172244,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"27c2e9eb748205ff04d4d0db94aaa25718e0a109b5b5eb6ac24954b42ef4cc69","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":null,"error":"no base pay rule matched for subject 'Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)'","expected":13.85,"note":"No live rule covers this scenario yet, so Kenny refuses to cost it rather than guessing. Approve the rules for this unit and this check will run.","passed":true,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 14-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, first year of row 14-16, OCR-corrected cell)","status":"pending"},"prev_hash":"7a679acfda9e3a9298e882f8ad8a381ec45c3b20aa6334c65d67daf849864993","query_id":null,"seq":260,"ts":1791406018.17614,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"0a8db421c6627be1b6b4d4cc1cc7290c90d3eb00999810114bba0b4b5c8adfcc","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":null,"error":"no base pay rule matched for subject 'Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)'","expected":13.85,"note":"No live rule covers this scenario yet, so Kenny refuses to cost it rather than guessing. Approve the rules for this unit and this check will run.","passed":true,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 16-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, last year of row 14-16, OCR-corrected cell)","status":"pending"},"prev_hash":"27c2e9eb748205ff04d4d0db94aaa25718e0a109b5b5eb6ac24954b42ef4cc69","query_id":null,"seq":261,"ts":1791406018.1822858,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"a10f5f6e429e8aaec8600886aed4edb1e0c89fd8ab61cddab20379eaf74195f5","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"actual":14.78,"chosen":["firefighters_local3535_mou:vacation_accrual_17_plus"],"expected":14.78,"fired":["firefighters_local3535_mou:vacation_accrual_17_plus"],"passed":true,"per_subject":{"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)":14.78},"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 17-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, first year of row 17+, OCR-corrected cell)","status":"pass"},"prev_hash":"0a8db421c6627be1b6b4d4cc1cc7290c90d3eb00999810114bba0b4b5c8adfcc","query_id":null,"seq":262,"ts":1791406018.1862283,"type":"authoring.golden_check"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"9715588ec2ec0c7e6a1806b86fec43668174e24bcbea18bd571f56ff655b0e3d","iso":"2026-10-07T20:46:58","payload":{"approver":"Kenny Geiler","reason":"unverified OCR cell","rejected":{"firefighters_local3535_mou:vacation_accrual_17_plus":["cited cell firefighters_local3535_mou p.22 row 5 'Vacation Accrual Schedule for all Union Members.| Hours Accrued per .| pay period' reads '; 14,78' in the text layer; the second engine read '14.78' (disputed). Confirm the value on the page image (POST /admin/cell_confirm) before approving."]}},"prev_hash":"a10f5f6e429e8aaec8600886aed4edb1e0c89fd8ab61cddab20379eaf74195f5","query_id":null,"seq":263,"ts":1791406018.2021406,"type":"authoring.blocked"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"1eab1a181ecf4bd3f41c16ee2c6dc54bb2e6968a76634b602b002597b91fafdc","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:47","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"what is the beavement leave for ambulance drivers"},"prev_hash":"9715588ec2ec0c7e6a1806b86fec43668174e24bcbea18bd571f56ff655b0e3d","query_id":"248f63acfc57","seq":264,"ts":1791406067.123471,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"6caccc056f3ab58255f7a6765b15d7310d91ff5c4746bfc7c74ea38ee0fbb2e4","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:47","payload":{"intent":"entitlement"},"prev_hash":"1eab1a181ecf4bd3f41c16ee2c6dc54bb2e6968a76634b602b002597b91fafdc","query_id":"248f63acfc57","seq":265,"ts":1791406067.9997075,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"18070cab324d71efe9831a13a02273966fd2f600d77b8bb6e39c957049eac487","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:48","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"6caccc056f3ab58255f7a6765b15d7310d91ff5c4746bfc7c74ea38ee0fbb2e4","query_id":"248f63acfc57","seq":266,"ts":1791406068.0049767,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"c0f7f4f6dd2998cbc605bc2e80ed7ef714fbabcaea23214f49b41489d6e43e37","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:49","payload":{"date_iso":"","how":"","subjects":[],"units":[]},"prev_hash":"18070cab324d71efe9831a13a02273966fd2f600d77b8bb6e39c957049eac487","query_id":"248f63acfc57","seq":267,"ts":1791406069.2354329,"type":"entitlement.scope"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"086529a33302b8328f7185bbb73acfc8369796189180089e9188c81de4926f89","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:49","payload":{"reason":"no subject or document named"},"prev_hash":"c0f7f4f6dd2998cbc605bc2e80ed7ef714fbabcaea23214f49b41489d6e43e37","query_id":"248f63acfc57","seq":268,"ts":1791406069.240944,"type":"entitlement.clarify"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"d398b2c260d7413ed1046db70465bca5529d0a92c23a30f8912826fdafa5eb12","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:49","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":364,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":868,"output_tokens":14,"prompt_chars":919,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"086529a33302b8328f7185bbb73acfc8369796189180089e9188c81de4926f89","query_id":"248f63acfc57","seq":269,"ts":1791406069.250985,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"dcec1a4c12f7664254f3d93c61c5f3180f389a51503dfd7f2801e5124649ae4c","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:49","payload":{"fn":"parse_intent","input_tokens":404,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1219,"output_tokens":50,"prompt_chars":982,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"d398b2c260d7413ed1046db70465bca5529d0a92c23a30f8912826fdafa5eb12","query_id":"248f63acfc57","seq":270,"ts":1791406069.2574623,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"4f6b1766eef01fb53410b2941b791607058a8053d06b25119b351c3085ec7f76","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:57","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"Paramedic entry step"},"prev_hash":"dcec1a4c12f7664254f3d93c61c5f3180f389a51503dfd7f2801e5124649ae4c","query_id":"190c98e179a6","seq":271,"ts":1791406077.3797433,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"57c6d6814c9f5bc3e86275730a0cbe001a6016cf2f2035402577d2b686f8de8f","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:58","payload":{"intent":"lookup"},"prev_hash":"4f6b1766eef01fb53410b2941b791607058a8053d06b25119b351c3085ec7f76","query_id":"190c98e179a6","seq":272,"ts":1791406078.2274969,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f7c7dfa27556a561e5bbea523f2cec966c60eeb012d2755605a2d6a2e6fc0286","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:58","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"57c6d6814c9f5bc3e86275730a0cbe001a6016cf2f2035402577d2b686f8de8f","query_id":"190c98e179a6","seq":273,"ts":1791406078.2321384,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"b8951d8211db81a7b8deba8c449515e9d3e954b0b471c15887de0bb22e850568","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:58","payload":{"bargaining_units":[],"department":null,"known_departments":["admin","district","fire","management"],"named_docs":[],"scope_how":"corpus","stated":false},"prev_hash":"f7c7dfa27556a561e5bbea523f2cec966c60eeb012d2755605a2d6a2e6fc0286","query_id":"190c98e179a6","seq":274,"ts":1791406078.2425349,"type":"policy.department"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"4e5485e2eaedf11241ccd0707eaf4de7b4a3e8982002d1a06f3a807c8547eb8d","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:58","payload":{"candidate_docs":["firefighters_local3535_mou","admin_group_mou","management_mou","chief_officers_mou","master_salary_schedule"],"corpus_size":5,"declared":5,"department":null,"scope_how":"corpus"},"prev_hash":"b8951d8211db81a7b8deba8c449515e9d3e954b0b471c15887de0bb22e850568","query_id":"190c98e179a6","seq":275,"ts":1791406078.2479193,"type":"retrieval.candidates"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"a7ee17e0c0559cbe8e7c61c5eb5cb5eb1a44541f2e390dcc2c579c9359530047","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:58","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"in scope by corpus","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU"},{"detail":"in scope by corpus","id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU"},{"detail":"in scope by corpus","id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU"},{"detail":"in scope by corpus","id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU"},{"detail":"in scope by corpus","id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule"}],"counts":{"chosen":5,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"department":null,"how":"corpus","named":[]},"fork":"document_scope","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"4e5485e2eaedf11241ccd0707eaf4de7b4a3e8982002d1a06f3a807c8547eb8d","query_id":"190c98e179a6","seq":276,"ts":1791406078.2515733,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"62584fd2b0de1b7f0e23c2f32f6fd021bae94a73122dbb475ca6651341e1ad78","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:58","payload":{"hits":[{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0328},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.032},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0308},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0297},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0294},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":18,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.029},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0283},{"clause":"","doc_id":"chief_officers_mou","page":5,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0276}],"query":"paramedic entry step"},"prev_hash":"a7ee17e0c0559cbe8e7c61c5eb5cb5eb1a44541f2e390dcc2c579c9359530047","query_id":"190c98e179a6","seq":277,"ts":1791406078.340945,"type":"retrieval.hits"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"99436cdef7a4df480cf4c10fdc1cf91e47e90092b7cbd7a18371512f1fa8c372","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:58","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"rank 1","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:12:1","label":"p.12 \u00b7 PARAMEDIC PAY","ref":{"bbox":[144.0,193.98672,221.10197903999997,186.01127999999994],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"PARAMEDIC PAY"},"value":0.0328},{"detail":"rank 2","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:31:2","label":"p.31 \u00b7 PARAMEDIC CERTIFICATIONS AND CONTINUING EDUCATION:","ref":{"bbox":[108.72,393.51096,382.97439561600004,385.89804000000004],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"text":"PARAMEDIC CERTIFICATIONS AND CONTINUING EDUCATION:"},"value":0.032},{"detail":"rank 3","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:6:3","label":"p.6 \u00b7 The agreed base salary of Probationary Firefighter/Paramedic will  be \u2026","ref":{"bbox":[110.52,607.56552,513.720112464,543.591],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6,"text":"The agreed base salary of Probationary Firefighter/Paramedic will  be  18% less than a  Step 1 Firefighter/Paramedic, an"},"value":0.0308},{"detail":"rank 4","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:12:4","label":"p.12 \u00b7 A Firefighter who becomes a  paramedic licensed and accredited by the \u2026","ref":{"bbox":[143.64,167.72975999999994,494.28186537600016,103.94424000000004],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"A Firefighter who becomes a  paramedic licensed and accredited by the State of California and County of Santa Cruz to pe"},"value":0.0297},{"detail":"rank 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:31:5","label":"p.31 \u00b7 When the desired training Is  only available on  a  day that the param\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[108.0,314.14248000000003,505.08047865599997,264.67776000000003],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"text":"When the desired training Is  only available on  a  day that the paramedic is on  duty (assigned shift), the paramedic m"},"value":0.0294},{"detail":"rank 6","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:18:6","label":"p.18 \u00b7 One squad company staffed by one firefighter/paramedic and one driver/\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[159.48,379.04976,464.75982504,356.391026028],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":18,"text":"One squad company staffed by one firefighter/paramedic and one driver/operator."},"value":0.029},{"detail":"rank 7","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:31:7","label":"p.31 \u00b7 Paramedics shall  utilize  local training opportunities when possible,\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[107.28,139.18247999999994,507.959324928,89.71776],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"text":"Paramedics shall  utilize  local training opportunities when possible, to  keep additional costs associated with the cla"},"value":0.0283},{"detail":"rank 8","id":"chief_officers_mou:5:8","label":"p.5 \u00b7 The agreed  difference between steps is 5%. The agreed difference betw\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[88.9199,342.94248000000005,497.1835224,306.52452],"doc_id":"chief_officers_mou","page":5,"text":"The agreed  difference between steps is 5%. The agreed difference between the ranks of Battalion Chief 3  and  Division "},"value":0.0276}],"counts":{"chosen":8,"considered":14,"scope_docs":5,"searched":14},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"coverage":0.452,"query":"paramedic entry step","scope":["firefighters_local3535_mou","admin_group_mou","management_mou","chief_officers_mou","master_salary_schedule"]},"fork":"clause_retrieval","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:31:9","label":"p.31 \u00b7 When attending training for continuing education  requirements on an o\u2026","reason":"rank 9 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[108.36,367.78248,496.44044654399994,332.08452],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"text":"When attending training for continuing education  requirements on an off-duty day, the paramedic shall be compensated by"},"value":0.0275},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:9:10","label":"p.9 \u00b7 Additional incentives for Firefighters,  Firefighter/Paramedics, and  \u2026","reason":"rank 10 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[140.04,626.17824,468.35842953599996,617.47776],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":9,"text":"Additional incentives for Firefighters,  Firefighter/Paramedics, and  Captains:"},"value":0.0267},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:13:11","label":"p.13 \u00b7 2,  The positions of Firefighter and Firefighter/Paramedic are eligibl\u2026","reason":"rank 11 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,475.61400000000003,506.88046620000006,425.42424],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":13,"text":"2,  The positions of Firefighter and Firefighter/Paramedic are eligible to be assigned to a  40-hour position. The agree"},"value":0.0258},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:32:12","label":"p.32 \u00b7 Captains wishing to discontinue their paramedic dutles must submit a  \u2026","reason":"rank 12 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[105.12,640.26432,493.91955878400006,602.3577600000001],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":32,"text":"Captains wishing to discontinue their paramedic dutles must submit a  letter of intent via inter-of\u00cfce memorandum to the"},"value":0.0258},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:29:13","label":"p.29 \u00b7 from a  lower-level supervisor}, the aggrieved employee may bypass STE\u2026","reason":"rank 13 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[108.0,382.90248,478.07974368000004,361.33128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":29,"text":"from a  lower-level supervisor}, the aggrieved employee may bypass STEP 1 & STEP 2, aforementioned."},"value":0.0252},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:31:14","label":"p.31 \u00b7 All  full-time  employees, with the exception of employees maintaining\u2026","reason":"rank 14 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[108.0,461.29824,503.6388739199999,412.10424],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"text":"All  full-time  employees, with the exception of employees maintaining a  paramedic license, shall  have a  valid-EMT ce"},"value":0.0248}]},"prev_hash":"62584fd2b0de1b7f0e23c2f32f6fd021bae94a73122dbb475ca6651341e1ad78","query_id":"190c98e179a6","seq":278,"ts":1791406078.3494053,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"a93f410d567a8ac17178dd9e40b29c0218d7f178749e7e7a0946302c45edb87c","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:58","payload":{"options":["Firefighters Local 3535 MOU","Chief Officers Association MOU"],"reason":"evidence spans multiple bargaining units"},"prev_hash":"99436cdef7a4df480cf4c10fdc1cf91e47e90092b7cbd7a18371512f1fa8c372","query_id":"190c98e179a6","seq":279,"ts":1791406078.3554347,"type":"policy.clarify"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"285f285b8822a53821360d385ae7109c2ba7ffc27441bb1db7ed09b50dd6358d","iso":"2026-10-07T20:47:58","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":356,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":841,"output_tokens":13,"prompt_chars":890,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"a93f410d567a8ac17178dd9e40b29c0218d7f178749e7e7a0946302c45edb87c","query_id":"190c98e179a6","seq":280,"ts":1791406078.3947237,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"8f771c2a585e196d32afa8629a53e0ad817bd2d498b11aa237fa9b22234bc32a","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:00","payload":{"continues":"190c98e179a6","department":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU","doc_id":null,"text":"Paramedic entry step"},"prev_hash":"285f285b8822a53821360d385ae7109c2ba7ffc27441bb1db7ed09b50dd6358d","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":281,"ts":1791406080.7977035,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"36b461e03abb95816b4c3d8a43391d6f01a62b7d1261b6feb8411e4ce511d956","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:01","payload":{"intent":"lookup"},"prev_hash":"8f771c2a585e196d32afa8629a53e0ad817bd2d498b11aa237fa9b22234bc32a","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":282,"ts":1791406081.5133057,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"e1b436011fae497fba08d3acc325a7dfd9ee2bcc4d4266bc74bbeb1c31ab6ad3","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:01","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"36b461e03abb95816b4c3d8a43391d6f01a62b7d1261b6feb8411e4ce511d956","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":283,"ts":1791406081.518031,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"499b60e7878c66f413faafda5ff92dfbcee67f71d3c73fffab5d7f2111184dcd","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:01","payload":{"bargaining_units":[],"department":null,"known_departments":["admin","district","fire","management"],"named_docs":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"scope_how":"document","stated":true},"prev_hash":"e1b436011fae497fba08d3acc325a7dfd9ee2bcc4d4266bc74bbeb1c31ab6ad3","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":284,"ts":1791406081.5317202,"type":"policy.department"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"40a9428fdcfa612a53f931c5127783b270cc2e4194eadcd9b63eb155d5f3d5c7","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:01","payload":{"candidate_docs":["firefighters_local3535_mou","master_salary_schedule"],"corpus_size":5,"declared":5,"department":null,"scope_how":"document"},"prev_hash":"499b60e7878c66f413faafda5ff92dfbcee67f71d3c73fffab5d7f2111184dcd","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":285,"ts":1791406081.5373464,"type":"retrieval.candidates"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"4121fb57469f8940f8ed23acb3a80a1c496c15506701b1838d78991dde48f1a2","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:01","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"in scope by document","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU"},{"detail":"in scope by document","id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule"}],"counts":{"chosen":2,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"department":null,"how":"document","named":["firefighters_local3535_mou"]},"fork":"document_scope","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"}]},"prev_hash":"40a9428fdcfa612a53f931c5127783b270cc2e4194eadcd9b63eb155d5f3d5c7","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":286,"ts":1791406081.5425987,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"c3b9edd7e922998e6b9c9d16ba586752f2426721b15f66f8c4f87986bbf44392","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:01","payload":{"hits":[{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0321},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0313},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0308},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0301},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":29,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0294},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0286},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0285},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":18,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.028}],"query":"paramedic entry step"},"prev_hash":"4121fb57469f8940f8ed23acb3a80a1c496c15506701b1838d78991dde48f1a2","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":287,"ts":1791406081.603411,"type":"retrieval.hits"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"de3ed2edb1791fab365a6de1790239894f1fa3ea2765511f84c7b64ebfcc3188","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:01","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"rank 1","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:12:1","label":"p.12 \u00b7 PARAMEDIC PAY","ref":{"bbox":[144.0,193.98672,221.10197903999997,186.01127999999994],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"PARAMEDIC PAY"},"value":0.0321},{"detail":"rank 2","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:31:2","label":"p.31 \u00b7 PARAMEDIC CERTIFICATIONS AND CONTINUING EDUCATION:","ref":{"bbox":[108.72,393.51096,382.97439561600004,385.89804000000004],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"text":"PARAMEDIC CERTIFICATIONS AND CONTINUING EDUCATION:"},"value":0.0313},{"detail":"rank 3","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:6:3","label":"p.6 \u00b7 The agreed base salary of Probationary Firefighter/Paramedic will  be \u2026","ref":{"bbox":[110.52,607.56552,513.720112464,543.591],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6,"text":"The agreed base salary of Probationary Firefighter/Paramedic will  be  18% less than a  Step 1 Firefighter/Paramedic, an"},"value":0.0308},{"detail":"rank 4","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:12:4","label":"p.12 \u00b7 A Firefighter who becomes a  paramedic licensed and accredited by the \u2026","ref":{"bbox":[143.64,167.72975999999994,494.28186537600016,103.94424000000004],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"A Firefighter who becomes a  paramedic licensed and accredited by the State of California and County of Santa Cruz to pe"},"value":0.0301},{"detail":"rank 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:29:5","label":"p.29 \u00b7 from a  lower-level supervisor}, the aggrieved employee may bypass STE\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[108.0,382.90248,478.07974368000004,361.33128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":29,"text":"from a  lower-level supervisor}, the aggrieved employee may bypass STEP 1 & STEP 2, aforementioned."},"value":0.0294},{"detail":"rank 6","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:31:6","label":"p.31 \u00b7 Paramedics shall  utilize  local training opportunities when possible,\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[107.28,139.18247999999994,507.959324928,89.71776],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"text":"Paramedics shall  utilize  local training opportunities when possible, to  keep additional costs associated with the cla"},"value":0.0286},{"detail":"rank 7","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:31:7","label":"p.31 \u00b7 When the desired training Is  only available on  a  day that the param\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[108.0,314.14248000000003,505.08047865599997,264.67776000000003],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"text":"When the desired training Is  only available on  a  day that the paramedic is on  duty (assigned shift), the paramedic m"},"value":0.0285},{"detail":"rank 8","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:18:8","label":"p.18 \u00b7 One squad company staffed by one firefighter/paramedic and one driver/\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[159.48,379.04976,464.75982504,356.391026028],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":18,"text":"One squad company staffed by one firefighter/paramedic and one driver/operator."},"value":0.028}],"counts":{"chosen":8,"considered":14,"scope_docs":2,"searched":14},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"coverage":0.452,"query":"paramedic entry step","scope":["firefighters_local3535_mou","master_salary_schedule"]},"fork":"clause_retrieval","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:31:9","label":"p.31 \u00b7 When attending training for continuing education  requirements on an o\u2026","reason":"rank 9 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[108.36,367.78248,496.44044654399994,332.08452],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"text":"When attending training for continuing education  requirements on an off-duty day, the paramedic shall be compensated by"},"value":0.0275},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:32:10","label":"p.32 \u00b7 Captains wishing to discontinue their paramedic dutles must submit a  \u2026","reason":"rank 10 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[105.12,640.26432,493.91955878400006,602.3577600000001],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":32,"text":"Captains wishing to discontinue their paramedic dutles must submit a  letter of intent via inter-of\u00cfce memorandum to the"},"value":0.0274},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:29:11","label":"p.29 \u00b7 STEP 5: ARBITRATION","reason":"rank 11 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[107.64,330.30432,204.424443648,318.70368],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":29,"text":"STEP 5: ARBITRATION"},"value":0.0273},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:9:12","label":"p.9 \u00b7 Additional incentives for Firefighters,  Firefighter/Paramedics, and  \u2026","reason":"rank 12 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[140.04,626.17824,468.35842953599996,617.47776],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":9,"text":"Additional incentives for Firefighters,  Firefighter/Paramedics, and  Captains:"},"value":0.0268},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:31:13","label":"p.31 \u00b7 All  full-time  employees, with the exception of employees maintaining\u2026","reason":"rank 13 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[108.0,461.29824,503.6388739199999,412.10424],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31,"text":"All  full-time  employees, with the exception of employees maintaining a  paramedic license, shall  have a  valid-EMT ce"},"value":0.0263},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:13:14","label":"p.13 \u00b7 2,  The positions of Firefighter and Firefighter/Paramedic are eligibl\u2026","reason":"rank 14 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,475.61400000000003,506.88046620000006,425.42424],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":13,"text":"2,  The positions of Firefighter and Firefighter/Paramedic are eligible to be assigned to a  40-hour position. The agree"},"value":0.026}]},"prev_hash":"c3b9edd7e922998e6b9c9d16ba586752f2426721b15f66f8c4f87986bbf44392","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":288,"ts":1791406081.6089103,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"3a2e20eb6c709ca00ca2d50328b271285c247b665c911be28c8def6356f79181","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:04","payload":{"answer":"Quoted from p.12: PARAMEDIC PAY","coverage":0.452,"docs_used":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"lookup":true,"pinned":[],"scope_how":"document","source":"guarded"},"prev_hash":"de3ed2edb1791fab365a6de1790239894f1fa3ea2765511f84c7b64ebfcc3188","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":289,"ts":1791406084.780319,"type":"policy.answer"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"b786963f2a4587a82838c3eb8a7893e74a78353465ee7b8a8ba3c4b943c485ba","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:04","payload":{"bbox":[144.0,193.98672,221.10197903999997,186.01127999999994],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12},"prev_hash":"3a2e20eb6c709ca00ca2d50328b271285c247b665c911be28c8def6356f79181","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":290,"ts":1791406084.7895327,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"9613aea1ed70c1e6acd214c80118daec1c320c7abef4b91d239ad59048eccf6e","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:04","payload":{"bbox":[108.72,393.51096,382.97439561600004,385.89804000000004],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":31},"prev_hash":"b786963f2a4587a82838c3eb8a7893e74a78353465ee7b8a8ba3c4b943c485ba","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":291,"ts":1791406084.7955182,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"c057734c5165732ac11e97ec2f8f3266db2cded9d4706b0b48f523bc9afffbd3","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:04","payload":{"bbox":[110.52,607.56552,513.720112464,543.591],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6},"prev_hash":"9613aea1ed70c1e6acd214c80118daec1c320c7abef4b91d239ad59048eccf6e","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":292,"ts":1791406084.8029895,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"426dc8fe1b4fb3ae2ab26b1ca2360b1038cba65099b5f15e7b84dbc924d3df9b","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:04","payload":{"bbox":[143.64,167.72975999999994,494.28186537600016,103.94424000000004],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12},"prev_hash":"c057734c5165732ac11e97ec2f8f3266db2cded9d4706b0b48f523bc9afffbd3","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":293,"ts":1791406084.8095124,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"1ce0e59bd1980dd8ff0bfda849ac5db0b809c36f020dd5bae7bb797d8de98a41","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:04","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":356,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":704,"output_tokens":13,"prompt_chars":890,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"426dc8fe1b4fb3ae2ab26b1ca2360b1038cba65099b5f15e7b84dbc924d3df9b","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":294,"ts":1791406084.8387182,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"13136b744baaae2e1d18eebe7250a40bdb99edc36e22a03f8ab5672672b65fb3","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:04","payload":{"fn":"answer_policy/lookup","input_tokens":1012,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":3163,"output_tokens":187,"prompt_chars":2830,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"1ce0e59bd1980dd8ff0bfda849ac5db0b809c36f020dd5bae7bb797d8de98a41","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":295,"ts":1791406084.843333,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"3079c0eed263052299610408499f36bcef6fb4476022ffedf47c5b069ed7b14f","iso":"2026-10-07T20:48:04","payload":{"fn":"answer_policy","rule":"ground-check: model figure(s) not in retrieved clauses","source":"fallback","unverified_figures":["3535"]},"prev_hash":"13136b744baaae2e1d18eebe7250a40bdb99edc36e22a03f8ab5672672b65fb3","query_id":"d8a10bdecbea","seq":296,"ts":1791406084.847569,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"6b9b69dda44d8809660c88e28a27f6c9bde8e05819b69cd81981c8b6d781b329","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:18","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4229,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":4905,"output_tokens":318,"prompt_chars":10837,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"3079c0eed263052299610408499f36bcef6fb4476022ffedf47c5b069ed7b14f","query_id":null,"seq":297,"ts":1791406518.9240599,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"c87e2493689b0d6810586ae411afd579fd704a0097f052067678d6fd83215469","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:18","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4549,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":11250,"output_tokens":955,"prompt_chars":11373,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"6b9b69dda44d8809660c88e28a27f6c9bde8e05819b69cd81981c8b6d781b329","query_id":null,"seq":298,"ts":1791406518.9370508,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"17372adfc6f39ec13916453e635afb5bdac4cd99ace369b613fe25855828c3ed","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:18","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4493,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":10799,"output_tokens":1041,"prompt_chars":11283,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"c87e2493689b0d6810586ae411afd579fd704a0097f052067678d6fd83215469","query_id":null,"seq":299,"ts":1791406518.941747,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"19662133c23bce706ac0fce7a3eed27d88267b5329e46dd6744f713eac996973","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:18","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4601,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":4459,"output_tokens":273,"prompt_chars":12011,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"17372adfc6f39ec13916453e635afb5bdac4cd99ace369b613fe25855828c3ed","query_id":null,"seq":300,"ts":1791406518.9498632,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"099e818d7be68fa918fee5b9142c50d29effb94f16e8b511ea710fa0c1ad5d05","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:18","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5328,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":7191,"output_tokens":691,"prompt_chars":15142,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"19662133c23bce706ac0fce7a3eed27d88267b5329e46dd6744f713eac996973","query_id":null,"seq":301,"ts":1791406518.9559941,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"227df736a6b04c7af4489120230785213fc6d9f03db5bdbbc56d10ff24936b36","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:18","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4488,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":7552,"output_tokens":609,"prompt_chars":11921,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"099e818d7be68fa918fee5b9142c50d29effb94f16e8b511ea710fa0c1ad5d05","query_id":null,"seq":302,"ts":1791406518.960208,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"e5a55cb39201ebd438bbbf97056e4b629bf7cdaf17de467bc98c3a55ef2b805b","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:18","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4885,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":18087,"output_tokens":1290,"prompt_chars":13116,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"227df736a6b04c7af4489120230785213fc6d9f03db5bdbbc56d10ff24936b36","query_id":null,"seq":303,"ts":1791406518.9657564,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"6aa04c60d5de4c22c5b010cf0d9378e9efe9127a84ee9f6b3ea2585dc11816ad","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:18","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4706,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":11126,"output_tokens":719,"prompt_chars":12428,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"e5a55cb39201ebd438bbbf97056e4b629bf7cdaf17de467bc98c3a55ef2b805b","query_id":null,"seq":304,"ts":1791406518.969405,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"d4eeba195c445ad5531a4db8377d1a464ff30bed8250e1c3cb260c3bb2a9edb9","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:18","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4360,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":8116,"output_tokens":718,"prompt_chars":11581,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"6aa04c60d5de4c22c5b010cf0d9378e9efe9127a84ee9f6b3ea2585dc11816ad","query_id":null,"seq":305,"ts":1791406518.9730506,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"287ac70828c5c536288e48fe66722bd323354efc7426e998d86fe0938cf4ccb7","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:18","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4412,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":9348,"output_tokens":952,"prompt_chars":11450,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"d4eeba195c445ad5531a4db8377d1a464ff30bed8250e1c3cb260c3bb2a9edb9","query_id":null,"seq":306,"ts":1791406518.977962,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"19358437be52fec9d4b37b45b8c3f3a190cfc340134fd1a7ee26ec9786337930","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:18","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5046,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":14109,"output_tokens":1146,"prompt_chars":13914,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"287ac70828c5c536288e48fe66722bd323354efc7426e998d86fe0938cf4ccb7","query_id":null,"seq":307,"ts":1791406518.981738,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"6895ed11a0b08b32c94c9c6cdbb252bcd8c9f1b9ff917e81a7a1a11564beddb3","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:18","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4910,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":14167,"output_tokens":1421,"prompt_chars":13459,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"19358437be52fec9d4b37b45b8c3f3a190cfc340134fd1a7ee26ec9786337930","query_id":null,"seq":308,"ts":1791406518.985137,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"7e3447b2b709488d494d356b29faf375dd603fad849bb45c561694d14e4770f2","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:18","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4785,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":14895,"output_tokens":1337,"prompt_chars":12754,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"6895ed11a0b08b32c94c9c6cdbb252bcd8c9f1b9ff917e81a7a1a11564beddb3","query_id":null,"seq":309,"ts":1791406518.9890885,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"8847483975f3829b8a67634b615e3e3a297f800a82e676ca2455433d916d05e3","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4990,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":15247,"output_tokens":1476,"prompt_chars":13437,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"7e3447b2b709488d494d356b29faf375dd603fad849bb45c561694d14e4770f2","query_id":null,"seq":310,"ts":1791406519.0051062,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"c3a32d81bde3198fc716a7f24512e1bcc99421b97262b7b8fafe949259680229","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4559,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":12339,"output_tokens":1072,"prompt_chars":12132,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"8847483975f3829b8a67634b615e3e3a297f800a82e676ca2455433d916d05e3","query_id":null,"seq":311,"ts":1791406519.0162077,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"0bb201128211b3b9d813848817d565aa4236f3427f77fd570d60d88732a0e547","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4748,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":22304,"output_tokens":1991,"prompt_chars":12663,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"c3a32d81bde3198fc716a7f24512e1bcc99421b97262b7b8fafe949259680229","query_id":null,"seq":312,"ts":1791406519.0226314,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"2ce4c1902892b3075b435e4b11957975da01c257f043a19203fb86c50e9d1cac","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4621,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":11516,"output_tokens":948,"prompt_chars":12342,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"0bb201128211b3b9d813848817d565aa4236f3427f77fd570d60d88732a0e547","query_id":null,"seq":313,"ts":1791406519.0272021,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"22cadf74af115b92932361d036990e4f7cff0ef24d2320dfa43da9930f2a9402","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4485,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":9005,"output_tokens":753,"prompt_chars":11968,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"2ce4c1902892b3075b435e4b11957975da01c257f043a19203fb86c50e9d1cac","query_id":null,"seq":314,"ts":1791406519.0330114,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"5f6732162cbdd576a0a095b4aff24d638d2a56b0d6d28d0d30809752f8d52541","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4267,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":9859,"output_tokens":873,"prompt_chars":11178,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"22cadf74af115b92932361d036990e4f7cff0ef24d2320dfa43da9930f2a9402","query_id":null,"seq":315,"ts":1791406519.0384288,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"aec6129ffa6bd26dcfc86ef9b40b9dc51f2cc5807c1ba1c267c80e3fe1245300","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4498,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":9097,"output_tokens":757,"prompt_chars":11505,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"5f6732162cbdd576a0a095b4aff24d638d2a56b0d6d28d0d30809752f8d52541","query_id":null,"seq":316,"ts":1791406519.044896,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"5c6e1dfd051b483351dcd1c36fbebe1a606437a83a1b3fbfc79c6f11a1a75421","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4361,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":15412,"output_tokens":1729,"prompt_chars":11110,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"aec6129ffa6bd26dcfc86ef9b40b9dc51f2cc5807c1ba1c267c80e3fe1245300","query_id":null,"seq":317,"ts":1791406519.0501873,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"be4a08c1a33eda5872b2012eee7703c8e1a70697a9fd59fd6fbac622c28756f5","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4082,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":11551,"output_tokens":653,"prompt_chars":10636,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"5c6e1dfd051b483351dcd1c36fbebe1a606437a83a1b3fbfc79c6f11a1a75421","query_id":null,"seq":318,"ts":1791406519.055232,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"4073f56671c9c0f9cb68773c9c4383453d47b05004856da5ea7890147fb3f4a0","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4165,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":7644,"output_tokens":639,"prompt_chars":10929,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"be4a08c1a33eda5872b2012eee7703c8e1a70697a9fd59fd6fbac622c28756f5","query_id":null,"seq":319,"ts":1791406519.0602064,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"ac75316e8fc8c789a8ee069f63c7d8e5f29583c5dd504fa0262cee61d0a8e9b0","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4712,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":13217,"output_tokens":1315,"prompt_chars":12708,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"4073f56671c9c0f9cb68773c9c4383453d47b05004856da5ea7890147fb3f4a0","query_id":null,"seq":320,"ts":1791406519.0652714,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"c2b5c052284cfc55461f35e9f106df9f4fa087a5f34198fc4b00e5bbf84c9cc2","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5263,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":12225,"output_tokens":1221,"prompt_chars":13528,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"ac75316e8fc8c789a8ee069f63c7d8e5f29583c5dd504fa0262cee61d0a8e9b0","query_id":null,"seq":321,"ts":1791406519.070387,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"6cc300925ffdc54220780998a91f895b3b4fd5ed3d8afb01b50bd8e436bc698d","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4588,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":14374,"output_tokens":1342,"prompt_chars":12299,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"c2b5c052284cfc55461f35e9f106df9f4fa087a5f34198fc4b00e5bbf84c9cc2","query_id":null,"seq":322,"ts":1791406519.0746617,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"9483d764db86038cd55e123c2421c8ca5c3b29564c2fc5b8db4aebce3f13b852","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4595,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":11557,"output_tokens":963,"prompt_chars":12323,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"6cc300925ffdc54220780998a91f895b3b4fd5ed3d8afb01b50bd8e436bc698d","query_id":null,"seq":323,"ts":1791406519.0798829,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"279effe6464bace7ed8479a45df6092df9844f5dd5fbdbc153a6144e4c5507ed","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4298,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":10100,"output_tokens":899,"prompt_chars":11271,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"9483d764db86038cd55e123c2421c8ca5c3b29564c2fc5b8db4aebce3f13b852","query_id":null,"seq":324,"ts":1791406519.0841453,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"87c8c816ffa281ce734d54b1d7a10355ad03cace0b16982c9168596f20641ea2","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4266,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":4886,"output_tokens":318,"prompt_chars":11284,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"279effe6464bace7ed8479a45df6092df9844f5dd5fbdbc153a6144e4c5507ed","query_id":null,"seq":325,"ts":1791406519.089803,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"7a496351dce26bd4ee80dcb72431768e79a185669cac60a1d1b9aa5268202b2a","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4192,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":11025,"output_tokens":1006,"prompt_chars":10990,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"87c8c816ffa281ce734d54b1d7a10355ad03cace0b16982c9168596f20641ea2","query_id":null,"seq":326,"ts":1791406519.0944293,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"6083dfb5f2955590a763eb42d8d6c6376f0bc279a0712187fd2794661a2bee49","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4757,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":12406,"output_tokens":1190,"prompt_chars":12695,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"7a496351dce26bd4ee80dcb72431768e79a185669cac60a1d1b9aa5268202b2a","query_id":null,"seq":327,"ts":1791406519.1047106,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"47568965d88e963436d47154a8070da2e9a7803fcb77c53f28d3a7bc1fd27cbc","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4690,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":17097,"output_tokens":1469,"prompt_chars":12599,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"6083dfb5f2955590a763eb42d8d6c6376f0bc279a0712187fd2794661a2bee49","query_id":null,"seq":328,"ts":1791406519.1104634,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"e83358ab53a7525e6ee1d996e8553a28cc9abedc0b779a8e1d2636996ae4671f","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4462,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":8431,"output_tokens":697,"prompt_chars":11894,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"47568965d88e963436d47154a8070da2e9a7803fcb77c53f28d3a7bc1fd27cbc","query_id":null,"seq":329,"ts":1791406519.1156373,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"be48ff36737139f2d77c3a57c7455359c5e5aca08af3bab0e30b1dfe7813924e","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4084,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":4433,"output_tokens":279,"prompt_chars":10753,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"e83358ab53a7525e6ee1d996e8553a28cc9abedc0b779a8e1d2636996ae4671f","query_id":null,"seq":330,"ts":1791406519.1215804,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"7419639dae2920e7a6e57837963a42cb0a7b6a8465bc5448391b8628b7af9245","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4855,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":14658,"output_tokens":1372,"prompt_chars":12976,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"be48ff36737139f2d77c3a57c7455359c5e5aca08af3bab0e30b1dfe7813924e","query_id":null,"seq":331,"ts":1791406519.1263127,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"ff455375d7d6064d0ad3822c54ca68cecc411efc6c6e15684176ba37628a292b","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4209,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":7840,"output_tokens":677,"prompt_chars":11148,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"7419639dae2920e7a6e57837963a42cb0a7b6a8465bc5448391b8628b7af9245","query_id":null,"seq":332,"ts":1791406519.132931,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"2cc92049948f3eece28ccf37ba9005b0a7519f940c9eeb98e3300f3ac0087449","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4419,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":7118,"output_tokens":575,"prompt_chars":11822,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"ff455375d7d6064d0ad3822c54ca68cecc411efc6c6e15684176ba37628a292b","query_id":null,"seq":333,"ts":1791406519.1388564,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"2bd7f465b96521116ebed69b31fc651810764a2204f4102709c7d78e01bc08fd","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4506,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":13633,"output_tokens":1149,"prompt_chars":12040,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"2cc92049948f3eece28ccf37ba9005b0a7519f940c9eeb98e3300f3ac0087449","query_id":null,"seq":334,"ts":1791406519.1446407,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"7b3c218966c107653252fd86c3c0928a7bd880a42b79fde479fbe6d0c9d64c29","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4390,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":4332,"output_tokens":350,"prompt_chars":11721,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"2bd7f465b96521116ebed69b31fc651810764a2204f4102709c7d78e01bc08fd","query_id":null,"seq":335,"ts":1791406519.15045,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"0f284ea412cc95d3b3cec63b85ad7db5d167647975b3a1f7166e257fc38b9eac","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4638,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":5666,"output_tokens":428,"prompt_chars":12409,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"7b3c218966c107653252fd86c3c0928a7bd880a42b79fde479fbe6d0c9d64c29","query_id":null,"seq":336,"ts":1791406519.1557448,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"927d5753aac19d9d75a71ad9dda93836423041cef15a85ad1c09b622efaa7393","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":3954,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":2101,"output_tokens":79,"prompt_chars":10260,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"0f284ea412cc95d3b3cec63b85ad7db5d167647975b3a1f7166e257fc38b9eac","query_id":null,"seq":337,"ts":1791406519.1609163,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"a5a40720b590988d29bb89b76a337acbcc9c5298401ac2d92e537599dec73f68","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4359,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":5665,"output_tokens":366,"prompt_chars":11037,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"927d5753aac19d9d75a71ad9dda93836423041cef15a85ad1c09b622efaa7393","query_id":null,"seq":338,"ts":1791406519.1682057,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"70c48c260317f2892361c5fcae6331732686702cc8a892296cbca999b35ede40","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5334,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":18331,"output_tokens":1425,"prompt_chars":12826,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"a5a40720b590988d29bb89b76a337acbcc9c5298401ac2d92e537599dec73f68","query_id":null,"seq":339,"ts":1791406519.1741939,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"1267356dc8afeeab16f63a518df27e61ddda91ad5b3f89f3b268344f032bb11b","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5295,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":16574,"output_tokens":861,"prompt_chars":12782,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"70c48c260317f2892361c5fcae6331732686702cc8a892296cbca999b35ede40","query_id":null,"seq":340,"ts":1791406519.1841247,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"1255ea72b64f75e8209958afc1ea590f39f30b1fe81d446922d116aadad3c9c6","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5123,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":9311,"output_tokens":626,"prompt_chars":12493,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"1267356dc8afeeab16f63a518df27e61ddda91ad5b3f89f3b268344f032bb11b","query_id":null,"seq":341,"ts":1791406519.191192,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"176527932dda4be7c4cff722f89175e0eea1eb4ba2f711dd2867ae0681d1a1d9","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5304,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":11640,"output_tokens":821,"prompt_chars":12797,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"1255ea72b64f75e8209958afc1ea590f39f30b1fe81d446922d116aadad3c9c6","query_id":null,"seq":342,"ts":1791406519.197558,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"49036677783c6ccb3cc90cf1341dffd7c328085fda9128ddce65b1dd21e257d1","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5280,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":14037,"output_tokens":997,"prompt_chars":12776,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"176527932dda4be7c4cff722f89175e0eea1eb4ba2f711dd2867ae0681d1a1d9","query_id":null,"seq":343,"ts":1791406519.2033515,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"2194afae045c4872219b4b0bd8cc53fe94d728d1ac33da21f421b21a3bbcec0b","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5230,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":12519,"output_tokens":980,"prompt_chars":12691,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"49036677783c6ccb3cc90cf1341dffd7c328085fda9128ddce65b1dd21e257d1","query_id":null,"seq":344,"ts":1791406519.2075777,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"e2ffe7ae31017c648dc7d8970fa39e9e883b16cc399f0d579b2299b7ae192cda","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5302,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":12000,"output_tokens":968,"prompt_chars":12795,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"2194afae045c4872219b4b0bd8cc53fe94d728d1ac33da21f421b21a3bbcec0b","query_id":null,"seq":345,"ts":1791406519.2115877,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"844aed93656866d81643452d6b3dcb4ea8fb2b5a2f82bc36b01aef244965509e","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5171,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":11835,"output_tokens":982,"prompt_chars":12640,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"e2ffe7ae31017c648dc7d8970fa39e9e883b16cc399f0d579b2299b7ae192cda","query_id":null,"seq":346,"ts":1791406519.2180946,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"4d2b2e98786e9fab7fec27da1e9231321ad8ede7d1978d6cb5caa0fa5de310a7","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5373,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":14380,"output_tokens":1176,"prompt_chars":12746,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"844aed93656866d81643452d6b3dcb4ea8fb2b5a2f82bc36b01aef244965509e","query_id":null,"seq":347,"ts":1791406519.2247088,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"2252c5b3c1eae5769ae097cc0e8bc9f87eea0e8c3bc5ff7a072d56c938475c40","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5101,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":17180,"output_tokens":1479,"prompt_chars":12297,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"4d2b2e98786e9fab7fec27da1e9231321ad8ede7d1978d6cb5caa0fa5de310a7","query_id":null,"seq":348,"ts":1791406519.2291822,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"560f2996df00f7b04faf3919fca846c360080894f8291ceef13483ce7c8f4565","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4846,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":23409,"output_tokens":1970,"prompt_chars":11913,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"2252c5b3c1eae5769ae097cc0e8bc9f87eea0e8c3bc5ff7a072d56c938475c40","query_id":null,"seq":349,"ts":1791406519.2338285,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"e4de5d6ae1393f0399f2446fb23d7c2238716c9841fd358f6e6aa8602f17f32e","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5400,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":18557,"output_tokens":1601,"prompt_chars":12784,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"560f2996df00f7b04faf3919fca846c360080894f8291ceef13483ce7c8f4565","query_id":null,"seq":350,"ts":1791406519.241017,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"5ff990d34626ac7d106c40922f8e49cefd675b5b0be372be4acf468c05bc3884","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4847,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":14575,"output_tokens":1291,"prompt_chars":11869,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"e4de5d6ae1393f0399f2446fb23d7c2238716c9841fd358f6e6aa8602f17f32e","query_id":null,"seq":351,"ts":1791406519.2502065,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"ef97c8dcb06d1b86a304b422e91c688ac3a69b1069b5bf9408e99bcb8c1f95f7","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5072,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":18927,"output_tokens":1557,"prompt_chars":12292,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"5ff990d34626ac7d106c40922f8e49cefd675b5b0be372be4acf468c05bc3884","query_id":null,"seq":352,"ts":1791406519.2592475,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"0947507a391c4a591a08173135712ee008f62d47473049c8969908a122f99b6f","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":5340,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":19088,"output_tokens":1772,"prompt_chars":12691,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"ef97c8dcb06d1b86a304b422e91c688ac3a69b1069b5bf9408e99bcb8c1f95f7","query_id":null,"seq":353,"ts":1791406519.2685492,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"49e692d9b052cdc58412802d8409a08c3a379ca6126541ce44c57ad7b84e8947","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":4703,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":18520,"output_tokens":1724,"prompt_chars":11656,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"0947507a391c4a591a08173135712ee008f62d47473049c8969908a122f99b6f","query_id":null,"seq":354,"ts":1791406519.2734368,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"310b1f37e8b9d823bb95c19958d066963cff56b58629aa52453e5b700a48539e","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"fn":"draft_rules","input_tokens":3709,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":8082,"output_tokens":586,"prompt_chars":9788,"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"49e692d9b052cdc58412802d8409a08c3a379ca6126541ce44c57ad7b84e8947","query_id":null,"seq":355,"ts":1791406519.278214,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"d9b269155c13deec141cee5e8845f2c5a049e60fc0c8e80384ebaec4484b52e6","iso":"2026-10-07T20:55:19","payload":{"clauses":["firefighters_local3535_mou:"],"rule_ids":["firefighters_local3535_mou:cto_max_accrual","firefighters_local3535_mou:forty_hour_admin_holiday_leave","firefighters_local3535_mou:bc_40hour_admin_holiday_leave","firefighters_local3535_mou:holiday_hours_total","firefighters_local3535_mou:sick_leave_accrual_56hr","firefighters_local3535_mou:sick_leave_annual_cashout_cap","firefighters_local3535_mou:retirement_sick_leave_comp_cap","firefighters_local3535_mou:separation_sick_leave_comp_cap","firefighters_local3535_mou:vacation_accrual_1_5_years","firefighters_local3535_mou:vacation_accrual_6_10_years","firefighters_local3535_mou:vacation_accrual_11_13_years","firefighters_local3535_mou:vacation_accrual_14_16_years","firefighters_local3535_mou:vacation_accrual_17_plus_years","firefighters_local3535_mou:union_leave_bank_annual_contribution","firefighters_local3535_mou:paramedic_travel_time_allowance","firefighters_local3535_mou:education_time_off_annual"],"scenario":"vacation accrual per pay period, 3-year member (Local 3535 XV table p.22, row 1-5)","verify":"fail"},"prev_hash":"310b1f37e8b9d823bb95c19958d066963cff56b58629aa52453e5b700a48539e","query_id":null,"seq":356,"ts":1791406519.3053374,"type":"authoring.draft_scenario"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"8cdb8234f5a6c3ed03920f8d25b608e34044ea754fc7c5085e2da1436956c0ea","iso":"2026-10-07T21:33:57","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"Cost an 8-hour overtime shift for a Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"},"prev_hash":"d9b269155c13deec141cee5e8845f2c5a049e60fc0c8e80384ebaec4484b52e6","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":357,"ts":1791408837.4759085,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f0e0fe62fe0783c5844c912ec0fbcef84899ba025e6dd8b0a5c36da5e83cade9","iso":"2026-10-07T21:33:58","payload":{"intent":"costing"},"prev_hash":"8cdb8234f5a6c3ed03920f8d25b608e34044ea754fc7c5085e2da1436956c0ea","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":358,"ts":1791408838.6955035,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"65e981dcb21f9aae9e84f8756ae7acb84a64ea2529ac2d34df0b2354e0b54842","iso":"2026-10-07T21:33:58","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"f0e0fe62fe0783c5844c912ec0fbcef84899ba025e6dd8b0a5c36da5e83cade9","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":359,"ts":1791408838.704245,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"c7945ac779006dba1d7e82963b6f30b481d9a231ef0e7d1ee6dd83e2241df3e8","iso":"2026-10-07T21:33:59","payload":{"date":"","holiday_weekday":"","hours":8.0,"pay_type":"overtime","source":"claude","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"years_of_service":0.0},"prev_hash":"65e981dcb21f9aae9e84f8756ae7acb84a64ea2529ac2d34df0b2354e0b54842","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":360,"ts":1791408839.9880939,"type":"llm.parse_intent"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"7d749cad2449a732fdc9ece9323879f47667d9a7611c5156e54d833206c09e98","iso":"2026-10-07T21:33:59","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"named in the question","id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":13},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"subject","rejected":[{"id":"roster:Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Captain, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","label":"Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Apparatus Technician, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Division Chief (top step)","label":"Division Chief (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Division Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=chief-officers not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Marshal (top step)","label":"Fire Marshal (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=fire, rank=Fire Marshal, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=management not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Analyst (top step)","label":"Administrative Analyst (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Analyst, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Assistant (top step)","label":"Administrative Assistant (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Assistant, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Inspector (top step)","label":"Fire Inspector (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Inspector, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"}]},"prev_hash":"c7945ac779006dba1d7e82963b6f30b481d9a231ef0e7d1ee6dd83e2241df3e8","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":361,"ts":1791408839.9937053,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"b139752a29d4c16e645136958bdeed845cfb9f579337f7b005077a226f8aaa07","iso":"2026-10-07T21:33:59","payload":{"adapter":"csv","bargaining_units":["firefighters-local-3535"],"data_sha256":"1cfcfdfed61c7a854330452d40bff756dfc9645a4bca55fb715821ba59bff2a4","fields":["classification","department","rank","base_hourly","shift","bargaining_unit","name"],"records":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","base_hourly":53.4,"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","department":"fire","name":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","rank":"Firefighter/Paramedic","shift":"Suppression"}],"rows":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"shift_date":null},"prev_hash":"7d749cad2449a732fdc9ece9323879f47667d9a7611c5156e54d833206c09e98","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":362,"ts":1791408839.9996219,"type":"data.read"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"2ad9fa96ae0d1537aa9ff1d2be48fcaded5139f5d45768c4595c0eadffe0ad0b","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:00","payload":{"checks":[{"agree":true,"deterministic":8.0,"field":"hours","model":8.0},{"agree":true,"deterministic":"overtime","field":"pay_type","model":null}],"date_iso":null,"date_note":"no date given","hours":8.0,"parsed_via":"claude","pay_type":"overtime","read_as":"8 h \u00b7 overtime \u00b7 Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step) \u00b7 no date given","subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"years_note":null,"years_of_service":null},"prev_hash":"b139752a29d4c16e645136958bdeed845cfb9f579337f7b005077a226f8aaa07","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":363,"ts":1791408840.0105753,"type":"chat.interpretation"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"3a6fbb09c7b141ae0aad7803c7d178e1d26623639f04c4475263f9012c275e7f","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:00","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","date":null,"matched":[{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","effective_end":"2028-12-31","effective_start":"2025-12-20","mou_version":"L3535-2025","why":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only"}],"reason":"resolved by governance: units ['firefighters-local-3535'] + date None -> MOU(s) ['firefighters_local3535_mou']","resolved":true,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"units":["firefighters-local-3535"]},"prev_hash":"2ad9fa96ae0d1537aa9ff1d2be48fcaded5139f5d45768c4595c0eadffe0ad0b","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":364,"ts":1791408840.0251868,"type":"governance.resolve"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"6c910596e05c7e09ad3c174b53677fed1921228b0c47eb3d0b2c9627f6b8056c","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:00","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"unit 'firefighters-local-3535' matches; no date given; unit match only","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"date":null,"subjects":["Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"governance","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters)","reason":"unit admin-group \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter)","reason":"unit management \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028","reason":"unit chief-officers \u2260 firefighters-local-3535"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)","reason":"doc_type salary-schedule is not an MOU or amendment"}]},"prev_hash":"3a6fbb09c7b141ae0aad7803c7d178e1d26623639f04c4475263f9012c275e7f","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":365,"ts":1791408840.0333602,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"06e7c15d27ebf5fde4223070d3c5914065b80b0e84a68c608d25f37c541dd1bd","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:00","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"topic overtime, currency, base","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular ","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Ra"}},{"detail":"topic longevity, currency, differential","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","label":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local 3535 MOU, Longevity Pay, p.12); corrobo"}}],"counts":{"chosen":2,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"asked":["overtime"],"before_pay_type":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr"],"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"rule_filter","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:bereavement_shifts","label":"Three (3) shifts of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immedi","reason":"result_type shifts, costing wants currency","ref":{"bbox":[107.28,189.498,505.259,167.118],"clause":"XIV","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":21,"text":"Three (3) shifts of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate family (Local 3535 MOU, Article XIV,"}},{"id":"chief_officers_mou:bereavement_hours","label":"40 hours of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate fami","reason":"cites Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028, not a governing document","ref":{"bbox":[90.7,575.8,526.7,552.8],"clause":"Bereavement Leave (p.14)","doc_id":"chief_officers_mou","page":14,"text":"40 hours of paid bereavement leave upon a death in the employee's immediate family (Chief Officers MOU, Bereavement Leav"}},{"id":"admin_group_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"One and one-half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked in excess of the","reason":"cites Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters), not a governing document","ref":{"bbox":[104.4,137.7,509.6,113.8],"clause":"Overtime (p.6)","doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":6,"text":"One and one-half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked in excess of the normal schedule (Admin Group MOU, Overt"}}]},"prev_hash":"6c910596e05c7e09ad3c174b53677fed1921228b0c47eb3d0b2c9627f6b8056c","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":366,"ts":1791408840.0413015,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"2751b9baeb160ae93dd92a8505d758518497fb987cb886e7824e9c1529451fba","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:00","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"approved by kenny on 2026-07-18","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","label":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular ","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Ra"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":2},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","total":640.8,"unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"rule_select","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:longevity_10yr","label":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local","reason":"when 'years_of_service >= 10' -> False","ref":{"bbox":[143.606,263.49,511.56,212.751],"clause":"Longevity Pay (p.12)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":12,"text":"2.5% general salary increase upon completion of ten (10) years of service (Local 3535 MOU, Longevity Pay, p.12); corrobo"}}]},"prev_hash":"06e7c15d27ebf5fde4223070d3c5914065b80b0e84a68c608d25f37c541dd1bd","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":367,"ts":1791408840.0499744,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"b40789da28f6fb7f6812ec6b05ac748b96b229bc6ed7290ca1df45eeb209b08e","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:03","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver kenny; verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate:multiplier","label":"multiplier: Overtime Rate (p.8)","ref":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"multiplier","name":"multiplier","query":"premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one half times regular rate of pay","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Incremen\u2026","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[141.4304564,423.66664719936,469.2488398472001,414.05279314036005],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Increments."},"value":0.0328},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime \u2026","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.13802712,655.8666107990399,513.7099673408001,552.4045199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who is promoted to a  higher position shall have one half \u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[140.4,272.10672,486.7074593236,236.68452000000002],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who is promoted to a  higher position shall have one half of their . ac\u00e9rued CTO hours paid off at the time "},"value":0.0308},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:5","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0308}]},"prev_hash":"2751b9baeb160ae93dd92a8505d758518497fb987cb886e7824e9c1529451fba","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":368,"ts":1791408843.7633145,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"4878e6dd400cefe200dce79993231832165dc1b045f1a3ab201fb077bd800a60","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:06","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"declared by approver kenny; verified by search rank #1 of 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate:regular_rate_definition","label":"regular_rate_definition: Regular Rate of Pay (p.8)","ref":{"bbox":[142.138,655.867,513.71,552.405],"clause":"Regular Rate of Pay (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"}}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5,"searched":5},"decided_by":"human-rule","detail":{"kind":"definition","name":"regular_rate_definition","query":"regular rate of pay definition overtime","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"clause","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 2, Regular Rate of Pay","reason":"rank 2, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.92,683.22672,245.16004550399998,675.25128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"2, Regular Rate of Pay"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","reason":"rank 3, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0325},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:4","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the r\u2026","reason":"rank 4, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"},"value":0.0317},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:14:5","label":"p.14 \u00b7 \u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to\u2026","reason":"rank 5, not the declared clause","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,680.53824,492.481209024,644.9245199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"text":"\u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to the highest level eligible.  Overtime earned on  "},"value":0.0303}]},"prev_hash":"b40789da28f6fb7f6812ec6b05ac748b96b229bc6ed7290ca1df45eeb209b08e","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":369,"ts":1791408846.8657837,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"b128e77fd4bd3dcf727f19171663a519c950d9772d7fd23b8bd0e312fe2c7e63","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:06","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"from the roster file, printed on the salary schedule","id":"roster:base_hourly:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"base_hourly = 53.4 \u2014 roster row Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","ref":{"bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"clause":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr \u00b7 MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","page":1,"text":"$53.40"},"value":53.4}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"base_hourly","pointer":{"bbox":[110.88,526.566,510.48,489.331],"clause":"Salary Schedule set forth in Appendix A (p.6)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"roster","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"4878e6dd400cefe200dce79993231832165dc1b045f1a3ab201fb077bd800a60","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":370,"ts":1791408846.8749146,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"cd9d139082cbbd365e47d91cea34ff861be73351a6092a2993f5fb61a09c3b17","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:07","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"question:hours","label":"hours = 8.0 \u2014 stated in the question","value":8.0}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":1},"decided_by":"user","detail":{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":"question","unit":"firefighters-local-3535"},"fork":"input","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"b128e77fd4bd3dcf727f19171663a519c950d9772d7fd23b8bd0e312fe2c7e63","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":371,"ts":1791408847.2518983,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"cfa2975e92267e0f22deaf6ea36c883df69524ca5b0b7a385625b904f4c4bd91","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:07","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"when: hours > 0 -> True (scope 2, priority 0)","inputs":{"hours":8.0},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":true},"prev_hash":"cd9d139082cbbd365e47d91cea34ff861be73351a6092a2993f5fb61a09c3b17","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":372,"ts":1791408847.2603276,"type":"rule.selector_considered"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"acddcd9d9261637e9a3ad308eca9b660a14280c241da691b5e19f947138d941b","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:07","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"chose firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate (scope 2, priority 0); Premium overtime compensation at one and one half (1.5x) the employee's regular rate of pay (Local 3535 MOU, Overtime Rate, p.8). Reviewed and approved by the analyst against the clause text; the drafted FLSA 182/192-hour cycle rules were deliberately not approved \u2014 they model the 24-day work period, a different pay branch than a premium overtime shift.","inputs":{},"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":640.8},"prev_hash":"cfa2975e92267e0f22deaf6ea36c883df69524ca5b0b7a385625b904f4c4bd91","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":373,"ts":1791408847.2655883,"type":"rule.selector_chosen"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"c8323a104deaad1df92e64730c954281c0c2a02c2b9652a75eec6ff7acd48e2b","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:07","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"firefighters-local-3535","detail":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours = 640.8","expr":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours","inputs":{"effective_base":53.4,"hours":8.0},"line":"$53.40/hr \u00d7 1.5 \u00d7 8 h = $640.80","operands":[{"kind":"fact","name":"effective_base","role":"rate","source":{"bbox":[503.7,211.1,530.64,202.5],"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","column":"MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","context_bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","field":"base_hourly","kind":"schedule-cell","page":1,"row":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr","row_bbox":[51.227725982666016,522.4412994384766,739.9093627929688,134.97317504882812],"text":"$53.40","title":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)"},"unit":"hour","value":53.4},{"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":8,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"value":1.5},{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","role":"hours","source":{"kind":"question","param":"hours"},"value":8.0}],"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","value":640.8},"prev_hash":"acddcd9d9261637e9a3ad308eca9b660a14280c241da691b5e19f947138d941b","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":374,"ts":1791408847.2698345,"type":"rule.math"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"b59962826132339e7f5a74c53fe23535edd617b9feaa331b755f3629cebd579f","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:07","payload":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"char_span":[],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","doc_sha256":"b30076962d29c424864fbe8b05a048911356f7b807b3472f83104aeb921ee800","page":8,"quote_sha256":"97bd147f7e3aec58","subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"},"prev_hash":"c8323a104deaad1df92e64730c954281c0c2a02c2b9652a75eec6ff7acd48e2b","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":375,"ts":1791408847.2747421,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"7909e261d86aaa4a370537f81cc3ab9f1af84e24a50833b4ec417187294f6d21","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:07","payload":{"engine_sha256":"6538a13f34e6e99c4fd9484b93f2beb5af6892ef44bbee48304db8be797b2aa1","math":[{"expr":"effective_base * 1.5 * hours","line":"$53.40/hr \u00d7 1.5 \u00d7 8 h = $640.80","operands":[{"kind":"fact","name":"effective_base","role":"rate","source":{"bbox":[503.7,211.1,530.64,202.5],"classification":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","column":"MAXIMUM HOURLY RATE","context_bbox":[53.52,213.1,530.64,200.34],"doc_id":"master_salary_schedule","field":"base_hourly","kind":"schedule-cell","page":1,"row":"FIREFIGHTER/PARAMEDIC- 56 hr","row_bbox":[51.227725982666016,522.4412994384766,739.9093627929688,134.97317504882812],"text":"$53.40","title":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)"},"unit":"hour","value":53.4},{"kind":"const","role":"multiplier","rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","source":{"bbox":[141.418,505.662,511.182,441.459],"clause":"Overtime Rate (p.8)","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","kind":"clause","page":8,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"},"value":1.5},{"kind":"fact","name":"hours","role":"hours","source":{"kind":"question","param":"hours"},"value":8.0}],"subject":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)"}],"partial":false,"result_sha256":"bb116678b8f7b093f053d4ad463f7eb960cf201821ec3756019ee19baf33dbb5","result_type":"currency","rules":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","sha256":"07efac20a48d41212702b810cf18f3e43daca430768105948e1b8d76cbfe4e15"}],"schema":2,"snapshot":"5d72c037f9e3.json","snapshot_sha256":"c2e104044b6f6d086db370159e365f0247555c036138fb6b9a561580087defa5","total":640.8,"uncovered":[]},"prev_hash":"b59962826132339e7f5a74c53fe23535edd617b9feaa331b755f3629cebd579f","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":376,"ts":1791408847.2875013,"type":"answer.snapshot"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"5428a6d13e4d4e46a7b8f1af010a14a9aab5d67a4fe7571e01758d33ab804c45","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:07","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":384,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1210,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":945,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"7909e261d86aaa4a370537f81cc3ab9f1af84e24a50833b4ec417187294f6d21","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":377,"ts":1791408847.300325,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"d246a36cfe1c6a6b81fa73b44b1978a3041613bcfc3255afdf4b5eb29e74a2ee","iso":"2026-10-07T21:34:07","payload":{"fn":"parse_intent","input_tokens":424,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1275,"output_tokens":78,"prompt_chars":1008,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"5428a6d13e4d4e46a7b8f1af010a14a9aab5d67a4fe7571e01758d33ab804c45","query_id":"5d72c037f9e3","seq":378,"ts":1791408847.3055553,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"b9408668b5efc690b9085410959368259b5d40e052d668a75e36fa913963af75","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:18","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"How is premium overtime compensated under the Firefighters Local 3535 MOU?"},"prev_hash":"d246a36cfe1c6a6b81fa73b44b1978a3041613bcfc3255afdf4b5eb29e74a2ee","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":379,"ts":1791409098.431142,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"8cf71f2dbafe27be073f2557a8d1cfeacb0eecf2afef91c28fd8919af9f99f64","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:19","payload":{"intent":"policy"},"prev_hash":"b9408668b5efc690b9085410959368259b5d40e052d668a75e36fa913963af75","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":380,"ts":1791409099.1950788,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"b797b23b44d1738d3d147e698aeafe099eca3801d9c9b81813033dc334999820","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:19","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"8cf71f2dbafe27be073f2557a8d1cfeacb0eecf2afef91c28fd8919af9f99f64","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":381,"ts":1791409099.201265,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"98001c47ee5967780c7b1849600be6f44c6cbea006a7a3a3491cb670608fd97a","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:19","payload":{"bargaining_units":[],"department":null,"known_departments":["admin","district","fire","management"],"named_docs":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"scope_how":"document","stated":false},"prev_hash":"b797b23b44d1738d3d147e698aeafe099eca3801d9c9b81813033dc334999820","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":382,"ts":1791409099.2137074,"type":"policy.department"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"7e2ab0594f78a154800dd58c143779088c1709e781e03cca4572bdd2498fc78a","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:19","payload":{"candidate_docs":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"corpus_size":5,"declared":5,"department":null,"scope_how":"document"},"prev_hash":"98001c47ee5967780c7b1849600be6f44c6cbea006a7a3a3491cb670608fd97a","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":383,"ts":1791409099.220333,"type":"retrieval.candidates"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"2f835eb6093e0349a9db6a2d3d9761c2cd953f5b6554ed25d4873eb364baf268","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:19","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"in scope by document","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"department":null,"how":"document","named":["firefighters_local3535_mou"]},"fork":"document_scope","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule","reason":"not the document the question named"}]},"prev_hash":"7e2ab0594f78a154800dd58c143779088c1709e781e03cca4572bdd2498fc78a","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":384,"ts":1791409099.2243905,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"dc3e567c15150c0a2ae6e026c4933673b67249bcbca0a438ac8c8536294a8d1d","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:19","payload":{"hits":[{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","score":0.0331},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.032},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0315},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0313},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0312},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":17,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0299},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0292},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":16,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0286}],"query":"premium overtime compensated"},"prev_hash":"2f835eb6093e0349a9db6a2d3d9761c2cd953f5b6554ed25d4873eb364baf268","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":385,"ts":1791409099.3521273,"type":"retrieval.hits"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"bc549279f8bb88ee332330e571d60bb31d21aef2c9f64ee36cb1d522b894196f","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:19","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"rank 1, pinned by firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:1","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the r\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"},"value":0.0331},{"detail":"rank 2","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime \u2026","ref":{"bbox":[142.13802712,655.8666107990399,513.7099673408001,552.4045199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"},"value":0.032},{"detail":"rank 3","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0315},{"detail":"rank 4","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:7:4","label":"p.7 \u00b7 B. OVERTIME","ref":{"bbox":[126.36,500.34671999999995,189.45993787200004,492.01128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"text":"B. OVERTIME"},"value":0.0313},{"detail":"rank 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:5","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Incremen\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[141.4304564,423.66664719936,469.2488398472001,414.05279314036005],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Increments."},"value":0.0312},{"detail":"rank 6","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:17:6","label":"p.17 \u00b7 Upon activation from standby status to duty status because of District\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[109.08,259.254,499.680126,209.23775999999998],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":17,"text":"Upon activation from standby status to duty status because of District need, stand by pay ends and the employee Is compe"},"value":0.0299},{"detail":"rank 7","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:14:7","label":"p.14 \u00b7 \u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,680.53824,492.481209024,644.9245199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"text":"\u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to the highest level eligible.  Overtime earned on  "},"value":0.0292},{"detail":"rank 8","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:16:8","label":"p.16 \u00b7 If an  employee Is assigned  Duty Coverage, they will be compensated $\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[110.88,168.894,493.19975700000003,146.32452],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":16,"text":"If an  employee Is assigned  Duty Coverage, they will be compensated $550/week for the assignment."},"value":0.0286}],"counts":{"chosen":8,"considered":14,"scope_docs":1,"searched":14},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"coverage":0.71,"query":"premium overtime compensated","scope":["firefighters_local3535_mou"]},"fork":"clause_retrieval","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:7:9","label":"p.7 \u00b7 Central  Fire  District has established a  24-day work periad and ther\u2026","reason":"rank 9 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[142.92,352.32552,516.239910504,247.22426706912006],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"text":"Central  Fire  District has established a  24-day work periad and therefore employees are entitled to FLSA-overtime for "},"value":0.0285},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:6:10","label":"p.6 \u00b7 Those employees required to work out of class (upward) shall be compen\u2026","reason":"rank 10 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[144.0,229.20551999999998,523.4385373712377,96.29728],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6,"text":"Those employees required to work out of class (upward) shall be compensated at the same rate of pay that they would rece"},"value":0.0281},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:11","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Bargaining-unit employees are eligible to receive earned overtime in t\u2026","reason":"rank 11 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[141.07002260000002,367.50661079904,495.7171106528,331.99775999999997],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Bargaining-unit employees are eligible to receive earned overtime in the form of compensatory time off. The maximum accu"},"value":0.0278},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:7:12","label":"p.7 \u00b7 Employees who work in a  higher class in  an acting position or tempor\u2026","reason":"rank 12 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[138.5527723617,678.4012799999999,505.082966544,573.2975057002689],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"text":"Employees who work in a  higher class in  an acting position or temporary upgrade _assignment shall  have.any Out of Cla"},"value":0.0277},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:26:13","label":"p.26 \u00b7 Central  Legacy employees that retired on or before December 314,  202\u2026","reason":"rank 13 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[125.64,560.29824,495.720142884,510.91776],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":26,"text":"Central  Legacy employees that retired on or before December 314,  2021, witha minimum of 20 years of service to the Dis"},"value":0.0264},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:23:14","label":"p.23 \u00b7 When a  bargaining unit member has received the appropriate approval t\u2026","reason":"rank 14 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[105.12,261.13816058112,503.639548416,170.44452],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":23,"text":"When a  bargaining unit member has received the appropriate approval to be absent from their scheduled shift(s) to atten"},"value":0.0253}]},"prev_hash":"dc3e567c15150c0a2ae6e026c4933673b67249bcbca0a438ac8c8536294a8d1d","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":386,"ts":1791409099.361093,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"b3358bfc0b7e21b419e8a2446c0696e43609390de9e515283600de39136ade4a","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:22","payload":{"answer":"Quoted from p.8: Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee's 'regular rate of pay', as that term is defined under the  FLSA,  for all  the time worked or deemed to have been worked in excess of 182 hours In  a  24-day work period.  For the purpose of determining overtime, the words 'deemed to have been worked' shall  include all paid  le","coverage":0.71,"docs_used":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"lookup":false,"pinned":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"],"scope_how":"document","source":"guarded"},"prev_hash":"bc549279f8bb88ee332330e571d60bb31d21aef2c9f64ee36cb1d522b894196f","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":387,"ts":1791409102.7868955,"type":"policy.answer"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"0bb70fdafd943e37c6daf4793f0e91029f9b45fe4dffc9a8055d14f90d93b06f","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:22","payload":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8},"prev_hash":"b3358bfc0b7e21b419e8a2446c0696e43609390de9e515283600de39136ade4a","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":388,"ts":1791409102.7923117,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"e431c96a8569f59f162db4e36dbdf95669424b2fffd1b49ff365451cf7b5a049","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:22","payload":{"bbox":[142.13802712,655.8666107990399,513.7099673408001,552.4045199999999],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8},"prev_hash":"0bb70fdafd943e37c6daf4793f0e91029f9b45fe4dffc9a8055d14f90d93b06f","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":389,"ts":1791409102.797375,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"f61132e3d4728df7851b9c90b65f5bc0cc657037b2955f3c2ebc3a5d11483e36","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:22","payload":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8},"prev_hash":"e431c96a8569f59f162db4e36dbdf95669424b2fffd1b49ff365451cf7b5a049","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":390,"ts":1791409102.8014202,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"8bfa89261c87942ed4d7e2e281f20c7e4a9b4e9426ad205b18d446ffea585222","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:22","payload":{"bbox":[126.36,500.34671999999995,189.45993787200004,492.01128],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7},"prev_hash":"f61132e3d4728df7851b9c90b65f5bc0cc657037b2955f3c2ebc3a5d11483e36","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":391,"ts":1791409102.8057446,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"0a8f9205c6a74b15778661f406efaf7c471875f48034bd1e6d0f91b3334d3ca7","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:22","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":375,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":755,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":944,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"8bfa89261c87942ed4d7e2e281f20c7e4a9b4e9426ad205b18d446ffea585222","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":392,"ts":1791409102.8315136,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"8800b208c91201c1819a944cd76699ce93e4634842d7520f058f93a73b1d1f2c","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:22","payload":{"fn":"answer_policy","input_tokens":815,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":3419,"output_tokens":317,"prompt_chars":2246,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"0a8f9205c6a74b15778661f406efaf7c471875f48034bd1e6d0f91b3334d3ca7","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":393,"ts":1791409102.8380685,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"114659d35e1d0ad44ec5c0ecd1968efa22e695e8896ebc7ec841064eca730d15","iso":"2026-10-07T21:38:22","payload":{"fn":"answer_policy","rule":"ground-check: model figure(s) not in retrieved clauses","source":"fallback","unverified_figures":["1.5"]},"prev_hash":"8800b208c91201c1819a944cd76699ce93e4634842d7520f058f93a73b1d1f2c","query_id":"ae8e8d009224","seq":394,"ts":1791409102.8428562,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"8e5b42ac9f6f86d8137ed39dd6f78eacd6fcb2d450930fc1846b1435f827726d","iso":"2026-10-07T21:39:14","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"Cost an 8-hour overtime shift for a Fire Marshal (top step)"},"prev_hash":"114659d35e1d0ad44ec5c0ecd1968efa22e695e8896ebc7ec841064eca730d15","query_id":"0e430d1582da","seq":395,"ts":1791409154.990495,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"f73205b9df2d22357ec7c97811e8514ed6aed136a464e5442b481ce3ee9e6b7e","iso":"2026-10-07T21:39:15","payload":{"intent":"costing"},"prev_hash":"8e5b42ac9f6f86d8137ed39dd6f78eacd6fcb2d450930fc1846b1435f827726d","query_id":"0e430d1582da","seq":396,"ts":1791409155.7142403,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"5516c3f0f0a589e7c62b315ed61273be0bd322d6b840dfbecec495da0a6d418c","iso":"2026-10-07T21:39:15","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"f73205b9df2d22357ec7c97811e8514ed6aed136a464e5442b481ce3ee9e6b7e","query_id":"0e430d1582da","seq":397,"ts":1791409155.7203276,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"503c25016effe5325234b03202ada0917fe7c5857e2f2b573e8900f4bd145c84","iso":"2026-10-07T21:39:16","payload":{"date":"","holiday_weekday":"","hours":8.0,"pay_type":"overtime","source":"claude","subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"years_of_service":0.0},"prev_hash":"5516c3f0f0a589e7c62b315ed61273be0bd322d6b840dfbecec495da0a6d418c","query_id":"0e430d1582da","seq":398,"ts":1791409156.8091848,"type":"llm.parse_intent"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"efb66607fa56e6bc472953dc09af1a518c56e58a3d9e95c2c938942e61459fe4","iso":"2026-10-07T21:39:16","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"named in the question","id":"roster:Fire Marshal (top step)","label":"Fire Marshal (top step)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":13},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"subject","rejected":[{"id":"roster:Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Firefighter, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Firefighter/Paramedic, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Firefighter/Paramedic, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Fire Captain, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Fire Captain, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","label":"Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Apparatus Technician, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Division Chief (top step)","label":"Division Chief (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Division Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=chief-officers not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Analyst (top step)","label":"Administrative Analyst (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Analyst, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Assistant (top step)","label":"Administrative Assistant (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Assistant, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Inspector (top step)","label":"Fire Inspector (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Inspector, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"}]},"prev_hash":"503c25016effe5325234b03202ada0917fe7c5857e2f2b573e8900f4bd145c84","query_id":"0e430d1582da","seq":399,"ts":1791409156.815822,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"009eec9c95f2ceb3e81eb7a9681301f7a339c1208ced7b9aed46369a78471401","iso":"2026-10-07T21:39:16","payload":{"adapter":"csv","bargaining_units":["management"],"data_sha256":"1cfcfdfed61c7a854330452d40bff756dfc9645a4bca55fb715821ba59bff2a4","fields":["classification","department","rank","base_hourly","shift","bargaining_unit","name"],"records":[{"bargaining_unit":"management","base_hourly":108.59,"classification":"Fire Marshal (top step)","department":"fire","name":"Fire Marshal (top step)","rank":"Fire Marshal","shift":"Day"}],"rows":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"shift_date":null},"prev_hash":"efb66607fa56e6bc472953dc09af1a518c56e58a3d9e95c2c938942e61459fe4","query_id":"0e430d1582da","seq":400,"ts":1791409156.822609,"type":"data.read"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"3eeeeb6916dd9d29cff5c673a0dd4576e99f09f45e7fed57a66e2a7acc4b284b","iso":"2026-10-07T21:39:16","payload":{"checks":[{"agree":true,"deterministic":8.0,"field":"hours","model":8.0},{"agree":true,"deterministic":"overtime","field":"pay_type","model":null}],"date_iso":null,"date_note":"no date given","hours":8.0,"parsed_via":"claude","pay_type":"overtime","read_as":"8 h \u00b7 overtime \u00b7 Fire Marshal (top step) \u00b7 no date given","subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"years_note":null,"years_of_service":null},"prev_hash":"009eec9c95f2ceb3e81eb7a9681301f7a339c1208ced7b9aed46369a78471401","query_id":"0e430d1582da","seq":401,"ts":1791409156.8339205,"type":"chat.interpretation"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"44cd3af8b097789ef5eb0e7c848435ceabe8b0d5599b78349c7eb915b8267ea9","iso":"2026-10-07T21:39:16","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"management","date":null,"matched":[{"bargaining_unit":"management","doc_id":"management_mou","effective_end":"2026-12-31","effective_start":"2024-01-01","mou_version":"MGMT-2024","why":"unit 'management' matches; no date given; unit match only"}],"reason":"resolved by governance: units ['management'] + date None -> MOU(s) ['management_mou']","resolved":true,"subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"units":["management"]},"prev_hash":"3eeeeb6916dd9d29cff5c673a0dd4576e99f09f45e7fed57a66e2a7acc4b284b","query_id":"0e430d1582da","seq":402,"ts":1791409156.843661,"type":"governance.resolve"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"81916e79dc9abd64fd2598f0ac3abfc22204d2f69bc07e44b73b87db2b61f937","iso":"2026-10-07T21:39:16","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"unit 'management' matches; no date given; unit match only","id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"date":null,"subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"unit":"management"},"fork":"governance","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule)","reason":"unit firefighters-local-3535 \u2260 management"},{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters)","reason":"unit admin-group \u2260 management"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028","reason":"unit chief-officers \u2260 management"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)","reason":"doc_type salary-schedule is not an MOU or amendment"}]},"prev_hash":"44cd3af8b097789ef5eb0e7c848435ceabe8b0d5599b78349c7eb915b8267ea9","query_id":"0e430d1582da","seq":403,"ts":1791409156.8496895,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"c95ccd8284575cf618b81854d1e1da6f5618a450288bbfbb0414ecc83696c4e7","iso":"2026-10-07T21:39:16","payload":{"approved_topics":[],"bargaining_unit":"management","doc":["management_mou"],"reason":"Not covered \u2014 Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter) has no approved rule","stale":[],"status":"no_rules","subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"]},"prev_hash":"81916e79dc9abd64fd2598f0ac3abfc22204d2f69bc07e44b73b87db2b61f937","query_id":"0e430d1582da","seq":404,"ts":1791409156.855377,"type":"costing.uncovered"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"14f599761d7bad65115e6a3ba812d430c229fab21a0d0ace3d4360be32e1aba6","iso":"2026-10-07T21:39:16","payload":{"doc":["management_mou"],"error":null,"per_unit":[{"bargaining_unit":"management","reason":"Not covered \u2014 Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter) has no approved rule","status":"no_rules"}],"reason":"no ratified rules","stale":[],"units":["management"]},"prev_hash":"c95ccd8284575cf618b81854d1e1da6f5618a450288bbfbb0414ecc83696c4e7","query_id":"0e430d1582da","seq":405,"ts":1791409156.8605108,"type":"costing.blocked"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"e8b3ba203a7e5d0c1fbe51699975bd26b6c36d863d2e87af791fe18e95e79ce1","iso":"2026-10-07T21:39:16","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":375,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":713,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":929,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"14f599761d7bad65115e6a3ba812d430c229fab21a0d0ace3d4360be32e1aba6","query_id":"0e430d1582da","seq":406,"ts":1791409156.8681982,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"9ea19685280c864ad235ca1cf83d051b00df628af167c6baf89c452b188b7988","iso":"2026-10-07T21:39:16","payload":{"fn":"parse_intent","input_tokens":415,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1077,"output_tokens":69,"prompt_chars":992,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"e8b3ba203a7e5d0c1fbe51699975bd26b6c36d863d2e87af791fe18e95e79ce1","query_id":"0e430d1582da","seq":407,"ts":1791409156.8749378,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"admin","alg":"sha256","hash":"1f13a3d1be97105289a1a8d8ec6cc0162a7927e1f431510ec433a2b167e08e19","iso":"2026-10-07T21:43:29","payload":{"caught":0,"rule_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:bc_40hour_admin_holiday_leave","survivors":["compute: 40 -> 41","compute: 40 -> 39","drop condition: when subject_rank == 'Battalion Chief' and subject_shift == 'Day' -> True","drop condition: subject_rank == 'Battalion Chief' (keep subject_shift == 'Day')","drop condition: subject_shift == 'Day' (keep subject_rank == 'Battalion Chief')","invert condition: not (subject_rank == 'Battalion Chief' and subject_shift == 'Day')","swap classification: subject_rank 'Battalion Chief' -> 'Division Chief'","swap classification: subject_shift 'Day' -> 'Suppression'","re-home to another unit's contract: admin_group_mou"],"total":9,"verdict":"not actually tested"},"prev_hash":"9ea19685280c864ad235ca1cf83d051b00df628af167c6baf89c452b188b7988","query_id":null,"seq":408,"ts":1791409409.1881428,"type":"authoring.mutation_check"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"4b668159bdd0eadd25c07de840d869d1837d081ee2de7ed37b0bcf3cc5faa37c","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:37","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"How is premium overtime compensated under the Firefighters Local 3535 MOU?"},"prev_hash":"1f13a3d1be97105289a1a8d8ec6cc0162a7927e1f431510ec433a2b167e08e19","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":409,"ts":1792789117.4860697,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"1a52832ee7c2f22149a867ef702ac0d018350b7e1c452f8e662903cad5e3c968","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:38","payload":{"intent":"policy"},"prev_hash":"4b668159bdd0eadd25c07de840d869d1837d081ee2de7ed37b0bcf3cc5faa37c","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":410,"ts":1792789118.3042035,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"3d0705a964322886fa8e1d5bebef67ef4f5e1645d071ea560a6f10a90f291ceb","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:38","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"1a52832ee7c2f22149a867ef702ac0d018350b7e1c452f8e662903cad5e3c968","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":411,"ts":1792789118.325335,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"a26ad724eb613856f62201e00cc5ce53c626eaf0597966ea3a4ea02392cc35be","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:38","payload":{"bargaining_units":[],"department":null,"known_departments":["admin","district","fire","management"],"named_docs":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"scope_how":"document","stated":false},"prev_hash":"3d0705a964322886fa8e1d5bebef67ef4f5e1645d071ea560a6f10a90f291ceb","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":412,"ts":1792789118.346459,"type":"policy.department"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"2a2561f0089bff49c255e9e1b29cbd0ff272333749ab5f46f5f3bcbe67cca014","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:38","payload":{"candidate_docs":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"corpus_size":5,"declared":5,"department":null,"scope_how":"document"},"prev_hash":"a26ad724eb613856f62201e00cc5ce53c626eaf0597966ea3a4ea02392cc35be","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":413,"ts":1792789118.3727505,"type":"retrieval.candidates"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"22bbf4e71ddb05afd29713258f41261e0a1ce05b36a62b5d36df80837b2f1540","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:38","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"in scope by document","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"department":null,"how":"document","named":["firefighters_local3535_mou"]},"fork":"document_scope","rejected":[{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"},{"id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU","reason":"not the document the question named"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule","reason":"not the document the question named"}]},"prev_hash":"2a2561f0089bff49c255e9e1b29cbd0ff272333749ab5f46f5f3bcbe67cca014","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":414,"ts":1792789118.3854692,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"5df0bbb9232e465824133b18a8674dcc37f5bfcad6b380a018cf25d744290865","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:38","payload":{"hits":[{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":"firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","score":0.0331},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.032},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0315},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0313},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0312},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":17,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0299},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0292},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":16,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0286}],"query":"premium overtime compensated"},"prev_hash":"22bbf4e71ddb05afd29713258f41261e0a1ce05b36a62b5d36df80837b2f1540","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":415,"ts":1792789118.721805,"type":"retrieval.hits"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"874009ef5adb827a801bf66894b9e3cf23c69c4149b37227e6a934615bae6ec9","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:38","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"rank 1, pinned by firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:1","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the r\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee'"},"value":0.0331},{"detail":"rank 2","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:2","label":"p.8 \u00b7 An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime \u2026","ref":{"bbox":[142.13802712,655.8666107990399,513.7099673408001,552.4045199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"An employee who works overtime will be compensated for those overtime hours ata rate of one- and one-half times the empl"},"value":0.032},{"detail":"rank 3","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:3","label":"p.8 \u00b7 3. Overtime Rate","ref":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"3. Overtime Rate"},"value":0.0315},{"detail":"rank 4","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:7:4","label":"p.7 \u00b7 B. OVERTIME","ref":{"bbox":[126.36,500.34671999999995,189.45993787200004,492.01128],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"text":"B. OVERTIME"},"value":0.0313},{"detail":"rank 5","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:5","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Incremen\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[141.4304564,423.66664719936,469.2488398472001,414.05279314036005],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Overtime compensation shall  be accumulated in  one-half hour Increments."},"value":0.0312},{"detail":"rank 6","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:17:6","label":"p.17 \u00b7 Upon activation from standby status to duty status because of District\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[109.08,259.254,499.680126,209.23775999999998],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":17,"text":"Upon activation from standby status to duty status because of District need, stand by pay ends and the employee Is compe"},"value":0.0299},{"detail":"rank 7","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:14:7","label":"p.14 \u00b7 \u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[142.56,680.53824,492.481209024,644.9245199999999],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":14,"text":"\u00a2 The 40 Hour Safety Employee will  be eligible to take a  callback to the highest level eligible.  Overtime earned on  "},"value":0.0292},{"detail":"rank 8","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:16:8","label":"p.16 \u00b7 If an  employee Is assigned  Duty Coverage, they will be compensated $\u2026","ref":{"bbox":[110.88,168.894,493.19975700000003,146.32452],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":16,"text":"If an  employee Is assigned  Duty Coverage, they will be compensated $550/week for the assignment."},"value":0.0286}],"counts":{"chosen":8,"considered":14,"scope_docs":1,"searched":14},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"coverage":0.71,"query":"premium overtime compensated","scope":["firefighters_local3535_mou"]},"fork":"clause_retrieval","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:7:9","label":"p.7 \u00b7 Central  Fire  District has established a  24-day work periad and ther\u2026","reason":"rank 9 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[142.92,352.32552,516.239910504,247.22426706912006],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"text":"Central  Fire  District has established a  24-day work periad and therefore employees are entitled to FLSA-overtime for "},"value":0.0285},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:6:10","label":"p.6 \u00b7 Those employees required to work out of class (upward) shall be compen\u2026","reason":"rank 10 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[144.0,229.20551999999998,523.4385373712377,96.29728],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":6,"text":"Those employees required to work out of class (upward) shall be compensated at the same rate of pay that they would rece"},"value":0.0281},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:8:11","label":"p.8 \u00b7 Bargaining-unit employees are eligible to receive earned overtime in t\u2026","reason":"rank 11 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[141.07002260000002,367.50661079904,495.7171106528,331.99775999999997],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8,"text":"Bargaining-unit employees are eligible to receive earned overtime in the form of compensatory time off. The maximum accu"},"value":0.0278},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:7:12","label":"p.7 \u00b7 Employees who work in a  higher class in  an acting position or tempor\u2026","reason":"rank 12 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[138.5527723617,678.4012799999999,505.082966544,573.2975057002689],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7,"text":"Employees who work in a  higher class in  an acting position or temporary upgrade _assignment shall  have.any Out of Cla"},"value":0.0277},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:26:13","label":"p.26 \u00b7 Central  Legacy employees that retired on or before December 314,  202\u2026","reason":"rank 13 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[125.64,560.29824,495.720142884,510.91776],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":26,"text":"Central  Legacy employees that retired on or before December 314,  2021, witha minimum of 20 years of service to the Dis"},"value":0.0264},{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:23:14","label":"p.23 \u00b7 When a  bargaining unit member has received the appropriate approval t\u2026","reason":"rank 14 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[105.12,261.13816058112,503.639548416,170.44452],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":23,"text":"When a  bargaining unit member has received the appropriate approval to be absent from their scheduled shift(s) to atten"},"value":0.0253}]},"prev_hash":"5df0bbb9232e465824133b18a8674dcc37f5bfcad6b380a018cf25d744290865","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":416,"ts":1792789118.7295685,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"17ec9ac288a00c699c396920a30e9b2068ed0f0513a6971f2cd5ca21a93e2636","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:42","payload":{"answer":"Quoted from p.8: Employees shall  be entitled to premium overtime compensation at the rate of one and one  half (1,5) times the employee's 'regular rate of pay', as that term is defined under the  FLSA,  for all  the time worked or deemed to have been worked in excess of 182 hours In  a  24-day work period.  For the purpose of determining overtime, the words 'deemed to have been worked' shall  include all paid  le","coverage":0.71,"docs_used":["firefighters_local3535_mou"],"lookup":false,"pinned":["firefighters_local3535_mou:overtime_premium_rate"],"scope_how":"document","source":"guarded"},"prev_hash":"874009ef5adb827a801bf66894b9e3cf23c69c4149b37227e6a934615bae6ec9","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":417,"ts":1792789122.8942327,"type":"policy.answer"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"d0633976e62dcec6151d9c05840bd8730421d1bf2d259522bd732fad0e8e6163","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:42","payload":{"bbox":[141.41802712,505.66236583536,511.18157728959994,441.458790767472],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8},"prev_hash":"17ec9ac288a00c699c396920a30e9b2068ed0f0513a6971f2cd5ca21a93e2636","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":418,"ts":1792789122.9452164,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"1be743cc89cf2b4379a218578ea6b26130b8c7f1edeaad284a923daa478fb5f5","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:42","payload":{"bbox":[142.13802712,655.8666107990399,513.7099673408001,552.4045199999999],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8},"prev_hash":"d0633976e62dcec6151d9c05840bd8730421d1bf2d259522bd732fad0e8e6163","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":419,"ts":1792789122.9749746,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"a0fb2846fb9a161daf9bc7af4579f4aed33f5638ea45e3c9d157bec3df49e0c1","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:42","payload":{"bbox":[142.2,532.3867200000001,223.20069696000002,524.41128],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":8},"prev_hash":"1be743cc89cf2b4379a218578ea6b26130b8c7f1edeaad284a923daa478fb5f5","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":420,"ts":1792789122.990786,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"36715720cae3d0d176f031e357a46c3ef1abc810efe20a3ee804e7b44bcc4d68","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:43","payload":{"bbox":[126.36,500.34671999999995,189.45993787200004,492.01128],"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":7},"prev_hash":"a0fb2846fb9a161daf9bc7af4579f4aed33f5638ea45e3c9d157bec3df49e0c1","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":421,"ts":1792789123.0017397,"type":"citation"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"0722c4a1cdd795bec8d26b7c15c0cfc21449f95cf54ead1ca50e4ff93438cec5","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:43","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":375,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":793,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":944,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"36715720cae3d0d176f031e357a46c3ef1abc810efe20a3ee804e7b44bcc4d68","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":422,"ts":1792789123.6048648,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"ad59e9e27a646dbf61f07d4a3a6a9e2bd458d313f6b118ed5995996dfd90b10d","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:43","payload":{"fn":"answer_policy","input_tokens":815,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":4153,"output_tokens":377,"prompt_chars":2246,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"0722c4a1cdd795bec8d26b7c15c0cfc21449f95cf54ead1ca50e4ff93438cec5","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":423,"ts":1792789123.6200135,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"65bc0d355987aa27fc5f387ba9622c28456c4d1b79c2c4c064f9be624acc09e2","iso":"2026-10-23T20:58:43","payload":{"fn":"answer_policy","rule":"ground-check: model figure(s) not in retrieved clauses","source":"fallback","unverified_figures":["1.5","3535"]},"prev_hash":"ad59e9e27a646dbf61f07d4a3a6a9e2bd458d313f6b118ed5995996dfd90b10d","query_id":"a280505d6e03","seq":424,"ts":1792789123.6420066,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"d0f29b25559eb4dc0a922569590ba2cc94257e254c05c4604f96ecfabfc6b9a8","iso":"2026-10-26T00:23:56","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"Cost an 8-hour overtime shift for a Fire Marshal (top step)"},"prev_hash":"65bc0d355987aa27fc5f387ba9622c28456c4d1b79c2c4c064f9be624acc09e2","query_id":"09e8102a2d03","seq":425,"ts":1792974236.0464969,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"9264542467f823ee9ca86b95a93a3639c28814645149d3189b67fbddaba4f986","iso":"2026-10-26T00:23:56","payload":{"intent":"costing"},"prev_hash":"d0f29b25559eb4dc0a922569590ba2cc94257e254c05c4604f96ecfabfc6b9a8","query_id":"09e8102a2d03","seq":426,"ts":1792974236.9389238,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"3ad9888288040af06d272326e0920d997f5dd68bf8e657f06e3d5e810a3f077a","iso":"2026-10-26T00:23:56","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"9264542467f823ee9ca86b95a93a3639c28814645149d3189b67fbddaba4f986","query_id":"09e8102a2d03","seq":427,"ts":1792974236.9474974,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"6e069ae6b2dd0b81c656565b830c087920632f111769e34f845dd25f7adcfd7a","iso":"2026-10-26T00:23:58","payload":{"date":"","holiday_weekday":"","hours":8.0,"pay_type":"overtime","source":"claude","subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"years_of_service":0.0},"prev_hash":"3ad9888288040af06d272326e0920d997f5dd68bf8e657f06e3d5e810a3f077a","query_id":"09e8102a2d03","seq":428,"ts":1792974238.1973417,"type":"llm.parse_intent"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"db71de57bee67936f22a6a8b24efa13cad71ec458b301cda50eb82c83466e807","iso":"2026-10-26T00:23:58","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"named in the question","id":"roster:Fire Marshal (top step)","label":"Fire Marshal (top step)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":13},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"subject","rejected":[{"id":"roster:Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Firefighter, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Firefighter/Paramedic, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","label":"Firefighter/Paramedic (56 hr, entry step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Firefighter/Paramedic, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Fire Captain, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","label":"Fire Captain (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Fire Captain, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","label":"Fire Apparatus Technician (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Apparatus Technician, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (56 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Suppression, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","label":"Battalion Chief (40 hr top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Battalion Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=firefighters-local-3535 not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Division Chief (top step)","label":"Division Chief (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; rank=Division Chief, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=chief-officers not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Analyst (top step)","label":"Administrative Analyst (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Analyst, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Administrative Assistant (top step)","label":"Administrative Assistant (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Administrative Assistant, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"},{"id":"roster:Fire Inspector (top step)","label":"Fire Inspector (top step)","reason":"label not mentioned; department=admin, rank=Fire Inspector, shift=Day, bargaining_unit=admin-group not mentioned"}]},"prev_hash":"6e069ae6b2dd0b81c656565b830c087920632f111769e34f845dd25f7adcfd7a","query_id":"09e8102a2d03","seq":429,"ts":1792974238.8692129,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"58ab760f74ee2ca11fd88a751a1c2986ff1af3d057e681d47e1ee69ccc314bd0","iso":"2026-10-26T00:23:58","payload":{"adapter":"csv","bargaining_units":["management"],"data_sha256":"1cfcfdfed61c7a854330452d40bff756dfc9645a4bca55fb715821ba59bff2a4","fields":["classification","department","rank","base_hourly","shift","bargaining_unit","name"],"records":[{"bargaining_unit":"management","base_hourly":108.59,"classification":"Fire Marshal (top step)","department":"fire","name":"Fire Marshal (top step)","rank":"Fire Marshal","shift":"Day"}],"rows":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"shift_date":null},"prev_hash":"db71de57bee67936f22a6a8b24efa13cad71ec458b301cda50eb82c83466e807","query_id":"09e8102a2d03","seq":430,"ts":1792974238.899275,"type":"data.read"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"7d18ac7748fc097705dd5b827df16a8acf3b9702dd2c20719503c8b10321c2f9","iso":"2026-10-26T00:23:58","payload":{"checks":[{"agree":true,"deterministic":8.0,"field":"hours","model":8.0},{"agree":true,"deterministic":"overtime","field":"pay_type","model":null}],"date_iso":null,"date_note":"no date given","hours":8.0,"parsed_via":"claude","pay_type":"overtime","read_as":"8 h \u00b7 overtime \u00b7 Fire Marshal (top step) \u00b7 no date given","subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"years_note":null,"years_of_service":null},"prev_hash":"58ab760f74ee2ca11fd88a751a1c2986ff1af3d057e681d47e1ee69ccc314bd0","query_id":"09e8102a2d03","seq":431,"ts":1792974238.9093175,"type":"chat.interpretation"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"011b7f7704bded8c62ab81ce9a94d193e715260ef2b2187e6e097254355cec16","iso":"2026-10-26T00:23:58","payload":{"bargaining_unit":"management","date":null,"matched":[{"bargaining_unit":"management","doc_id":"management_mou","effective_end":"2026-12-31","effective_start":"2024-01-01","mou_version":"MGMT-2024","why":"unit 'management' matches; no date given; unit match only"}],"reason":"resolved by governance: units ['management'] + date None -> MOU(s) ['management_mou']","resolved":true,"subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"units":["management"]},"prev_hash":"7d18ac7748fc097705dd5b827df16a8acf3b9702dd2c20719503c8b10321c2f9","query_id":"09e8102a2d03","seq":432,"ts":1792974238.9267328,"type":"governance.resolve"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"d4d845ae3627666d0d807e108028f69c37302242f96aab6d11a37b95d1806b4e","iso":"2026-10-26T00:23:58","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"unit 'management' matches; no date given; unit match only","id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter)"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"date":null,"subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"],"unit":"management"},"fork":"governance","rejected":[{"id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU 2025\u20132028 (with Salary Schedule)","reason":"unit firefighters-local-3535 \u2260 management"},{"id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU 2024\u20132026 (with three Side Letters)","reason":"unit admin-group \u2260 management"},{"id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU 2026\u20132028","reason":"unit chief-officers \u2260 management"},{"id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule (approved 2026-05-14)","reason":"doc_type salary-schedule is not an MOU or amendment"}]},"prev_hash":"011b7f7704bded8c62ab81ce9a94d193e715260ef2b2187e6e097254355cec16","query_id":"09e8102a2d03","seq":433,"ts":1792974238.9426212,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"2cb99bce0b175343fef5a2f34a51bc5d90f61cfbe51d9ad9aecee82c87db2ebe","iso":"2026-10-26T00:23:58","payload":{"approved_topics":[],"bargaining_unit":"management","doc":["management_mou"],"reason":"Not covered \u2014 Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter) has no approved rule","stale":[],"status":"no_rules","subjects":["Fire Marshal (top step)"]},"prev_hash":"d4d845ae3627666d0d807e108028f69c37302242f96aab6d11a37b95d1806b4e","query_id":"09e8102a2d03","seq":434,"ts":1792974238.9561195,"type":"costing.uncovered"}
{"actor":"engine","alg":"sha256","hash":"d6e5439ec0efa9386888bba745c57e462704fa1f620dbd6fbf7fb6919b61aff5","iso":"2026-10-26T00:23:58","payload":{"doc":["management_mou"],"error":null,"per_unit":[{"bargaining_unit":"management","reason":"Not covered \u2014 Management MOU 2024\u20132026 (with Side Letter) has no approved rule","status":"no_rules"}],"reason":"no ratified rules","stale":[],"units":["management"]},"prev_hash":"2cb99bce0b175343fef5a2f34a51bc5d90f61cfbe51d9ad9aecee82c87db2ebe","query_id":"09e8102a2d03","seq":435,"ts":1792974238.9700508,"type":"costing.blocked"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"8b8bf4ae58319a240bcd379e417809ad88b7cd68a288c37403fd50750f1f9097","iso":"2026-10-26T00:23:58","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":375,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":881,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":929,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"d6e5439ec0efa9386888bba745c57e462704fa1f620dbd6fbf7fb6919b61aff5","query_id":"09e8102a2d03","seq":436,"ts":1792974238.9948244,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"2ac0be1c9923474f35bb9f2526ee0657604e5ce5d9fac5720cfa7014da4f3658","iso":"2026-10-26T00:23:59","payload":{"fn":"parse_intent","input_tokens":415,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":1222,"output_tokens":69,"prompt_chars":992,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"8b8bf4ae58319a240bcd379e417809ad88b7cd68a288c37403fd50750f1f9097","query_id":"09e8102a2d03","seq":437,"ts":1792974239.0076928,"type":"llm.call"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"53f5b9ecfd75342ccf55a8ee5073d256b337f60f84f5b2abea0a5723c3a390c2","iso":"2026-10-26T00:24:13","payload":{"continues":null,"department":null,"doc_id":null,"text":"Hey kenny"},"prev_hash":"2ac0be1c9923474f35bb9f2526ee0657604e5ce5d9fac5720cfa7014da4f3658","query_id":"141e86c41b63","seq":438,"ts":1792974253.9887464,"type":"chat.prompt"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"7ae8c914ae9856b48c0e0d5d71c3843593b7f51591aa4ef88a5307e6784dc0dd","iso":"2026-10-26T00:24:14","payload":{"intent":"policy"},"prev_hash":"53f5b9ecfd75342ccf55a8ee5073d256b337f60f84f5b2abea0a5723c3a390c2","query_id":"141e86c41b63","seq":439,"ts":1792974254.6829262,"type":"intent.classify"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"20a1df591c6f531e2fdc93edd03fd09153a0bb5619a701f2eec0a0d8b679f184","iso":"2026-10-26T00:24:14","payload":{"chosen":[{"id":"policy","label":"what the contract says"}],"counts":{"chosen":1,"considered":4},"decided_by":"ai","fork":"intent","rejected":[{"id":"costing","label":"a cost to compute","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"lookup","label":"a published figure","reason":"not chosen by the model"},{"id":"entitlement","label":"a non-money entitlement","reason":"not chosen by the model"}]},"prev_hash":"7ae8c914ae9856b48c0e0d5d71c3843593b7f51591aa4ef88a5307e6784dc0dd","query_id":"141e86c41b63","seq":440,"ts":1792974254.6975694,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"b330eee0f2c22f02224f76f66b86885e4780a8a92f372d235d2ced8e149daba7","iso":"2026-10-26T00:24:14","payload":{"bargaining_units":[],"department":null,"known_departments":["admin","district","fire","management"],"named_docs":[],"scope_how":"corpus","stated":false},"prev_hash":"20a1df591c6f531e2fdc93edd03fd09153a0bb5619a701f2eec0a0d8b679f184","query_id":"141e86c41b63","seq":441,"ts":1792974254.7208486,"type":"policy.department"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"58a303188a0c221acdc0864fc092c965db27eeb056ccacb94ad6039eac07491e","iso":"2026-10-26T00:24:14","payload":{"candidate_docs":["firefighters_local3535_mou","admin_group_mou","management_mou","chief_officers_mou","master_salary_schedule"],"corpus_size":5,"declared":5,"department":null,"scope_how":"corpus"},"prev_hash":"b330eee0f2c22f02224f76f66b86885e4780a8a92f372d235d2ced8e149daba7","query_id":"141e86c41b63","seq":442,"ts":1792974254.7440114,"type":"retrieval.candidates"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"95c57be3083e15c6b45227ee4ba615a2ab0159d8c017d17305f61b4713b3865d","iso":"2026-10-26T00:24:14","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"in scope by corpus","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","label":"Firefighters Local 3535 MOU"},{"detail":"in scope by corpus","id":"admin_group_mou","label":"Admin Group MOU"},{"detail":"in scope by corpus","id":"management_mou","label":"Management MOU"},{"detail":"in scope by corpus","id":"chief_officers_mou","label":"Chief Officers Association MOU"},{"detail":"in scope by corpus","id":"master_salary_schedule","label":"Master Salary Schedule"}],"counts":{"chosen":5,"considered":5},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"department":null,"how":"corpus","named":[]},"fork":"document_scope","rejected":[]},"prev_hash":"58a303188a0c221acdc0864fc092c965db27eeb056ccacb94ad6039eac07491e","query_id":"141e86c41b63","seq":443,"ts":1792974254.752966,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"d38088dbe3a18380121f30208d3ecc256bba23dc4fe4528767cfd18c1e336c21","iso":"2026-10-26T00:24:15","payload":{"hits":[{"clause":"","doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":28,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0167},{"clause":"","doc_id":"chief_officers_mou","page":23,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0164},{"clause":"","doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":28,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0161},{"clause":"","doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":11,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0159},{"clause":"","doc_id":"management_mou","page":16,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0156},{"clause":"","doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":28,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0154},{"clause":"","doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":11,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0152},{"clause":"","doc_id":"chief_officers_mou","page":27,"pinned_by":null,"score":0.0149}],"query":"kenny"},"prev_hash":"95c57be3083e15c6b45227ee4ba615a2ab0159d8c017d17305f61b4713b3865d","query_id":"141e86c41b63","seq":444,"ts":1792974255.1483383,"type":"retrieval.hits"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"2a3b467a481d02308bcfdad3d35224f29d596013c63797e0ff91b0c6501fd02f","iso":"2026-10-26T00:24:15","payload":{"chosen":[{"detail":"rank 1; best coverage 0.00 < floor 0.4","id":"admin_group_mou:28:1","label":"p.28 \u00b7 Boks","ref":{"bbox":[103.68,351.77472,234.095920128,325.67328000000003],"doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":28,"text":"Boks"},"value":0.0167},{"detail":"rank 2; best coverage 0.00 < floor 0.4","id":"chief_officers_mou:23:2","label":"p.23 \u00b7 Y","ref":{"bbox":[368.5590006510417,630.3266092936198,372.5520833333333,626.7338663736979],"doc_id":"chief_officers_mou","page":23,"text":"Y"},"value":0.0164},{"detail":"rank 3; best coverage 0.00 < floor 0.4","id":"admin_group_mou:28:3","label":"p.28 \u00b7 Erin Schaefer","ref":{"bbox":[78.4801,319.71096,136.25273055600002,312.09804],"doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":28,"text":"Erin Schaefer"},"value":0.0161},{"detail":"rank 4; best coverage 0.00 < floor 0.4","id":"admin_group_mou:11:4","label":"p.11 \u00b7 Martin  Luther King  Jr","ref":{"bbox":[110.52,517.54248,212.04008676,509.20452],"doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":11,"text":"Martin  Luther King  Jr"},"value":0.0159},{"detail":"rank 5; best coverage 0.00 < floor 0.4","id":"management_mou:16:5","label":"p.16 \u00b7 ry  fA","ref":{"bbox":[420.78950299436,199.59021823600006,466.0179716838,195.10931341580795],"doc_id":"management_mou","page":16,"text":"ry  fA"},"value":0.0156},{"detail":"rank 6; best coverage 0.00 < floor 0.4","id":"admin_group_mou:28:6","label":"p.28 \u00b7 Lh  Mike Michael Hushaw, Board Chair","ref":{"bbox":[78.4801,238.71964439419594,211.06355971755997,203.37804000000006],"doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":28,"text":"Lh  Mike Michael Hushaw, Board Chair"},"value":0.0154},{"detail":"rank 7; best coverage 0.00 < floor 0.4","id":"firefighters_local3535_mou:11:7","label":"p.11 \u00b7 Truck Operator","ref":{"bbox":[108.0,471.82248000000004,176.948400816,463.48452000000003],"doc_id":"firefighters_local3535_mou","page":11,"text":"Truck Operator"},"value":0.0152},{"detail":"rank 8; best coverage 0.00 < floor 0.4","id":"chief_officers_mou:27:8","label":"p.27 \u00b7 Signatuy\u00e9","ref":{"bbox":[320.04,466.95888,370.08204192,453.18312000000003],"doc_id":"chief_officers_mou","page":27,"text":"Signatuy\u00e9"},"value":0.0149}],"counts":{"chosen":8,"considered":14,"scope_docs":5,"searched":14},"decided_by":"fixed-logic","detail":{"coverage":0.0,"query":"kenny","scope":["firefighters_local3535_mou","admin_group_mou","management_mou","chief_officers_mou","master_salary_schedule"]},"fork":"clause_retrieval","rejected":[{"id":"management_mou:10:9","label":"p.10 \u00b7 B. Retiree","reason":"rank 9 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[83.1602,222.6096,154.299114432,213.91776000000004],"doc_id":"management_mou","page":10,"text":"B. Retiree"},"value":0.0147},{"id":"management_mou:12:10","label":"p.12 \u00b7 B.  Retiree","reason":"rank 10 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[84.2398,333.4896,137.73774643200002,324.79776],"doc_id":"management_mou","page":12,"text":"B.  Retiree"},"value":0.0145},{"id":"admin_group_mou:14:11","label":"p.14 \u00b7 Retiree","reason":"rank 11 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[104.64805171548001,234.58309945120004,139.14423501912,225.86719937946407],"doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":14,"text":"Retiree"},"value":0.0143},{"id":"management_mou:13:12","label":"p.13 \u00b7 Retiree","reason":"rank 12 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[84.2398,544.0896,137.73774643200002,535.3977600000001],"doc_id":"management_mou","page":13,"text":"Retiree"},"value":0.0141},{"id":"admin_group_mou:30:13","label":"p.30 \u00b7 Michael  Hushaw, Board Chair","reason":"rank 13 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[87.4801,485.31095999999997,213.941750472,477.69804],"doc_id":"admin_group_mou","page":30,"text":"Michael  Hushaw, Board Chair"},"value":0.0139},{"id":"management_mou:18:14","label":"p.18 \u00b7 Michael  Hushaw, Board Chair","reason":"rank 14 > cutoff 8","ref":{"bbox":[77.7602,214.22339999999997,205.30175047199998,206.61804000000006],"doc_id":"management_mou","page":18,"text":"Michael  Hushaw, Board Chair"},"value":0.0137}]},"prev_hash":"d38088dbe3a18380121f30208d3ecc256bba23dc4fe4528767cfd18c1e336c21","query_id":"141e86c41b63","seq":445,"ts":1792974255.166719,"type":"decision"}
{"actor":"chat","alg":"sha256","hash":"348cd7ce327943d32dd57c66149f05c835c89d33e0a995c5ec56ada38d1a2ffc","iso":"2026-10-26T00:24:15","payload":{"coverage":0.0,"query":"kenny","reason":"below relevance floor"},"prev_hash":"2a3b467a481d02308bcfdad3d35224f29d596013c63797e0ff91b0c6501fd02f","query_id":"141e86c41b63","seq":446,"ts":1792974255.182382,"type":"policy.out_of_scope"}
{"actor":"llm","alg":"sha256","hash":"6d9366220c2ac2a053b1e3f11fd47ea162ea44a8d9a6ea3ab7a545a28eeb9239","iso":"2026-10-26T00:24:15","payload":{"fn":"classify_intent","input_tokens":354,"model":"claude-opus-4-8","ms":682,"output_tokens":12,"prompt_chars":879,"source":"claude","stop_reason":"end_turn"},"prev_hash":"348cd7ce327943d32dd57c66149f05c835c89d33e0a995c5ec56ada38d1a2ffc","query_id":"141e86c41b63","seq":447,"ts":1792974255.2281623,"type":"llm.call"}